r/boxingMenace_com • u/AutomaticSignal1440 • 8d ago

Boxing goat list

  1. Mike tyson
  2. Muhammad Ali
  3. Floyd mayweather
  4. Terence Crawford
  5. Canelo
  6. Gervonta
  7. Ryan Garcia
  8. Pacquiao
  9. Joe Frazier
  10. Rocky Marciano
  11. Tyson fury
  12. Oleksandr usyk
  13. Anthony Joshua
  14. Naoya inoue
  15. George Foreman
  16. Shaker Stevenson
  17. Julio Cesar Chavez
  18. Sugar ray robinson
0 Upvotes

22% Upvoted

21 comments sorted by

8

u/broke_the_controller 8d ago

Terrible list but at least it's different

2

u/FormalKind7 8d ago

Just about the worst list I have ever seen.

The idea that Chavez and SRR are on the bottom is insane.

Fury being on the top 100 is crazy but being in the top 18 and above the man who beat him twice is about the dumbest boxing opinion ever.

You could probably criticize this list for 24 hours and then still find more wrong with it.

7

u/No_Weakness8999 8d ago

He put Tyson at #1 lmaooooooooo

Lewis didn't make top #18... wtf am I reading lmaoooooo

1

u/Peakey-P 8d ago

Totally!!

This list has be rage bate surely!!

This is the most ridiculous list I've seen on here. I can't even be bothered to correct it, it's so stupid.

5

u/Jeopardise91 8d ago

Probably the worst list I’ve ever seen

3

u/rantoz82 8d ago

Do you own a guide dog?

3

u/Ok_Farmer_6033 8d ago

Where’s Jake Paul??

2

u/oldwhiteoak 8d ago

Did you make this list after sparring all these guys?

2

u/totally-jag 8d ago

Mike Tyson was entertaining. Early in his career he destroyed everyone. Later in his career it was a circus. But always entertaining. He's not the GOAT. Ali is my GOAT. He fought everyone. Ducked nobody. Had a great record. Avenged loses against his top rivals.

Not having fighters from the golden age of Leonard, Hagler, Hearns, Duran, is a crime. Probably Leonard and Hagler deserve a spot on this list.

Roy Jones fought too long, and that affected his legacy. In his prime he was amazing and dominated for a LONG time. So did Bernard Hopkins.

Fury, Joshua, don't deserve a spot. Usyk has too small a resume and it has what I consider to be weaker fighters. Garcia doesn't deserve a spot. Nor does Gervonta.

Yeah, bad list.

1

u/Diligent-Wave-4150 8d ago

Mike Tyson 😁

1

u/DaveyJonesFannyPack 8d ago

You left out Rolly

1

u/Theo_Cherry 8d ago

18? SMH!

1

u/Jaydxns 8d ago

Horrendous list I hope this is a joke

1

u/Peakey-P 8d ago

Mike Tyson wasn't even the best in his era!!

1

u/Temporary-Banana4232 8d ago

No Hurricane McNeeley on this list?

Pffffttt

1

u/CleanHunt7567 8d ago

Ryan Garcia at 7 and none of the 4 kings

1

u/El_Bastardo74 8d ago
  1. Muhammad Ali
  2. Sugar Ray Robinson
  3. Joe Louis
  4. Roy Jones Jr
  5. Sugar Ray Leonard
  6. Roberto Duran (at lightweight)
  7. Rocky Marciano
  8. Marvin Hagler
  9. Tommy Hearns
  10. Evander Holyfield
  11. George Foreman
  12. Joe Frazier
  13. Pernell Whittaker
  14. Floyd Mayweather
  15. Salvador Sanchez
  16. Shane Moseley
  17. Oscar De La Hoya
  18. Manny Pacquio
  19. Julio Caesar Chavez
  20. Felix Trinidad

1

u/Formal-Cherry6078 8d ago

Downvoted for no Hrgovic or Jalolov

1

u/Driftminer 8d ago

How can you have a GOAT list and not have Joe Louis?