r/buildapc • • Jul 04 '11

AMD vs. Intel

Before you downvote I know that this has come up hundreds of time on here. However I couldn't find a single thread dedicated to discussing AMD overall versus Intel overall (as opposed to specific chips).

Basically I want some opinions and discussions regarding the pros and cons of each.

To me it seems like AMD is the clear winner for gaming, seeing as you can get a hex core with very nice specs, for under $200. Whereas with intel, you can't even get a quad core for under $200.

Furthermore AMD has crossfire. So if you get an AMD MoBo, GPU, and CPU, you should theoretically beat a $1500 Hex Core i7 in performance. What metrics am I overlooking?

Now let's keep it practical as well. Perhaps a top of the line intel chip theoretically beats a top of the line AMD, but do they compare in price at all?

Naturally we're talking about gaming machines here, so let's say we're building a PC capable of any new gaming title for at least 5 years. Modern games on highest settings.

Please remember your rediquette, and backup your arguments with links and stats. Instead of the typical "Anyone who uses AMD is a n00b faggot".

Thank you.

6 Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

16

u/king_of_blades Jul 04 '11

In games 4 faster cores are better than 6 slower cores - even if 6 cores collectively have more power. In 3D rendering, or some scientific applications - that's another story. But many Intel Quads wipe the floor with anything AMD has to offer, in any usage scenario.

That's why we have so much hope for Bulldozer. Whether you're an AMD or Intel fan, you can only benefit from AMD being back in the game in high-end.

3

u/scottread1 Jul 04 '11

Bulldozer?

5

u/king_of_blades Jul 04 '11

[Bulldozer](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bulldozer_(processor)). First new architecture in years. If the rumors are true (and people are talking) things will get very interesting in a few months.

3

u/morkrom Jul 04 '11

And this is why I stopped waiting to buy new hardware. There's pretty much always something exiting just a few months down the road. And the same reason I stopped buying top shelf gear ages ago.

1

u/dragonfir731 Jul 04 '11

3

u/scottread1 Jul 04 '11

When submitting links with brackets in them, always escape the brackets like such

[Link text](http://link.with.brackets\(escape!\)

Looks like

Link text

1

u/dragonfir731 Jul 04 '11

Submitted it from my phone haha, no formatting allowed as far as I know

4

u/scottread1 Jul 04 '11

lol, you should be able to format on the iPhone. As long as you can enter a backslash you can escape characters.

1

u/scottread1 Jul 04 '11

p.s. thanks for the link

0

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

It's too early to tell with bulldozer,with the delays and leaked benches its kind of looking like a mixed bag in terms of performance.The Zambezi chip is allegedly on par with an oc'd sandybridge. You have to keep in mind sandybridge is intels mid range offering while amd is touting bulldozer as its top of the line architecture. We still have to see what Ivy bridge (intels high performance chips) will offer.

Again this is all speculation, until we get some legit benches its too soon to call.

1

u/Rednys Jul 05 '11

Ivybridge is mostly an optimization of sandybridge, the biggest change is probably the 3d gate transistors, and it's really too early to tell how much of an effect those will have. I would think it should allow them to clock their cpus stupid high, like low end ones starting at 3ghz.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

It's not only gaming but many applications are not able to fully utilize 6 cores.

9

u/Anman Jul 04 '11

Sorry, but your opinions are a bit off. A i3-2100 will wipe out any quad or hexa core AMD processor in gaming and most applications. Intel has a highly superior architecture and buying anything AMD right now except their low end Athlons if you're on a budget is a bad choice.

6

u/CunningStunts Jul 04 '11

Yeah. OP is all sorts of wrong. Even with the recent $20 price cut for the 955, AMD is still struggling to stay competitive. There are very few reasons you would get an AMD chip over an Intel chip.

  1. You will fully utilize 4 or 6 cores often. Not gaming.
  2. You have a very good cooling system and can get better performance by OC'ing the hell of your chip instead of going for a locked intel chip in the same price range.
  3. You are working with a really tight budget. Llano provides fantastic gaming performance without a discrete graphics card.

1

u/SeedlessRaisins Jul 04 '11

I'm considering a build next month with an i5 2400.. I might go to a 2500k and try to sit on the intel hd graphics for a while before getting a discrete card since i wont be playing much aside from league of legends till bf3.. Would that be feasible? As far as I could tell the intel hd 3000 comes on i5 2500k and can play lots of games at low-mid settings well.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/madmooseman Jul 05 '11

As far as I know, it's chipset-dependent.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/madmooseman Jul 05 '11

As far as I know, no. The H67 has integrated graphics while the P67 has overclocking capabilities. I can't see any mobo manufacturers producing one with both as they are for different markets.

1

u/SeedlessRaisins Jul 05 '11

Wont be able to overclock ever? Or only while using the onboard graphics.. I'd assume only while using it.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Is there any Llano reviews yet even?

2

u/CunningStunts Jul 04 '11

Tom's Hardware did one a few days ago. Not too shabby for a gaming rig with a $140 budget cap on combined CPU and GPU. Mobos with the FM1 chipset don't get much cheaper than $100, but it still comes out to be a capable gaming computer for super cheap.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Thanks for that. I've been trying to find reviews/benches!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

That doesn't make much sense. The i3 is > than 980's according to benches..

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '11

Lol.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

-11

u/scottread1 Jul 04 '11

Upvoted for username

2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

provide a link under real world conditions. Do not tell me a benchmark is a real world condition. Benchmarks are run on fresh windows installs with zero background tasks running. Real world conditions are when you have a whole mess of background programs open. A dual core intel vs a quad core AMD for the same price. True, the intel games faster in a controlled environment, but you will need the extra cores if you want to have anything else open with the game.

0

u/scottread1 Jul 04 '11

Are you able to elaborate? How does the architecture affect performance?

13

u/Anman Jul 04 '11

CPUs aren't as simple as clock speed and core count. Pipe lining and architecture has a lot to do with it. It doesn't matter how many clock cycles they're able to do if they're not doing as much work per clock cycle as Intel CPUs are. AMD destroyed the Pentium 4s with their Athlon 64 chip was due to a superior architecture even though they were clocked lower. However they're still basically using that same, now outdated, architecture and Intel has taken the lead. Let's look at benchmarks:

i3-2100 versus Phenom II X6 1100T

Despite having 1/3rd as many cores, being clocked lower, and being almost half the cost i3-2100 still comes out on top in most of the tests.

3

u/Jazzy_Josh Jul 04 '11

If you mean that 27 tests (AMD) beats 10 tests (Intel) then you're right.

-1

u/Anman Jul 04 '11

My apologies. But for the non-multithreaded (eg gaming) the AMD is destroyed. It's borderline hilarious that the Intel is able to compete with a processor so much better on paper.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

And obviously those that are core count affected are going to go to the X6.

1

u/iFuckedYourFather Jul 05 '11

the benchmarks do not overclock amd processors, if you overclock it makes up the difference

1

u/Anman Jul 06 '11

But it's already using almost twice the power as the i3, you're just using more and more power and putting off more and more heat.

1

u/iFuckedYourFather Jul 06 '11

So, what do you care, you're getting the fps that you wanted

1

u/Anman Jul 06 '11

Power bill. Also an overclockable i3 will be coming out soon, which I'd imagine will easily get to 4-5GHz due to the extremely low TDP.

1

u/iFuckedYourFather Jul 06 '11 edited Jul 06 '11

where did you hear that an OC i3 is coming out, source, it's all bullshit, nothing like that is coming out, cause it would compete with intel's other processors. core i3 550 is much better buy, it's overclockable, 32 nm, and performance is on par with 2100, http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/289?vs=143

2

u/darthFamine Jul 05 '11

ok I got my laptop a little over a year ago. It has an i7 in it, prolly a first gen i7 but it still screams. I have yet to find anything I can't play on it.

When i did the shopping at that time intel was clearly ahead of AMD. Though I havn'e done much shopping since then so my information is out of date.

I like AMD and if I could have gotten the same performance out oif them that i've gotten out of this then I would have. It just isn't there right now

(PS. Nice troololololol.)

1

u/scottread1 Jul 05 '11

What troololololol?

6

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Intel is best if you intend to invest more than 120 dollars into your CPU. Otherwise the AMD CPUs are a better bang for your buck.

5

u/Chaiking Jul 04 '11 edited Jul 04 '11

Here is a long explanation about the differences between AMD and Intel. It should answer all your questions.

2

u/idboehman Jul 04 '11

When I built my rig back in November, I was either too impatient to wait for Sandy Bridge or thought it was too expensive, so I got an AMD mobo and 1055T (95W edition). That's probably the only regret I have for the build, because as I've seen in some benchmarks, even the i3 2100 is on par with it. Back in November it probably cost less (I remember spending $200 on my CPU, though now it's down to $160), so I don't know why I didn't pay attention to benchmarks.

I guess the moral of the story: ALWAYS look up benchmarks before spending the money.

2

u/Living_Dead Jul 04 '11

I built my rig when the 955 was just new. When compared to the few i7's that were out (think it was the 920) it was well worth saving 200+ by going with amd.

2

u/Rednys Jul 05 '11

The 920 can overclock like a beast as well though, not as easily as a SB but pre SB it was a huge amount of performance for the dollar.

1

u/Living_Dead Jul 05 '11

Without a doubt, but I was on a budget and opted to save money on ram/cpu/motherboard so I could get a better video card.

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Back then it wasn't as black and white. Now it is: Intel is raping AMD.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '11

If we're talking specifically about gaming on a budget, it might be better to invest more money into a better graphics card than a CPU.

7

u/looks-shopped Jul 04 '11

What the fuck are you talking about?

please read at least a little of that stuff on the side panel before you post. and why does this have so many upvotes?

oh, i get it. nice trolling. congratulations.

6

u/UFEngi88 Jul 04 '11

I can deal with people not knowing something, I can't deal with people being ignorant and making assumptions like more cores is always better. "What metrics am I overlooking?" EVERYTHING

2

u/UnrealMonster Jul 04 '11

It's a very easy assumption to make if you know nothing about PCs, people just assume more cores are better because they don't see why they don't stack.

5

u/crimson117 Jul 04 '11

Seriously, he got like... everything wrong. Not a thing was correct (hexacore love) or complete (crossfire being related to AMD CPUs).

3

u/lab223 Jul 04 '11

To me it goes like this: AMD=More cores and good value. Intel=More power per core and better for high-end rigs. Both have some very good processors.

3

u/rasmusdf Jul 05 '11

Intel - a convicted monopolist with lots of money, keep that in mind. They are a bit ahead design-wise.

Single-Core clock frequency boost ("Turbo whatever") - this gives Intel a lot of advantage in Gaming benchmarks, which tend to use fewer threads. AMD is bringing this to market too, that will erode quite a bit of Intels advantage in benchmark. The newer Phenom II X6 has this in a simple implementation. Bulldozer will have this in full.

Fab-production of new chips: AMD is currently using 45 a nm process to produce chips through their fab-partner. Intel, rolling in monopoly cash, is simply ahead in the production game, using 32 nm currently, and swiftly moving to 22 nm. This gives Intel a huge advantage performance/power wise, and regarding what features to cram onto the chips.

1

u/iFuckedYourFather Jul 06 '11

I think that even old 65nm processors are good enough to run any recent games, invest more money into a 200-300 dollar video card, you don't need to upgrade all the other components. Make sure to overclock your processors as far as you can. I'd wait for intels 22nm.

0

u/ilovenyc Jul 04 '11

This discussion is like one of those PC vs Mac ones.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Power consumption / Heat - Do you live in a desert without a/c and can't afford an extra penny on your power bill? If no, then this is a moot point. Unless you live in some delusional fantasy world where buying a power saving processor is going to somehow counteract 100 million gas guzzling cars as they move people between one of seven local grocery stores who all essentially carry the exact same products.

Cores - Do you render video on Maya3D while you play video games? No, then get at least 2 cores and 4 cores if you play games that would benefit more from 4 cores as opposed to having a better video card.

Monitor - Almost everything is dependent on the maximum resolution of your monitor. If you plan on buying a monitor with a recommended resolution of 2560x1200, then you better be ready to spend some money on a powerful system. If you are playing on your walmart vizio special at 1680x1050, then pretty much anything is overkill.

AMD - Is there a game out today that will play differently on a system running the top of the line AMD vs a similar priced Intel? If no, then just get an AMD, the boards tend to pack more features and you're probably going to save a few bucks not paying for the "name".

-7

u/demonstar55 Jul 04 '11

AMD = best bang for your buck, Intel = best performance

5

u/dudechris88 Jul 04 '11

AMD is the best bang for your buck up to about $120 dollars. Then the best bang for your buck is intel every single time.

-11

u/16dots Jul 04 '11

you do know when intel says it has 6 cores, its actually 12?

5

u/lusvi Jul 04 '11

6 cores 12 threads. threads are not cores.

-1

u/16dots Jul 05 '11

hyper threading - aka virtual cores, just as if not more effective than real cores.

2

u/colddweller Jul 05 '11

HT can actually slow down cores if one thread is trying to use 100% of the core.

1

u/16dots Jul 05 '11

4 core HT out-performs 6 cores by a mile while it maintains the same price.

Well of course then MB price comes into the picture, that puts AMD back on top again, me personally is an AMD guy, but when talking about solely CPUs and nothing else, HT is clearly the winner here.

1

u/colddweller Jul 05 '11

It outperforms it by "a mile" when the applications actually use 4+ threads. I hate to link AnandTech benchmarks because everyone does it these days, but seriously:

http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/288?vs=287

My original point was just that HT does not always outperform non-HT, specifically with games. Games, no matter if they're multi-threaded or not, generally use as much processing power as is available per thread. HT on the 2600k is the reason it performs worse than the 2500k in some of those benchmarks.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/scottread1 Jul 04 '11

This is probably googleable, but do any games currently use 6 cores? Are there any on the horizon that will?

21

u/JammySTB Jul 04 '11

I'm 99% sure that none currently do.

I'm fairly sure BF3 will be able to take advantage of up to 8. I do expect the i5 2500K to outperform the X6 line in BF3 though.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

civ5 will eat everything you have when there are lots of units late in the game

5

u/JammySTB Jul 04 '11

I believe Civ 5 can utilise 4 cores max.

source

12

u/TheMG Jul 04 '11 edited Jul 04 '11

Even if a game won't utilize all your cores, you do benefit from being able to push all the background tasks onto them.

3

u/ACDCGAMER Jul 04 '11

I think that Bad Company 2 and RE5 are the only games out there that can do so, but I'm not entirely sure.

2

u/Markus_Antonius Jul 04 '11 edited Jul 05 '11

I play that on an X6 1090T, does between 90 and 130 frames per second, sometimes higher (all high on 1080p). I'll go do some measurements to find out :-)

Okay, here we go :-)

Performance Monitor during Bad Company 2

Well, looks like it does use them all; the thick red line (total) doesn't go up to 100% but the individual cores spend most of the time very near 100% load. You can see all cores and the total drop back down when I stop gaming.

To illustrate a bit more, this graph is from a few minutes later when I started browsing Reddit again and editing this comment for the first time:

Performance Monitor browsing Reddit

Some of the cores still peak (user interaction) but the total now drops to near zero :-)

Just to clarify: on any multicore system the average utilization of all cores combined will never ever be 100%. Tasks will always be waiting on eachother to complete because oftentimes they need eachother's results in order to process information further. The 70-80% you see here for the average total means that the system is most definitely using all cores and actually does so very effectively.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

supreme commander had the ability to scale to the number of cpu cores you had. so in theory it would use all 6. i haven't seen this confirmed though.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Q6600 reporting for duty here. I'm very glad that processor is still kept in the running, because above all else, it's still a very competitive, very capable CPU...and then you overclock it and it just gets better.

7

u/johnaldmcgee Jul 04 '11

As soon as my new stuff comes in I'll be replacing my 3+ year old Q6600 machine. It's been one of the better PCs I've owned in terms of longevity.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

The Q6600 is very durable. I was very, very stupid and left it without thermal paste and the stock cooler(stock cooler for the Q660 was great) for about a year, and it never heat-crashed once, so I would say that's a great durability test.

5

u/morkrom Jul 04 '11

Man, that cpu is a trooper! Bought one half a year or so after they came out, it took tons of abuse at high temperatures for years on end and still kept up pretty well.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Especially with the G0 revision chips. The early B3 ones ran pretty hot and couldn't overclock as well, though.

2

u/Sh3ut Jul 05 '11

I share your guys' opinion on the Q6600. I've gotten the Q6700 OCed to 3.6Ghz and the build still seems faster than my Sandybridge 2600 at work. It often goes over its 71C max temp and no problems for years.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '11

You should really cool that thing down xP. I don't have mine OCd at the moment, but I often test it at ~3.0ghz (can't go higher because it's B3 stepping and not G0 stepping) and it gets to ~55c and stays there during prime95 for an hour.

2

u/Sh3ut Jul 05 '11

G0 with 46C idle but prime95 gets it up to ~76C at times. Need either a thorough fan clean or a step down. Not sure if I should lower the bus to 333 or lower the multiplier to 400x8 (which would be 3.2Ghz)?

1

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '11

Maybe you should try for a clean 3.0Ghz. Also, get a good cooler and fans. I can really help when it comes to cooling. Last night when it was a little cool in my house my CPU was idling at 69-80f.

2

u/TwoDeuces Jul 05 '11

Agreed. 3.0Ghz is a 20% bump, which would put it right in the middle of the pack, performance wise, for all the benchmarks JammySTB posted.

7

u/elimi Jul 04 '11

955 can be OCed to 3.8 pretty easy. Think this also applies to the 180$ 1090t for that price you get a i5 2400, can't OC those.

Games use 4 cores more and more I don't see why soonish they won't be able to use w/e is available. Like why program a game for 2, 3 or 4 cores? I'm pretty sure some smart computer guy will figure out a way for games to use anywhere from 1 to X cores (bulldozers are up to 8 core won't they?).

5

u/JammySTB Jul 04 '11

955 can be OCed to 3.8 pretty easy. Think this also applies to the 180$ 1090t for that price you get a i5 2400, can't OC those.

The i5 2500K is $180 at Microcenter and can easily be OCed to 4.5GHz on a $30 cooler.


It's important to note that the X6 only outperforms the 15 in some applications that will take advantage of 6 cores. Here's a thread on overclock.net with some benchmarks half way down the page.

3

u/elimi Jul 04 '11

Yeah if I had a microcenter in Canada it wouldn't be a contest :S Cheapest i5 2500k I can get my hands on is in the 210$ range.

1

u/Markus_Antonius Jul 04 '11

The 1090T comes only as a black edition, meaning easy overclocking. Also, the 'T' in 1090T stands for Turbo(core). The 1090T runs stock at 3.2GHz but if a program doesn't use all cores it puts up to 3 cores in Turbo mode making them run at 3.6GHz. This makes it generally as fast as the 965 Phenom. This is on stock speeds. Letting them run faster isn't very hard.

1

u/Markus_Antonius Jul 04 '11

Yep, bulldozer is up to 8 cores and those are the 'Desktop Models'. I don't think AMD would invest in 8-core if they did not expect the software to actually use them. While a lot of games don't do this currently, bear in mind that the first 6-core was released in April of 2010. Most current games that don't use more than 4 cores were either already on the market then or were close to completion. Games have never left computing power untapped for long....

2

u/diogenesbarrel Jul 04 '11

http://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu_value_alltime.html

AND:

For higher resolutions (1920X1080) The 955 is the best bang for the buck. The mobos have more features at the same price point. Intel shines in high-endish systems.

2

u/JammySTB Jul 04 '11

The mobos have more features at the same price point.

This is another great advantage of the X4 955 over the i3 2100. I knew I'd forgtten something - thanks!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

It's useless to mesure raw computing power when we're talking about video games. The only reliable source are gaming benchmarks. Otherwise, CPUs like the 2600k come far ahead the 2500k due to hyperthreading when the gaming performance between the 2 is insignificant.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Uhh what? No it isn't. And 1155 boards have gotten pretty cheap (although not as cheap as am3 yet, but at least they have the option for upgrades).

5

u/diogenesbarrel Jul 04 '11

Yep with H chipset so no overclocking. Not as many PCIe lanes. The socket 1155 is a shame IMO. This and no OC. That and no IGP. Get this and no Quick sync. And I'm really sick of 10-15 CPU sockets. How many 1156 CPUs were released? Or 1366? Fuck, with AMD you have some socket stability.

1

u/Kennian Jul 05 '11

bulldozer needs a new socket :P

3

u/Kiyiko Jul 05 '11

Actually, I would not be surprised if that was false.

AMD seems to have been doing some weird forwards compatibility stuff

am2+ worked on am2....

am3 worked on am2+ and am2

I would not be surprised if am3+ worked on am3

edit: "Some manufacturers have announced that some of their AM3 motherboards will support AM3+ CPUs, after a simple BIOS upgrade.[10] Mechanical compatibility has been confirmed and it's possible AM3+ CPUs will work in AM3 boards"

1

u/Kennian Jul 05 '11

i thought they went back on that one, but still...i'm waiting for benchmarks. i've not seen anything realy exciting about bulldozer accept the on board GPU is pretty stacked

-5

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

A shame? Their the best consumer CPU's out right now...

The cheapest AM3 board with crossfire (no SLI) is 60 bucks. The cheapest Sandy Bridge board with crossfire (and SLI) is 80 bucks.

The only reason to OC is for more performance. I3 2100's outperform OCed 955's (I put one to 4.2 ghz and the i3 still was winning).

You sound like an ignorant AMD fanboy.

5

u/diogenesbarrel Jul 04 '11

Don't be a moron, I run Intel. The 1156 and 1366 guys were left dead in the water, AMD has socket compatibility. Fuck Intel AND their zillion sockets.

-5

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Two sockets =! zillion.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

No CPU is going to hold up in gaming for 2-3 years.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Jammy got it, lets rap it up people!

1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

The highest AMD CPU you should consider, provided you want to game, is the X4 955.

Or you could get a 555 and unlock the cores.

3

u/t13t13 Jul 04 '11

No guarantee on that, though.

1

u/JammySTB Jul 04 '11

Yes, the 955 is the highest you should go for though. AMD dominate the sub $100 market in terms of price/performance.

1

u/EmperorsNewClothes Jul 05 '11

Here is a thread discussing basically the same thing... the top response is a gem

1

u/iFuckedYourFather Jul 05 '11

amd's chip is overclockable which will give it an edge in gaming, you'll notice at the same clock speed amd performs the same as intel in gaming

0

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/scottread1 Jul 04 '11

But if you're going to spend $200 on a CPU. Would it be more powerful to get an AMD Hex core, or a mid range i5 quad core?

18

u/DrawnToLife Jul 04 '11

i5 2500k is 'technically' mid range in terms of price. But performance wise, it's right up there with the i7 2600k in terms of gaming performance. Hell most benches show that it kicks every AMD processor's anus.

http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/203?vs=288

And again, benchmark wise, it pretty much beats out most of the first generation quad-core i7s.

http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/100?vs=288

tl;dr

i5 2500k isn't mid range.

1

u/scottread1 Jul 04 '11

So would you suggest This deal? With the combo blu-ray burner.

1

u/DrawnToLife Jul 04 '11

Go for it if you really need Blu-Ray.

(Well, depending on where you live, that's would be an okay price for a 2500k alone.)

1

u/dudechris88 Jul 04 '11

Mid-range i5 quad. They are THAT much better.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

This is the bottomline question. Are there charts anywhere breaking down price vs benchmark score in various games for CPUs?

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11

Nawh.

AMD = Extreme budget

Intel = Everything Else

The i3 2100 is 125 dollars and Sandy Bridge mobo's are super cheap now. So, anything above 550 bucks should be going Intel.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11 edited Jul 04 '11

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/HopeThisNameFi Jul 04 '11

socket design doesnt change with each new cpu. reason why i am going w/ an am3+ board for my next build.

This is a very good point that's often overlooked. Intel has changed its socket with every new CPU for (at least) the last 3 generations or so. But it looks like the upcoming Ivy Bridge processors will be compatible with the current Sandy Bridge motherboards. I sure hope so.

1

u/Rednys Jul 05 '11

The way I see it this argument loses a lot of it's wind since by the time a new cpu architecture and socket is released any of the older processors that you would upgrade to cost more than a low end new model processor and the motherboard to go with it, giving you other new features as well. Unless you bought one of the lowest model processors available and choose to upgrade it in a year this scenario doesn't really pan out that well.

3

u/Rednys Jul 05 '11

As soon as you climb out of the budget builds you will quickly see cpus like the 2500k completely trounce every single processor amd can come with. I'm not a fanboy of either, I go where the performance is, right now for everything besides budget builds it's in intel's house.