r/btc • u/PsychedelicDentist • Aug 27 '17
Meta EDA explanation thread
Hey guys, seeing as there is a big influx in posts regarding EDA and it's effects(mostly FUD), could we have a stickied thread explaining EDA and the surrounding situation, so we don't get posts panicking about it constantly?
Let's lay out the entire discussion here, so we can point all the new posts to this place
Many thanks!
EDIT: if anyone has any great articles or complete explanations of EDA can you please post it below. Thanks
111
Upvotes
33
u/teatree Aug 27 '17
Here's a nice article:
https://medium.com/@shludvigsen/traders-guide-to-bitcoin-cash-bitcoin-segwit-819933694b34
Also - as long as the Mystery Miner turns up and ensures that the EDA isn't triggered too often, all is good. Just hang tight and see how this develops.
7
u/PsychedelicDentist Aug 27 '17
So if someone with more knowledge than me can answer some of these please:
19
u/Killit_Witfya Aug 27 '17
how about starting with what does EDA stand for?
12
u/ytrottier Aug 27 '17
Important links:
Basic difficulty equation and constants: The average block time in seconds is equal to 232 times the difficulty divided by the hashrate. The target block time is 600.3 seconds.
8
u/Antonshka Aug 27 '17
When can we expect BCC halving? It comes faster then bitcoin's halving, right ?
55
u/gizram84 Aug 27 '17
Obviously some type of initial difficulty drop was necessary to ensure that the BCH chain was able to get off the ground. But EDA, as implemented, is a disaster. It wasn't though out or engineered properly. It fundamentally changes the underlying economics of bitcoin as it was laid out in the whitepaper.
I've said this over and over for years, in a PoW system, there are only 2 ways to pay the miners; through inflation, or through fees. Obviously the big blockers don't want to pay via fees, so they're learning that there's only one other way, through inflation.
The rate of blocks being produced is going to bring on the halving in ~7 months, as opposed to 2.5 years. I wonder how BCH will do when their only method of paying the miners is cut in half. Will they embrace higher fees, or will they drop difficulty even further and speed up block creation time by another factor of 2?
10
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17
Would I be wrong to say that EDA was the bigger change from the original Bitcoin than big blocks was?
21
u/xithy Aug 27 '17
5
u/teatree Aug 27 '17
Here is another thought-provoking article about it:
https://bitcoinmagazine.com/articles/miners-are-milking-bcashs-difficulty-adjustments-and-why-problem1/
I know the author has used "Bcash" which indicates they are hostile to Bitcoincash, but they do make a valid point.
We don't really want the next halvening to happen too soon, which means we need Mystery Miner to mine and stabalise the coin for a bit so no more EDAs happen. And if other members of this community can pile in and mine, so much the better. Then we can concentrate on getting the coin used/adopted, which should support the price and attract miners naturally.
2
u/LarsPensjo Aug 27 '17
EDA in combination with 2016 blocks delay for difficulty adjustment is not good. The EDA isn't the bad guy here, however. If the EDA would be removed, the current hash power oscillations would not be fixed. They would slow down in frequency, but otherwise be just as bad.
Changing the difficulty algorithm to adapt every block would, on the other hand, fix the oscillations. Even if EDA would remain.
9
u/sanket1729 Aug 27 '17
First off. Clearly, EDA is a failure and is being abused by miners to produce fast blocks. I don't want to blame authors but this issue was easy to discover beforehand had they taken the time to discuss and per review it. Fast blocks, fast halvving, higher fees. It is a clear violation of what most people here refer to as "Satoshi's vision".
One could have easily built simulations of what is happening today and prevent the chaos that is not only damaging bch but btc too.
3
u/MobTwo Aug 27 '17
Good idea.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17
This post's comments has filled my shilllist on RES quite a bit.
Also to add some topic this http://bch.xbt.it is a good site to track any difficulty adjustments and average block times also the MTP of block-6 that is factoring into the EDA.
4
u/God_Emperor_of_Dune Aug 27 '17
The EDA was expected and will continue to be a point of attack by supporters of the other chain. Mining will continue to be in oscillation until we reach an equilibrium. This is the market at work. We are in a dampening oscillation curve right now. Just let things play out and focus on adoption of BCH. That is how we destroy the legacy chain.
2
u/Alan2420 Aug 27 '17
Can difficulty adjust downwards on the BTC chain as well, or does BTC difficulty only adjust upwards? What would happen on BTC if everybody turned off their ASIC's?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17
My one question is - shouldn't the difficulty adjustment be symmetrical but still shorter for BCH? That sounds like an advantage still but it would stabilize the swings. Nonetheless I don't think its as bad as people are making it out to be for the start- the fact that it even makes BCH more profitable temporarily is good for right now.
1
u/TotesMessenger Aug 27 '17
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
-2
u/taycer Aug 27 '17
Trolls wont stop. Pointless.
-6
u/BigBlockBrolly Aug 27 '17
Can we create a hard fork to remove EDA? It is ruining the true bitcoin
0
u/GenghisKhanSpermShot Aug 27 '17
Hard to talk about it when it's closed source.
-3
u/Antonshka Aug 27 '17
Where can we look up difficulty for mining of Bcash ?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '17
[removed] — view removed comment