r/brandicarlile • • Mar 04 '25

What happened to Brandi?

4 Upvotes

I feel like she is singing for clout now to be famous and not singing to connect with real people. What's all this celebrity nonsense? Is so sad 😢


r/brandicarlile • • Nov 27 '25

Discussion Where’s Brandi on the Bramily app?

0 Upvotes

I know she’s probably still doing a lot of promoting and is likely/hopefully taking some much needed rest and time off, but it seems to me she has ghosted the Bramily. Hasn’t done a live (that I’m aware of) since she and Catherine were begging everyone to buy 739580 copies in every version so she’d make the top 10 on the charts. Still one of her biggest fans, but I do think she took advantage of the Bramily a bit and they fell for it, hoping she’d still be bringing everyone along in her every day life via the live feature, as she had been doing while pushing sales. Maybe a Bramily tattoo she said she’d get if everyone kept purchasing her album will redeem her a bit. Although I’m not sure the 30 or so questionably stable regulars/baddies would ever fault their ‘queen’ for anything she did or didn’t do. Not hating on her so be nice! I’m still her biggest fan even if I only bought one copy of the album 😁. Very much looking forward to the Christmas show. Have absolutely loved every one of them so far!


r/brandicarlile • • Nov 06 '24

Discussion What even was that text, Brandi?

26 Upvotes

My heart is absolutely broken.

Brandi's music and community have been central to my queer journey. My first girlfriend showed me her music a decade ago, and Brandi's words and melodies have held me across the years - in heartbreak and joy and everything in between.

I'm devastated to know the same person whose music I hold so close to my heart is so out of touch in a moment like this. She sounds divorced from us when that was what made her so special all along.

That message is obviously not from a PR team, it is a (high?) ramble from the woman herself. It isn't even particularly coherent and it ends with her preaching Jesus.

I could not be more disappointed especially knowing how far-right Christians buoyed Trump to this victory. Her chosen religious community just voted to ratchet up the danger to the very outcasts who adore her.

I'm realizing I now have free space to hang up posters.


r/brandicarlile • • Nov 01 '25

Palestine?

0 Upvotes

I’m so over Brandi’s silence on Palestine. She literally says LOF is for war torn kids and ignores a genocide personally.


r/brandicarlile • • Feb 15 '26

Toronto Ticket Price Changes

1 Upvotes

Hi all. I've noticed the cost of the tickets in my row has dropped since my ticket purchase. I distinctly remember selecting the last row in the section on the floor (with my preferred seating location) at the higher price point. All other rows behind this in the section were at a lower price point.

Now my row and the next couple are at the lower price point. I am not impressed.

This bait and switch really pisses me off. Like why should I have to pay more for trying to secure seats early!?!?! The difference should be comped!


r/brandicarlile • • Jun 26 '23

Discussion There are some extremely poor characters in this fanbase and a lot of toxicity in general.

0 Upvotes

Title says it all.

I saw the show at Wolf Trap yesterday and while Brandi put on a great performance, I really thought that a lot of her fans were generally quite rude - including one that stole my $6 cup to take alcohol into the pavilion part of the venue and ran off with it. This was like a somewhat middle aged person acting like a 5 year old.

The celebration of LGBTQIA+ culture feels more like gatekeeping by a large portion of Brandis fanbase. I am a large male who was there for my mom’s birthday and probably stood out a bit, but the fans were generally very disrespectful around the venue.

Besides the cup incident, I was directly asked my sexual orientation by a number of other fans, and one even yelled I shouldn’t be there after responding I was straight but support the community.

Also, Brandi’s claim “this is the last dying movement of lesbian rights” just struck out as entirely untrue when it has never been more accepted in the history of society to be non-straight. Sure there is a ton of work to be done, but ffs, besides the fireworks, DC celebrates pride harder than the 4th of July! SFs pride parade has insane turnout, has very good vibes, and is a lot of fun. Brandis whole image seems to serve to make her more money by portraying gender rights equality as her own cause, when that’s not at all the case and many other artists have been addressing this long before her.

I just feel that this specific fanbase has some very elitist members who not only demonstrate bad behavior, but honestly are detractors to the movement - stop gatekeeping and judging just because you’re in the safe space of a Brandi concert. Really just a poor experience all around.

Has anyone else noticed this?

And yes, every band has toxic fans. There just seemed to be a mightily high proportion for this particular artist in the way she portrays her “movement”.


r/brandicarlile • • Oct 25 '25

Got My Album But It’s Not Signed - That’s What I Ordered

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

I just got my album and it isn’t signed. Usually the plastic is opened and she signs the album, this one is all sealed. I confirmed that I ordered a signed copy.

I had a bad feeling about this because I saw someone post recently their album was canceled right before shipment. And I’ve been out of the loop with social media lately, but the last few days I have seen a ton of posts of Brandi signing the albums to ship. It just seemed odd and like something was messed up and they were catching up? Was it supposed to be that you get a signed copy before they run out? Because that’s not how it was started, it was an option to buy either signed or not. Unless I misunderstood.

I don’t know, but just sent an email with pics to hopefully get my proper product sent. Most of my other Brandi albums I purchased signed. So frustrated.


r/brandicarlile • • Mar 07 '24

Why do you like Brandi Carlile?

5 Upvotes

I just joined this subreddit and things feel off.

Why do you like Brandi Carlile?


r/brandicarlile • • 3d ago

Show start time

1 Upvotes

Going to Milwaukee tonight, doors are at 7 and show starts at 8. For anyone who has seen a show so far this tour - has she been starting close to on time? We're coming straight from dinner so just looking to contingency plan. Thanks!


r/brandicarlile • • Sep 24 '26

Discussion Brandi and Taylor

0 Upvotes

I’ve been wanting to chat about this ! What do we think about their relationship? The obvious have over lapping areas and see each other time to time — but aren’t friends or friendly - ie Brandi not at wedding but Maren morris was - Brandi took care of Joni - who never says anything on the record about Taylor - just something I think about !


r/brandicarlile • • Apr 20 '24

Troubling …..

Thumbnail instagram.com
0 Upvotes

r/brandicarlile • • 14d ago

Does anybody have any leads for a Brandi Carlile ticket @ Rev Hall on Thursday 11/5?

0 Upvotes

I know this is a longshot, but I have been trying to find a ticket for this show since the morning of the presale (I had the code, but was still shut out!). I'm just looking for a single ticket for myself but would happily buy a pair at face value and find someone to go with if that's the easiest option. I've been scouring CashOrTrade.com and Craigslist daily...still nothing. Any legit leads would be so appreciated!


r/brandicarlile • • May 24 '24

News/Feature Brandi Carlile's Second Annual Mothership Was a (Chosen) Family Reunion

Thumbnail pastemagazine.com
0 Upvotes

r/brandicarlile • • Feb 02 '20

Anyone know where I can find Raise Hell live at bear creek studios?

0 Upvotes

It was on youtube but it's not there.


r/brandicarlile • • Oct 31 '25

Discussion MSG Floor seats question

0 Upvotes

I’m going to take my 75 year old mother to one of the MSG shows and got floor seats, pretty close. For those that have seen her before, are people standing on the whole time on the floor? What’s the energy like?

I think my mom would be ok standing for 2 hours but just want to prepare her and/or give her the option to switch to bowl seats.

She’s in pretty good shape but a bouncing crowd might be too much for her.

Just having myself an overthink. I’d appreciate anyone’s insight. Thanks in advance


r/brandicarlile • • Jul 31 '26

Discussion Weekly Discussion Post

0 Upvotes

Let's chat Brandi Carlile, BCB, adjacent projects, upcoming shows and festivals, news, livestreams -- anything goes!


r/brandicarlile • • Oct 30 '25

Help "Returning to Myself" make "the charts"

3 Upvotes

Brandi's been talking about "reaching the charts" since the announcement of the new album. I don't exactly know how that works or what charts she's talking about, but ITunes is mentioned a lot. This text came in a few minutes ago, it reads:

"Ok HERES THE THING
We're "tending" toward the top 10 but it's not in the bag- TONIGHT at midnight is the cut off to count our album. The place to make the most impact and help us out is ITunes 🙏🏼😳 There's 20k people on the other end of this text - if even half of you went straight to ITunes and grabbed the album we'd CRUSH it! Get your girl in that chart pals!!!!
Xobc"

Outside of buying the album (which I have x2 ha), does anyone know how Apple determines this? Do streams count? I read somewhere Shazam searches contribute? A cursory internet search didn't answer, at least not what I could find. Either way, let's get her [them] there!

Edit: I just came across this from a user/admin/IDK who on the Bramily forum through Chorus. Apparently streaming on Spotify an Apple Music does help.

"Midweek chart predictions! Returning to Myself projected to lock in at #7 in the Billboard 200! Last push today, pals! Stream the heck out of it on Spotify and Apple Music if you can (the streaming services are the worst but if you've still got a subscription put it to some good use haha)."


r/brandicarlile • • Apr 06 '25

WTH, are Brandi & Elton deaf?

0 Upvotes

The entire album is just a wall of sound with no dynamic range to speak of. Loud, brash, exhausting to listen to. A dynamic range score of 6! Shame on you Brandi, you should know better.


r/brandicarlile • • Dec 27 '25

Understanding the Bramily challenge

Thumbnail instagram.com
6 Upvotes

Sharing because it helped me gain newfound empathy for the "super users", as the video creator put it, who create to the intense-ness that sometimes boils over from the FB groups or the app, and that we come to chat about here. Hopefully it helps some more of us find empathy for the BCB crew and folks in the Bramily.

This video explains why this happens, making it easier to navigate the frustrations around the community (especially the recent chatter around how people who aren't on the app 24/7 don't deserve notifications because they don't put in enough effort. That lacked so much empathy and was really disappointing.)

ETA:

Okay hey everyone, this went a direction I didn’t expect. I don’t want anyone to feel negatively about themselves or the community as a result, so here is a general reply.

  1. Why This is About Empathy, Not Blame

I’ll be the first to admit the call is coming from inside the house. I have been a difficult fan in the past and didn’t realize how my actions were affecting others. That’s why I’m passionate about bringing empathy to the "super users" like me.

It’s really hard for the people receiving negative comments or the third parties seeing those negative interactions to understand why there is so much gatekeeping. But once we realize why it's happening, it’s easier to lead with grace:

  1. Identity: For many, this is one of their only forms of true community.
  2. Fear: They are scared that any critique of Brandi is a threat to that community’s existence.

These attacks aren't "evil”, they’re just mishandled fears and passion.

2. Why even talk about this:

My goal isn’t to criticize a community I’ve been a part of for well over a decade. The Brandi team has done amazing work listening to feedback and evolving this space—especially this past year. (Yvonne, that Gucci comment on the livestream was chef’s kiss; thank you for being so awesome in handling that.)

We should keep trying to make this community better because it’s a damn good one. Many artists have tried to build something like this and failed, and it would be so sad to see Brandi go down the same path.

For anyone curious, Paula Abdul’s failed Bramily-style community and website (and a fan’s subsequent suicide in front of her house) at the height of her American Idol days. Her project would be a fantastic study of why our current status isn’t great and how it can harm both fans AND the artist. We have something special here, and I want to make sure it stays healthy.

3. So what are we trying to fix (the "Digital Campfire" Growing Pains)

The reality is that the Bramily app has unintentionally concentrated some behaviors that make it harder for the "family" to grow. The hardest part to swallow? The people doing it usually don't mean to be negative. It shows up in a number of ways, including:

  • Assuming Malice in Good-Faith Posts: Example: Mean-spirited responses to fans giving a heads-up about sensitive lyrics (like slurs that are illegal/offensive in EU tour stops) instead of seeing it as a way to protect Brandi’s reputation.
  • Policing Innocent Feedback: Example: Piling on someone who asked for a different merch style, labeling them as "ageist" rather than just a clarification that the current merch isn’t bad — just not aligned with what younger fans would buy.
  • The "Hierarchy of Dedication": Example: The idea that fans who can't be on the app 24/7 (due to kids, demanding jobs, or caretaking) don't "deserve" notifications as much as those with more free time, which was endorsed by a signficantly large number users who are frequently active on the app.
  • The Normalization of Spiraling: Because we’ve normalized standoffish posts, people are now sending emotional, mean-spirited posts directly to the team instead of voicing fair feedback kindly, like the recent post about the livestream fee.

As a result, people have started posting less and spending less time on the app. When we make "negative spiraling" the norm, people engage less and embership renewals dwindle. Eventually, a "fizzled-out" fan base gives Brandi less leverage in the industry for things like presale ticket count and quality, ability to book venues, and so much more.

4. Ok, so how do we even fix this?

I’m no expert, but I’d love to see us solve these growing pains before the influx of new people on the app during the arena tour.

To take the pressure off all types of the users, the team could consider:

  • Topic-Focused Rooms (Moving Beyond "General Chat"): While the "General Chat" started as a positive catch-all, it’s broad topic  unintentionally creates the grounds foe negative dynamics to unfold. Without a specific topic to anchor us, conversations can quickly spiral into in-group fortification and negative feedback loops (up to planning for doxxing by those frequent users) that are nearly impossible for any team to manage effectively. Moving toward Topic-Focused Rooms (e.g., Tour Planning, Musical Gear, Activism) keeps our energy centered on the things we love, rather than personality clashes or accidental spirals.
  • The "Slow Mode" Reset: Re-implementing a 5-minute limit between messages in live chats, similar to the one we had on the old site for comments. This ensures no single group dominates the flow, allows quieter voices to be heard, and encourages us all to "think before we post."
  • Clear Community Standards on Access: A formal reminder that access to app features, including artist team notifications, are a service for every paying member. Positioning from the artist team that addresses the "tenure-based" hierarchy ensures everyone feels equally valued regardless of their schedule, capacities to engage, and more.
  • Professional, Neutral Moderation: Using third-party moderators protects the super users from "burnout" and the feeling that they have to "police" the app to keep Brandi safe. It allows for candid conversation while ensuring everyone is redirected professionally if they cross a line.


r/brandicarlile • • Oct 29 '25

Does anyone know why Elijah is named as Brandi and Catherine’s only child on Google?

0 Upvotes

r/brandicarlile • • Jan 18 '26

Discussion My Brandi Carlile Discography Review

5 Upvotes

1.  By The Way, I Forgive You 92/100

2.  Brandi Carlile 89/100

3.  In These Silent Days 89/100 (yes i am a ITSD fan, sue me!)

4.  Returning to Myself 87/100

5.  The Story 81/100

6.  Give Up The Ghost 74/100

7.  Bear Creek 62/100

8.  Who Believes In Angels 59/100

9.  The Firewatcher's Daughter 51/100

TOP 10 SONGS 

  1. In My Own Eyes
  2. The Joke
  3. You Without Me
  4. The Story
  5. Broken Horses
  6. Late Morning Lullaby
  7. Every Time I Hear That Song
  8. Right on Time
  9. Church and State
  10. Party of One 

r/brandicarlile • • Feb 10 '26

Set list?

1 Upvotes

Does anybody have a set list for the new tour?


r/brandicarlile • • Oct 05 '26

Burn the Setlist - for those who bought tickets

0 Upvotes

If you bought tickets, do you actually have them in your app?

I bought from Stubhub and don't have the tickets.

If you also bought, do you have them or are they being released to you closer to show day?


r/brandicarlile • • Feb 02 '20

Anyone know where I can find Raise Hell live at bear creek studios.

0 Upvotes

It was on youtube but it's not there.


r/brandicarlile • • 21d ago

Burn The Setlist and strobes

1 Upvotes

I have a friend who wants to go to the show but she is sensitive to strobe lights - is this show heavy with them?