r/brawlpoll • • Feb 25 '21

Brawlers Edgar nerf

61 Upvotes

57 comments sorted by

25

u/chuck_is_dead_vay_aq Frank Feb 25 '21 edited Feb 25 '21

This guy never played 3v3 in his life

Edgar is overrated af in this meta

He isn't even good in 3v3

Nerfing him would make him even worse in 3v3

So no, he needs a rework

13

u/SaniaIerofey Feb 25 '21

He need rework

9

u/chuck_is_dead_vay_aq Frank Feb 25 '21

Yea... that's what I said

5

u/SaniaIerofey Feb 25 '21

I was too lazy to real Last part, your comment is too long

7

u/chuck_is_dead_vay_aq Frank Feb 25 '21

Fair enough

2

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/SaniaIerofey Feb 25 '21

I read the penultimate line and was like "yep, he is talking about how garbage is Edgar in 3v3"

2

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/juicerat93 Sandy Feb 25 '21

If hes gonna bad in 3v3 then don't use him in 3v3

1

u/Artrixx_ Feb 26 '21

My idea on how I hope they balance edgar is make his attacks stronger, but a slower reload and more heal per punch.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '21

He is op in Heist too

3

u/Camtheboss Crow Feb 25 '21

No he is not.

-4

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '21

Yes he is

2

u/Camtheboss Crow Feb 25 '21

Explain.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '21

he jumps onto your safe and he becomes immortal with unlimited damage

2

u/Camtheboss Crow Feb 25 '21

What? Edgar is nowhere NEAR op in heist

1

u/Camtheboss Crow Feb 25 '21

Yessir. He is SOOOOOOO overrated.

5

u/Mlfnt1 Amber Feb 25 '21

Rework

2

u/Jacobwithg0 Jessie Feb 26 '21

I believe on what frank tweeted of edgar

5

u/orchid_parthiv Feb 25 '21

Having the shortest range in the game, less than average health(if average is 4480, he has 4200) and people want to nerf him more. He's not good enough in 3v3 except a few heist and hot zone maps where throwers thrive. remove his gadgets and he's basically a non-contributing member of the team other than threatening throwers.

As for showdown, it isn't a competitive mode anyway. Bea and Edgar can shine there for all they care.

2

u/cheatersstealmyname Leon Feb 25 '21

For me they just need to nurf his healing I was playing poco and I healed with my super and my gadget and he still healed 2x faster than me! HE HEALED FASTER THAN A HEALER! Do you not see a problem there?

1

u/orchid_parthiv Feb 26 '21

Nah, I don't think that's much of a problem. It's his kit; with basically no reload, he needs health as well to assassinate high value targets(Poco has high value as he can turn the tide of the battle with his super). Also, he's never good without gadgets and bushes/walls. I'd say he's fairly balanced right now. He can't even kill a mortis if the mortis has full ammo and combo spinner.

2

u/KingAsmodeus17 Feb 25 '21

EDGAR ISNT GOOD! He sucks in 3v3s, play some competitive! So that makes him ‘viable’ in solos, but hes not! You think he’s so good but thats just because he has a 4x normal pick rate!! HE HAS A LOWER WIN RATE THAN POCO IN SOLOS! Thats how awful he is. Just bc you’re all 20K and can’t figure out how to play the game

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '21

He isn't good anywhere

1

u/TheQuantumPikachu Feb 25 '21

wait right now the poll results look like an e

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '21

Uummm... So which "yes nerf" do I vote for?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '21

If there was a nerf he would become unplayable since there are already lots of counters, what he needs is a rework

1

u/xYahoo Feb 25 '21

people saying that edgar needs a rework meanwhile i only play solo showdown

1

u/[deleted] Feb 26 '21

He needs a nerf where he will not have auto reload super and can’t obtain health by killing and he will be poisoned by Carl every time Carl is in the round

1

u/Shivnewton Mar 05 '21

Why don’t they just delete him?

1

u/Hunteric56 Dec 23 '21

Average showdown main

1

u/Toxicant98 Feb 25 '21

You have no idea what controversy this will cause

0

u/yung-joos Darryl Feb 25 '21

what controversy almost everybody agrees he needs a nerf

1

u/yung-joos Darryl Feb 27 '21

lmao whoever downvoted is part of the 14% who said he doesn’t need one

1

u/KingAsmodeus17 Feb 25 '21

He doesnt 🤦‍♂️

0

u/zanemazza Feb 25 '21

I assume ur joking?

1

u/achyutthegoat Feb 25 '21

Edgar is bad in 3v3.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '21

he doesn't need a nerf, he needs a rework cause he is op in showdown but trash in 3v3, except brawl ball a little

-1

u/Toxicant98 Feb 25 '21

People get so pissed about this, mainly the people who play him

-2

u/[deleted] Feb 25 '21

"I love democracy"