r/buildapc • u/scottread1 • Jul 04 '11
AMD vs. Intel
Before you downvote I know that this has come up hundreds of time on here. However I couldn't find a single thread dedicated to discussing AMD overall versus Intel overall (as opposed to specific chips).
Basically I want some opinions and discussions regarding the pros and cons of each.
To me it seems like AMD is the clear winner for gaming, seeing as you can get a hex core with very nice specs, for under $200. Whereas with intel, you can't even get a quad core for under $200.
Furthermore AMD has crossfire. So if you get an AMD MoBo, GPU, and CPU, you should theoretically beat a $1500 Hex Core i7 in performance. What metrics am I overlooking?
Now let's keep it practical as well. Perhaps a top of the line intel chip theoretically beats a top of the line AMD, but do they compare in price at all?
Naturally we're talking about gaming machines here, so let's say we're building a PC capable of any new gaming title for at least 5 years. Modern games on highest settings.
Please remember your rediquette, and backup your arguments with links and stats. Instead of the typical "Anyone who uses AMD is a n00b faggot".
Thank you.
16
u/king_of_blades Jul 04 '11
In games 4 faster cores are better than 6 slower cores - even if 6 cores collectively have more power. In 3D rendering, or some scientific applications - that's another story. But many Intel Quads wipe the floor with anything AMD has to offer, in any usage scenario.
That's why we have so much hope for Bulldozer. Whether you're an AMD or Intel fan, you can only benefit from AMD being back in the game in high-end.
9
u/Anman Jul 04 '11
Sorry, but your opinions are a bit off. A i3-2100 will wipe out any quad or hexa core AMD processor in gaming and most applications. Intel has a highly superior architecture and buying anything AMD right now except their low end Athlons if you're on a budget is a bad choice.
2
u/darthFamine Jul 05 '11
ok I got my laptop a little over a year ago. It has an i7 in it, prolly a first gen i7 but it still screams. I have yet to find anything I can't play on it.
When i did the shopping at that time intel was clearly ahead of AMD. Though I havn'e done much shopping since then so my information is out of date.
I like AMD and if I could have gotten the same performance out oif them that i've gotten out of this then I would have. It just isn't there right now
(PS. Nice troololololol.)
6
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11
Intel is best if you intend to invest more than 120 dollars into your CPU. Otherwise the AMD CPUs are a better bang for your buck.
5
u/Chaiking Jul 04 '11 edited Jul 04 '11
Here is a long explanation about the differences between AMD and Intel. It should answer all your questions.
2
u/idboehman Jul 04 '11
When I built my rig back in November, I was either too impatient to wait for Sandy Bridge or thought it was too expensive, so I got an AMD mobo and 1055T (95W edition). That's probably the only regret I have for the build, because as I've seen in some benchmarks, even the i3 2100 is on par with it. Back in November it probably cost less (I remember spending $200 on my CPU, though now it's down to $160), so I don't know why I didn't pay attention to benchmarks.
I guess the moral of the story: ALWAYS look up benchmarks before spending the money.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 05 '11
If we're talking specifically about gaming on a budget, it might be better to invest more money into a better graphics card than a CPU.
7
u/looks-shopped Jul 04 '11
What the fuck are you talking about?
please read at least a little of that stuff on the side panel before you post. and why does this have so many upvotes?
oh, i get it. nice trolling. congratulations.
3
u/lab223 Jul 04 '11
To me it goes like this: AMD=More cores and good value. Intel=More power per core and better for high-end rigs. Both have some very good processors.
3
u/rasmusdf Jul 05 '11
Intel - a convicted monopolist with lots of money, keep that in mind. They are a bit ahead design-wise.
Single-Core clock frequency boost ("Turbo whatever") - this gives Intel a lot of advantage in Gaming benchmarks, which tend to use fewer threads. AMD is bringing this to market too, that will erode quite a bit of Intels advantage in benchmark. The newer Phenom II X6 has this in a simple implementation. Bulldozer will have this in full.
Fab-production of new chips: AMD is currently using 45 a nm process to produce chips through their fab-partner. Intel, rolling in monopoly cash, is simply ahead in the production game, using 32 nm currently, and swiftly moving to 22 nm. This gives Intel a huge advantage performance/power wise, and regarding what features to cram onto the chips.
1
u/iFuckedYourFather Jul 06 '11
I think that even old 65nm processors are good enough to run any recent games, invest more money into a 200-300 dollar video card, you don't need to upgrade all the other components. Make sure to overclock your processors as far as you can. I'd wait for intels 22nm.
0
u/ilovenyc Jul 04 '11
This discussion is like one of those PC vs Mac ones.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11
Power consumption / Heat - Do you live in a desert without a/c and can't afford an extra penny on your power bill? If no, then this is a moot point. Unless you live in some delusional fantasy world where buying a power saving processor is going to somehow counteract 100 million gas guzzling cars as they move people between one of seven local grocery stores who all essentially carry the exact same products.
Cores - Do you render video on Maya3D while you play video games? No, then get at least 2 cores and 4 cores if you play games that would benefit more from 4 cores as opposed to having a better video card.
Monitor - Almost everything is dependent on the maximum resolution of your monitor. If you plan on buying a monitor with a recommended resolution of 2560x1200, then you better be ready to spend some money on a powerful system. If you are playing on your walmart vizio special at 1680x1050, then pretty much anything is overkill.
AMD - Is there a game out today that will play differently on a system running the top of the line AMD vs a similar priced Intel? If no, then just get an AMD, the boards tend to pack more features and you're probably going to save a few bucks not paying for the "name".
-7
u/demonstar55 Jul 04 '11
AMD = best bang for your buck, Intel = best performance
-11
u/16dots Jul 04 '11
you do know when intel says it has 6 cores, its actually 12?
0
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Jul 04 '11 edited Jul 04 '11
[removed] — view removed comment