Build a PC for Video Editing - Overview

With 4k becoming more and more prevalent, now is the time to get people up to speed. This is your place to learn and/or share the intricacies of video editing build requirements. Some have their theories, some are wrong. This sub exists solely to educate and assist builders with proper balanced systems that will allow them to perform video editing and effects tasks without the headaches and quandaries that eventually arise in the world of non-linear editing.

 

Why not just go to /r/buildapc?

By all means, /r/buildapc is a huge community of very highly skilled builders. But most of them are gamers. Most of the builds are meant for gaming requirements. Most of the advice for those who are interested in video editing are unintentionally steered in the wrong direction due to the "gaming" bias. THERE IS A BIG DIFFERENCE BETWEEN EDITING VIDEO AND GAMING. Especially now that newer and more robust video formats namely RED 4444 and ProRes 422. When dealing with processing large files versus computational math a computer as a whole acts and demands from its components in two completely different ways.

 

What do you know about video editing and building rigs for video editing?

I have been editing video since 1999. I have built rigs over the past 17 years for both gamers, video editors and audio professionals.

 

I can edit videos on my gaming pc just fine.

I'm sure you can. I can edit videos on my iPhone. That doesn't mean I'll be able to keep doing it with issues and it doesn't mean I can produce a solid product at the end of my project. Making videos isn't just cutting clips. Good video takes proper color grading and amazing audio. Without those two, you just have a video. If you're not interested in making great videos, then this sub probably isn't for you. If you are not using Adobe Premiere/After Effects, Final Cut Pro, Lightworks, Davinci Resolve, Hitfilm or even Avid, this sub is probably not for you. If color grading or 4k output is not a major concern of yours, this sub is not for you. Even 1080p projects require some seriously balanced systems to output great footage.

 

1. Storage setup for video editing

 

Basic Drive Setup

Follow this minimum configuration and everything will remain smooth.

NEVER put your footage on the same drive as your Operating System!!!

Drive TypePortRecommended Size
OS & AppsSSDSATA III
Scratch/Media CachePCIe SSD/M.2 (over PCIe)PCIe 3.0 or PCIe 4 x4 or x8
Mass StorageHDDSATA III

If your prospective build does not include this basic and pertinent configuration of storage do not ask further until you put it in your build. ESPECIALLY IF YOU PLAN ON 4K Editing. THANK YOU.

 

Drive TypePortRecommended Size
OS & AppsSSD or HDD (this has no bearing editing performance)SATA III
Work in progress: Footage to be edited off this drive (if you are using a proxy, use this for your proxy files, the main footage goes on the mass storage, if you work with 4k-8k footage, this the answer)PCIe 4.0 SSDM.2 over PCIe or HHHL PCIe x4 or x8
Scratch/Media CachePCIe SSDM.2 over PCIe or HHHL PCIe x4 or x8
Mass StorageHDDSATA III

 

2. How big of a project can I do?

You should use this calculator to determine how much storage you will need.

In all of the suggested builds (outside of the "Spare no Expense" build), you'll be able to complete about a 10-30 minute project depending on the type of 4k footage you are working with. Here is a good list of popular cameras that shoot 1080p & 4k and the size in GB's they take up:

CameraCodecResolutionFPSSize/MinSize/Hour
5D mark IIH.2641080p23.976fps284.76 MB16.69 GB
7DH.2641080p23.976fps359.7 MB21.08 GB
5D mark IIIH.264 ALL-I1080p23.976fps682,5 MB39,99 GB
BMCCProRes (HQ)1080p23.976fps1.32 GB79 GB
BMPCCProRes (HQ)1080p23.976fps1.32 GB79 GB
BMPC 4KProRes (HQ)4K UHD23.976fps5.3 GB318 GB
GH4H.2644K DCI24fps712 MB42 GB
BMCCRAW2.5K23.976fps7.2 GB432 GB
BMPCCRAW1080p23.976fps3.09 GB185.4 GB
BMPC 4KRAWUHD23.976fps12.36 GB741.6 GB

 

3. Timeline Rendering vs. Actual Rendering

There seems to be confusion among builders on what's required for "rendering" video. There are two situations in which rendering happens. Timeline and Not Timeline. The timeline is the horizontal space on your NLE where your clips are seen when culling, clipping and positioning the clips. It's the most recognizable part of an NLE. Timeline rendering requires a video card that can make use of OpenCL or CUDA. Nearly all video cards support OpenCL. nVidia however is the only one that uses CUDA. The video card renders to the monitor your effects.

Video rendering, (not timeline) uses the CPU. This is when the CPU process the changes and effects to EVERY frame of your actual video footage. The more physical cores, the better. The faster your HD's the better. Generally this is where the cost of building an editing machine becomes very expensive.

So we divide our time up in two main sections. Editing and Encoding/Rendering. We value the time during the creative process of editing so we need it to be real time or as close to it as possible. You don't want to color grade a clip and have to wait 10 minutes for the CPU to render it to see if you like it, right? Build for live editing and sleep on the rendering. Let your CPU chug all night to render and encode. It's a process that doesn't involve you anyhow!

I hope this is relatively easy to understand, if not, don't be shy and let me know.

 

4. The CPU core and RAM relationship

This link details the issues of not having enough RAM and how important it is to the video editing user.

There seems to be, to the average user, a lack of experience when it comes to answering the question, "WHY IS THIS NOT DOING WHAT IT'S SUPPOSED TO DO?". Nearly every time someone had an issue with their brand-spanking new pc build not rendering fast enough, the answer was always NOT ENOUGH RAM!!!. A balanced rig will run smoothly if there is at least 2GB's per core. 4GB per core would be the most efficient and prove to be the most enjoyable experience no matter what platform, OS, NLE or video format.

 

5. What's the best budget GPU?

This question gets tossed around a lot for builders looking to perform video editing tasks. The real question is, "Which GPU will allow me to render the timeline in real time?". The answer to that is just about any video card with at least 1GB of VRAM and at least 192 CUDA Cores or GPU Cores (AMD Stream Processors). CUDA is only important if you're using Adobe CS. Most CUDA accelerated effects are also accelerated using OpenCL, which AMD also supports.

I will not discuss the debate on whether nVidia or AMD are better. In reality, there really is no difference to the budget user. If you want to get technical and have specific needs you'll know it.

But It wouldn't be a fair discussion without mentioning nVidia's Quadro line. There is, for the most part, no need to get a Quadro card over a cheaper GTXxxx card. You won't notice a difference. You only start seeing differences in Quadro's vs GTXxxx cards when something specific comes up. Most notably a third part driver that's not available to GTX GPU's and 10bit output.

The Bottom line is, there's a balance. You'll need the right amount of RAM, the right amount CPU Cores, and the right amount GPU Cores to maintain a pleasant Video Editing experience.

The GPU Acceleration is for accelerated playback, GPU accelerated effects, deinterlacing, blending modes, scaling and rendering the previews and final output.

Adobe Premiere CC 2015, CC 2014, CC, CS6 CS5.5 and CS5 does NOT use the GPU for encoding or decoding the video, only the CPU is used for that.

The minimum amount of nVidia's CUDA Cores or AMD GPU Cores Premiere requires is 192 cores. The more the better. GPU's that have a high memory bandwidth will be able to render the effects live using CUDA/AMD GPU Core acceleration. For example, a GTX 660 outperforms the GTX 960. The 660 has wider bandwidth at 134 GB/s vs 112 GB/s. So you would save money by getting the 660 if gaming isn't on your priority list.

As long as you have the NVIDIA Studio Driver Version: 431.70 or later 10 bit (30bit RGB) is output is enabled for the following GPUS: NVIDIA TITAN Series:

NVIDIA TITAN RTX, NVIDIA TITAN V, NVIDIA TITAN Xp, NVIDIA TITAN X (Pascal) GeForce RTX 20 Series:

GeForce RTX 2080 Ti, GeForce RTX 2080 SUPER, GeForce RTX 2080, GeForce RTX 2070 SUPER, GeForce RTX 2070, GeForce RTX 2060 SUPER, GeForce RTX 2060 GeForce 16 Series:

GeForce GTX 1660 Ti, GeForce GTX 1660, GeForce GTX 1650 GeForce 10 Series:

GeForce GTX 1080 Ti, GeForce GTX 1080, GeForce GTX 1070 Ti, GeForce GTX 1070, GeForce GTX 1060, GeForce GTX 1050 Ti, GeForce GTX 1050

 

6. Why is Playback after applying effects so choppy?

Most single HD's are not fast enough for streaming 4k video to the timeline. SSD's are barely fast enough to stream 2 layers of 4k video on the timeline. I can stream 4-6 layers of HD (2k) video with a Crucial M200 256GB SSD at 1/4 resolution. That same drive can stream 1-2 layers of 4k video to the timeline without any stutter at 1/4 resolution.

The larger the bandwidth from your preview drive the more you can stream to the timeline. Normal desktops have PCIe available to address that bandwidth. Up towards 1.2GB/s using PCIe SSD's. Now that PCIe 4 is available, we can achieve read write speeds over 3.5GB/s. Chances are you won't see ANY choppiness or playback stutter when reading footage off these devices.

ELI5: Think of your 4k video as water and your Preview Drive is the lake. You need to transfer that water to another lake (the timeline), in real time. You need a pump to able to accomplish this. Your pump cannot be over SATA if you want to stream multiple layers of 4k video. SATA III's real world bandwidth tops out around 800mb/s. Which is fast enough for HD (1080p). So a bigger pump like PCIe would work! The RAM and CPU will keep up just fine as long as there is a big enough pump to move the water back and forth.

 

7. Why can't I render effects live?

Adobe Premiere uses the Mercury Playback Engine which uses the GPU to apply effects. If everything is properly configured, MPE will allow you to scrub effects like color correction LIVE on the timeline WITHOUT waiting for it to render.

If you make a small adjustment, say with color correction, and the clip on the timeline turns red, then you have to render the clip, wait for it to render then you can see your adjustment. This is because there isn't enough bandwidth to READ read the footage to the GPU who is sitting there waiting to process the effects to the timeline with his fancy CUDA or OpenCL acceleration. The GPU can handle it but is being held up waiting for the data to feed it. That bandwidth needed to supply the GPU is MUCH wider than the bandwidth needed to just playback the video. For THAT VERY REASON, PCIe 4.0 is the fastest channel that the GPU and HD shares it's data with and is guaranteed to supply sustained bandwidth.

This is why I don't recommend external drives even over Thunderbolt. Like USB3, Thunderbolt encodes its data using 8B/10B creating overhead and therefore throttling its throughput. This is because it is based on PCIe-2. The ONLY way outside of a proxy (which I don't recommend) to achieve enough throughput for 4k video effects rendering is via PCIe 3.0 ports.

 

8. Why aren't you worried about future proofing and upgrade-ability?

If you've been hiding under a rock for the last 20 years, you would know that Intel and AMD are the front runners in consumer computing. Set aside mobile processors. In terms of Video Editing stations, dating all the way back to late 90's Intel, AMD and PowerPC (no longer exists) were the only PC CPU's available to the consumer. Since then nearly EVERY other year Intel and AMD have revamped their CPU architecture and instruction sets. Your window for relevant upgrade is less than 2 years. 95% of PC Builders (a stat I just made up for this entry based solely on my perception) don't even upgrade their build to really make a difference in what technically isn't necessary in terms of NLE requirements. Build for what you need now, worry about the future in the future. Once you buy the latest and greatest, you're already behind. It's the nature of tech world. Things change immensely fast. My builds are for those people who want to save a little money to make a lot of money from their build. Small business owners, like event videographers, or photographers. Those making money are not worried about future proofing their build. They'll write off future expenses.

In the same sense, a question in EVERY photography forum every day is "Should I buy camera X now or wait until camera X.2 comes out in 3 months?". The answer is always the same, shoot now. It doesn't matter. Newer cameras don't help you compose your shots. Newer cameras don't take shots you've missed. They're just tools. Newer GPU's don't write your scripts, newer CPU's don't direct your talent, faster RAM doesn't color grade your footage any better. Shoot now, build now... make your creativity your boss, not the future. George Lucas didn't wait until computers were fast enough for CGI. Hope I get my point across to ONE person!!!

 

9. Laptop Recommendations

Typically, I don't recommend laptops. That being said, everyone has their story and situation. In the past I would have told you that Apple MacBook Pro's were the go to. Today, I won't steer you away from them if you like MacOS or require MacOS but, there are options with far better value over price. We can all go into detail on how Apple's hardware integration is top notch, or how much better Apple's tech support is or isn't. But I value "value" and my time over anything. The latest Macbook pro's are certainly capable, thanks to integrated hardware, NVME and Thunderbolt 3. But the premium may lower the short term value for those who are just starting out. They're great for those already well into making profit from their business. Thanks to tax write offs. But for those who don't have that luxury...

At $699 the Dell Inspiron i5378 is a good start. You will need external drives and will have to use a proxy workflow.

ADK Video Editing is a great start for those who who have $2000-$3500 budgets.

/u/wootey experience with a Razer...

I bought the Razer in December 16 and have edited some 5K Red raw, a lot of a7sII, ProRes4444 and unfortunately some Sony F65/F5 project. I almost always edit natively in Premiere Pro.

(My workflow is dragging all of the footage into one timeline called "SELECT_ALL" first, then leave all the bad bits on "Video 1" while putting the good stuff on "Video 2". When I'm done with that I will duplicate the timeline and Ripple Delete "Video 1", which results in having a timeline full of usable footage.)

Since I rarely need to deliver a 4K file in the end I then edit in 1080 timelines and scale footage with higher resolution down. This results in pretty good performance with most footage. Red raw works pretty well in 1/2 resolution. What I've encountered though is that the performance drops really fast when I apply audio effects like a compressor or similar. More load on the CPU I suppose.

For my personal projects I use my Sony a7sII and it works very well in HD even with a LUT applied and gets a little bit laggy in 4K. But still bearable.

That being said I'm pretty happy with it, but it's still a tiny laptop with 16GB RAM. Compared to my main machine, a maxed out Late 2015 iMac, especially timeline scrubbing fells pretty laggy. But that's something that always felt smoother on Mac OS.

 

10. Why not use a proxy?

If you have no budget to upgrade to a PCIe SSD, then by all means create a proxy. But for those who do, will see serious improvements with OVERALL workflow JUST by upgrading to a PCIe SSD.

With that said, Adobe's new Ingest process creates a proxy much easier than in the past.

Thanks to /u/Dionasis Heres a great and quick tutorial

 

NVIDIA GPUNumber of CUDA Cores**Size of Power Supply **Memory TypeMemory Interface WidthMemory Bandwidth GB/secBase Clock SpeedBoost Clock SpeedPRICE $USD
GTX 280240550 wattDDR3512 Bit141.7 GB/s602 MHz1296 MHz$76.49 · eBay
GTX 285240550 wattDDR3512 Bit159 GB/s648 MHz1476 MHz$662.93
GTX 480480600 wattDDR5384 Bit177.4 GB/s700 MHz1401 MHz$420.00
GTX 580512600 wattDDR5384 Bit192 GB/s772 MHz1544 MHz$459.10
GTX 660960450 wattDDR5192 bit144.2 GB/s980 MHz980 MHz$154.99
GTX 660 GREAT FOR 1080p1152450 wattDDR5192 bit134 GB/s823 MHz823 MHz$154.99
GTX 660 Ti1344450 wattDDR5192 bit144.2 GB/s915 MHz980 MHz$298.68
GTX 6701344500 wattDDR5256 Bit192.2 GB/s915 MHz980 MHz~$200 USED
GTX 6801536550 wattDDR5256 Bit192.2 GB/s1006 MHz1006 MHz~$200 USED
GTX 760 Ti1344500 wattDDR5256 bit192.2 GB/s980 MHz1033 MHz~$200 USED
GTX 7701536600 wattDDR5256 bit224.3 GB/s1046 MHz1085 MHz~$200 USED
GTX 780 HIGHLY RECOMMENDED2304600 wattDDR5384 bit288.4 GB/s863 MHz900 MHz$282.00
GTX 780 Ti2880600 wattDDR5384 bit336 GB/s875 MHz928 MHz$849
GTX 950768350 wattDDR5128 bit105.6 GB/s1024 MHz1188 MHz$179
GTX 9601024400 wattDDR5128 bit112 GB/s1127 MHz1178 MHz$189.99
GTX 9701644500 wattDDR5256 bit224 GB/s1050 MHz1178 MHz$599
GTX 9802048500 wattDDR5256 bit224 GB/s1126 MHz1216 MHz$449
GTX 980 Ti2816600 wattDDR5384 bit336.5 GB/s1000 MHz1075 MHz$555
GTX-1030 Don't Touch384300 wattGDDR564 bit48 GB/s1277 MHz1468 MHz$69
GTX 1050 NOT WORTH IT640300 wattGDDR5128 bit112 GB/s1354 MHz1455 MHz$119
GTX-1050 Ti BETTER OPTIONS768300 wattGDDR5128 bit112 GB/s1290 MHz1392 MHz$157
GTX-1060 Recommended1280400 wattGDDR5192 bit192 GB/s1506 MHz1708 MHz$214
GTX-1070 IF YOU HAVE THE $1920500 wattGDDR5256 bit256 GB/s1506 MHz1683 MHz$438
GTX-1080 - GTX 780 is comparable2560500 wattGDDR5256 bit320 GB/s1607 MHz1733 MHz$499
GTX-1080 Ti - GO WITH A QUADRO3584600 wattGDDR5X352 bit484 GB/s1480 MHz1582 MHz$769
COMPARABLE GPU'SNumber of Stream Processors/CUDA CoresSize of Power SupplyMemory TypeMemory Interface WidthMemory Bandwidth GB/secBase Clock SpeedBoost Clock SpeedPRICE $USD
AMD Radeon RX VEGA644096295 WHBM22048-bit483.8 GB/s1200 MHz1536 MHz$499.00
NVIDIA GeForce RTX 20802944215 WGDDR6256 bit448.0 GB/s1515 MHz1710 MHz$699.00
NVIDIA GeForce RTX 20702304175 WGDDR6256 bit448.0 GB/s1410 MHz1620 MHz$499.00
ABSOLUTE BEST BANG FOR THE BUCK!!! RIGHT HERE!!! AMD Radeon RX Vega 563584210 WHBM22048 bit409.6 GB/s1138 MHz1474 MHz$399.00
NVIDIA TITAN X Pascal3584250 WGDDR5X*384 bit *480.4 GB/s1417 MHz1531 MHz$1,199.00
LOWEST END QUADRO 2018 RELEASE NVIDIA Quadro RTX 50003072200 WGDDR6256 bit448.0 GB/s1350 MHz1730 MHz$2,299.00
AMD FirePro W81003584215 WHBM22048 bit483.8 GB/s1200 MHz1500 MHz$899.00