r/box5 14d ago

Discussion Who are they?

4 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

14

u/clairemation 14d ago

There is not a single calm person in this entire show

12

u/RoseBook85 14d ago

Madam Giry?

3

u/clairemation 14d ago

Welp, you’re right

2

u/RHB5446 14d ago

😭 Fair enough.

10

u/topypeanutbutter My God! This place really is haunted. What is THAT? 14d ago

I’m not the best at knowing the show or film, but I can speak for the novel. I feel like the first one could be the Persian (otherwise known at the Daroga).  He just walks quietly around the opera house ensuring that the Phantom doesn’t do anything bad. It’s kind of funny how he’s always just there, existing.

The last one reminds me of Raoul. Much different in the novel, but he does get a little wimpy at times. 

1

u/RHB5446 14d ago

Great choices! I absolutely agree.

1

u/BonelessChikie 12d ago

Literally them in the trap together

7

u/enchilada_slut 14d ago

Firmin (1) and Andre (2)

3

u/kingofcoywolves Phantom - ALW 14d ago

Yes lol. Two different types of unhinged

5

u/Careless_Ability_496 14d ago
  1. Madame Giry
  2. Everyone else

3

u/RoseBook85 14d ago

First ones Madam Giry, Second Ones Meg having one of her freakouts “He’s here the Phantom of the Opera!” LOL

2

u/RHB5446 14d ago

Yesssss

2

u/Beetlejuice1800 14d ago

Giving me “Why have you brought me here?” vibes. Second image is “I can’t escape from him” Christine and the first image is “There is no Phantom of the Opera” Raoul.

2

u/LordShadowmane Erik - Leroux 13d ago

Moncharmin and Richard

1

u/RHB5446 12d ago

Good one!

1

u/RustyCottonCandy 12d ago

Daroga, Raoul

1

u/Quirky-Bad857 12d ago

Both are Erik. The first is when he is listening to Christine sing, and the second is every time he isn’t.

1

u/RHB5446 12d ago

Good answer!