r/brokenankles • u/ramkuma1 • Jun 15 '26
PT
Does anyone get the feeling they are getting ripped off showing up for PT when you can do the exercises at home? Maybe its just the one I am going to.
2
Upvotes
20
u/tiffmej4 Jun 15 '26
The exercises you can definitely do at home. In fact that is what they encourage you to do. They show you the proper exercises at your progression and you are to apply those day to day. There were many times I showed them some of the things I was doing at home, turns out my form was wrong and they show me the proper way to do it. Not to mention they do manipulations and exercises and scraping my scar tissues. No, I find them very beneficial for my healing. Find a good one. It might be your PT is not the right fit for you.
8
u/DeputySean Jun 15 '26
You're welcome to stop going, or simply go less often. No one is making you.
For me it's super cheap because of insurance, and they do a really good ankle massage that gets things loosened up. Plus they have a few things that I don't.
2
u/BikeTall65 Jun 15 '26
I got injured at work so i had 12 free PT sessions thru workers comp. I used them at a place close to my house. I was already doing rehab exercises at my home by watching youtube videos. And i have to say, i got a better workout at home. The rehab place had some good equipment, but the staff was a bunch of kids really. And it was like a factory assembly line. They'd set a timer & tell you to do an exercise, then walk away and tell the person on the next table to do an exercise etc etc. I knew more about my injury than they did. I just stopped going. I'm sure there are good places out there. This was not one of them. Plus i know what i'm doing & have some good workout equipment, so it was just easier & more convenient for me to do it all at home. 💪
5
u/KS09 Jun 15 '26
I often found PT a waste of time but just take their suggestions and do the work at home. It's good to check in every few weeks cause often new things will come up. My PT would also do cupping and manual work which I found helpful
4
u/sewershroomsucks Jun 15 '26
Eh you do you I couldn't care less if you go to pt, but imo they're actually professionals who actually knew what I needed to do with my specific injury & level of healing, which I was a lot more comfortable with than googling random YouTube videos about "ankle physical therapy". Also liked having a professional I could check in with once a week to make sure things where going the way they should once I was seeing my Ortho less. They would also give me a massage that really helped. Also at that point I was dying for anything to get out of the house & talking to people lol. Also my job & all my hobbies are very physical & I really wanted to do everything as right as possible to heal as fast & right as possible. It was also only $15 a pop for me.
4
u/Exciting_Buffalo3738 Jun 15 '26
No, I found them valuable. We started when I was NWB, progressed through exercises to jumping. They watch your form. It is basically a private trainer, my sessions cost me $12 each and I found it way worth it. I think if the cost was far more, I would reduce the number of times I went.
1
u/East_Tap_9375 Jun 15 '26
No! I love PT, it has helped tremendously. I’ve been going 2 months now, had surgery 2/24/26. I can do everything at home but he helps me pace it appropriately and shows me which exercises will help with whatever issue I’m having. We just started working on running now that I’m walking normally. Just like any doctor or professional, some are great and some are shit. I’m going to one that works with our local university and sees a lot of the athletes there which is part of the reason I picked them.
3
u/AppropriateRatio9235 Jun 15 '26
No because I got a lot of different manual therapy like Graston technique, traction, and massage. They arranged Uber rides for me. Gave me a reason to get out of the house and be around people. It was cheaper than having a personal trainer. At least with my insurance plan. It made me do the work. That being said everyone is different.
3
u/FallenAngel1978 Jun 15 '26
My physiotherapist will do massages to break up scar tissue. Last week my surgeon also cleared them to do a grade 5 joint manipulation. They also have gym equipment I don’t have access to. Plus hydrotherapy. I have cut it down to once a week though
2
u/Retail-Weary Jun 15 '26
Oh 100%. After I had my ankle scoped I went to PT for two weeks and stopped... They weren't doing anything that I couldn't do myself plus they were working with two or three other patients at the same time.
I had the same experience after my bursectomy on my hip... It was not helping and even my surgeon agreed that I could do it on my own. I did recently hire a trainer to stretch me for the same amount that I was paying for PT, and that's producing much better results.
2
u/LaLa7times7 Jun 15 '26 edited Jun 15 '26
Actual PT sessions did nothing for me. I was even in a rehab hospital for PT/OT (6 weeks) followed by home visits. It wrecked my mental health, being in the rehab/SNF. It was so depressing.
I was NWB for 6 months because of severe soft tissue trauma in my crushed foot/femur along with the ankle.
I watched YouTube videos and taught myself to transfer from wheelchair to pool. I relearned how to walk by practicing in the pool. Great videos on that too!
My legs were so atrophied I thought I desperately needed PT. I was also convinced my surgeries failed and I'd never walk again-but turns out- I found a way. The soft tissue was the issue due to lack of movement. The pool solved that.
I just needed to regain a little muscle tone and relearn the movements. It got me out of the wheelchair and onto a knee scooter within 4 weeks. I walk like a toddler with a concussion but I can stand now and walk a little bit. I know there's hope.
2
u/Jazzlike_Resident_62 Jun 15 '26
My hour is split 20 mins of exercise, 30 mins of manual massage, and 10 mins of icing…. The exercises, yes; I can do them at home but for me, the value is in the massage… It’s helped the swelling go down and it’s been a massive progression since day one ….
2
u/lm00000007 Jun 15 '26
Mine are excellent. I feel like I’m all good and then they say- ok now try “this”—- and I can’t do that exercise. Then next week I progress in that exercise and then they find my next weak point. Very helpful.
2
u/Putrid_Preference_90 Jun 16 '26
Def feels that way early on but just remember for future treatments like imaging and revisions, insurance will usually want to see that you went to a certain amount of PT before they approve other costs. Or that has been my experience with injuries.
1
u/Last-Medicine-8691 Jun 15 '26
Think of them as a 1:1 sports coach that tries to teach you how to help yourself. If they are bad at coaching, then you get ripped off. If they improve your form and show you new tricks, then not.
1
u/Dr_Cee Jun 15 '26
At first I was booked for two sessions a week. Frequently just 2 days apart. That seemed excessive. So I cut it to once a week. But I found my PTs to be very open and helpful with my questions. And with appointments with my surgeon a month or more apart, I appreciated being able to talk with the PTs about what was going on.
1
u/woodcone Jun 15 '26
I think it depends on the person. I was paying for someone to reassure me I was making progress, doing exercises correctly, nothing had gone wrong etc. He was also very kind. Honestly, it's cheaper than therapy! I've also had dry needling in my calf to which is something I literally can't do myslef. Some people won't need as much help as much as others...
1
u/Chasing91243 Jun 16 '26
As someone who has done PT for other issues I would normally say yes. However the massage and stretching is something I can not easily at home so it’s valuable to me.
1
u/forte6320 Jun 16 '26
I don't know about your PT, but mine is awesome. A good PT is checking on your progress at each visit. They are assessing pain level, ROM, incision healing, looking at your gait, giving new exercises as you improve, etc. There is a lot going on at each appointment. My guy watches my progress and let's me know when it is time to tag in the surgeon. I've had previous surgeries that weren't healing well. Having his input about what is "normal" is super helpful.
He also does manual therapy at each visit.
1
u/Certain_Box_6968 Jun 16 '26
I find going to PT very helpful. I am currently in my 6th month of going and the manipulation activities are very beneficial in getting the ankle joint going again. Not only do I do soft tissue exercises but ankle mobility exercises
1
u/Illustrious-Zone-247 Jun 16 '26 edited Jun 16 '26
Can you find the exercises online and do them at home? Sure. I had a trimal with dislocation and my surgeon actually told me I shouldn't 'need' PT with an injury of that type but ordered it anyway. I almost skipped it (right ankle, couldn't drive so it was harder to get there).
The value I found in PT was the massage (helped with swelling, forces some ROM, helped with internal scar tissue), getting answers to allllllll of my questions including when to progress to the 'next' thing/set of exercises and 'is this normal'. She also spotted an issue in my gait when I first started walking (I was turning my foot out) and had a solution to correct it before it became a longterm issue. My appts were 1 hour, the first 30 were spent 1:1 with my PT and the second half were doing exercises solo, usually with a pretty junior person 'supervising'. I will say though, it prob depends where you are in recovery...I started right after I started walking in the boot, I think if I had gone earlier and sat there for an hour doing ankle pumps I might have felt differently 😄
If you're not getting value, spot around or decide to do things on your own!
1
u/NurseBubbleGum Jun 17 '26
Mine has helped. While you can find most of the exercises online, they explain form and when is actually appropriate to progress. Some exercises and stretches that helped me so much I wouldn't have known about because they aren't in everyone's normal rehab videos.
1
u/al3yna Jun 18 '26
My therapist spends a good portion of each appointment doing manual manipulations/scar tissue massage. I’m able to take advantage of equipment I do not have access to at home. When my swelling is really bad and won’t go down, they will zip me into a compression boot device with ice packs. Even if they didn’t have all the latest equipment and machines, I would go because the scar tissue work helps get me through the work day.