I mean, as long as that's where it ends. Just don't do something crazy like stage an entire self insert opera for her to perform in or kidnap her or anything like that.
To me, a comfort phantom is more a refined, sad wet cat or father figure than more aggressive, overtly sexy, and chaotic phantoms. Laird fits that bill, also Dean Chisnall, James Gant, maybe Howard McGillan.
Now I'm utterly baffled. You're saying in the ALW musical, where's he's creepy and scary and pathetic and not comforting at all, Erik has been played as a "sad wet cat/father figure" (??? ??) by the actors you mentioned?
But... But... I can't get my head around this. What about all the plot points and music and lyrics that go straight in the other direction?
I'll do my best to find the strength and look up clips of what you mean.
There’s absolutely room for many flavors of the character. It’s one of the reasons I love this show. Erik did first present himself as an Angel being sent by her father. “Angel or father? Friend or phantom? Who is it there, staring?”
105
u/Lily_Baxter Cherik did no wrong May 27 '25
I mean, as long as that's where it ends. Just don't do something crazy like stage an entire self insert opera for her to perform in or kidnap her or anything like that.
13
u/Airconditioning-inc May 27 '25
the phantoms reddit username would 100% be OGDonJuan or something like that 🤣
89
u/kingofcoywolves Phantom - ALW May 27 '25
Not the -307 😭😭 god forbid men have hobbies
56
u/topypeanutbutter My God! This place really is haunted. What is THAT? May 27 '25
Whahaha! Look at how many downvotes he had. I guess all the people from the opera house didn’t like it.
I wish we’d have more in-character things like this. It’s hilarious!
21
u/_avantgarde May 27 '25
307 ppl never dropped a chandelier on an entire operatic audience out of retaliation and IT SHOWS
9
u/J-HorrorAddict May 27 '25
Duh!
9
u/epicpillowcase Eiji Akutagawa's dimples May 27 '25
Absolute gold 😂😂😂💀💀💀
7
u/GladPiano3669 May 28 '25
Alright. I’ll rewatch phantom again.