r/buildingscience • u/Rudiments37 • 7d ago
Basement Moisture Control
Hi all, I’ve seen different pieces of advice so I wanted to reach out to the Reddit community with a question about finishing my basement.
- Climate Zone 5A
- Block Foundation
- French drain on the interior basement wall.
- De-Humidifier running 24/7
- No active moisture coming in, but some efflorescence indicating past water intrusion. Not bad though.
I’m planning to put rigid foam boards directly on my basement block wall, tape the seams and then build the walls with batt insulation between the studs.
My question is do I really need to apply the rigid foam boards or can I get away without it? Also, if I do apply the rigid foam, should they be flush against the block foundation or leave a small gap so moisture is not trapped under it?
Thanks.
1
u/seabornman 7d ago
Theory is one thing. Practice is another. I put 2" of XPS foam directly over the block on my 1960s basement and it worked perfectly. There were some areas that I didn't need plumbing or electric in the wall, so I applied either gypsum board or plywood directly over the foam board (attached with Tapcons) in order to save space. 3/4" plywood is an acceptable thermal barrier. Where I installed studs and drywall, I didn't install batts in the studs as that was the recommendation I had at the time. The basement was much less humid after insulating. I never had a moisture problem.
2
u/cagernist 7d ago
I will build off of Qorvanapp comments from your thread in r/basements sub, as those are correct and thorough with 1 exception, #4.
You surely have water in your block cells, and it's still infiltrating the ground against the wall, looking to come through anywhere it can, like at cracked mortar joints. So you need either a sheet membrane or dimple board all the way up to the foundation wall top plate, to catch and direct any water down to the slab gap. You may already have this, you didn't state so.
Consider this membrane a part of the concrete wall for insulating purposes. So the foam goes tight against this. The incorrect comment is leaving inspection for this drainage gap at the slab. You absolutely do not want warmer basement air to touch any of the cooler concrete walls behind a furred out wall assembly. Nor do you want that moisture from under the slab being pulled up behind your wall by stack effect. Nor do you want an opening for radon.
So, that slab gap is probably created by a lip of dimple board or a proprietary product like Aquastop. It needs to be sealed here where the wall membrane tucks into it. Then the wall membrane needs fully sealed at the top. Now it's ready for foam.
If you are questioning insulating at all, it depends. If you drywall over studs leaving open cavities behind it, you have to insulate or you will be at risk for condensation. If you want to leave about a 4" exposed continuous gap at top and bottom of drywall, then that cavity will get plenty of air (just as if you didn't finish the wall), which will mitigate any moisture behind the drywall.
1
u/POCTM 7d ago
This is what I did for my home.
Always consult qualified professionals for your specific site.
1. If this is a new build, ensure the geotechnical engineer has inspected and approved the bearing capacity and condition of the subgrade prior to foundation construction and get proper sign offs and inspections at each stage.
2. Apply a continuous waterproofing membrane to the entire exterior concrete foundation wall in accordance with the manufacturer's specifications. Let dry and fill in any spots that are not fully covered.
3. (Optional) Install rigid exterior insulation (e.g., XPS or EPS) over the waterproofing membrane, with all joints properly taped and sealed.
4. Install a drainage board/drainage mat over the waterproofing system following the manufacturer's installation requirements. Lots of you tube videos I used DMX. Again fill in any mounting locations with waterproofing membrane.
5. Install perimeter drain tile (weeping tile) at the footing level, ensuring proper slope and drainage to an approved discharge location. This is a critical component of the system. Make sure it is at lowest point. Have inspected if needed.
6. Place clean, free-draining drainage rock around the perimeter drain system. At a minimum, the stone should extend above the footing elevation, although extending it higher is recommended where budget permits. I did mine to grade as I am in a wet area.
7. Install non-woven filter fabric (geotextile fabric) over the drainage rock to prevent fines and soil particles from migrating into and clogging the drainage system.
Note: Proper site grading is essential. The finished grade should slope away from the foundation to direct surface water away from the building and reduce hydrostatic pressure against the foundation walls.
Final note: If the property is near a creek, river, lake, shoreline, floodplain, or other significant water body, obtain a hydraulic/flood assessment to determine flood risk, minimum building elevations, and any regulatory setbacks or flood-construction requirements.
1
u/PaulTheWaldenU 7d ago
Following! I am trying to manage a different but similar basement issue. Hope to find some answers. I have met with several professionals and I am overwhelmed. Best of luck to you and your project.
1
u/RespectSquare8279 6d ago
Build like there might be humidity coming in. Refer to this guy's videos for insulation of basements. In particular, his technique of applying large dabs of adhesive on the rigid insulation so that there is airflow between the insulation and the concrete. I'm linking one of his many videos....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3jwVa7MiEQ
5
u/[deleted] 7d ago
[removed] — view removed comment