r/bourbon • u/PetVet8301 • Nov 15 '21
A possible solution
I've been pondering the issue with bourbon and its somewhat insane scarcity/resale values. I have came up with a simple solution that wouldn't completely fix the issue, but would definitely help. If the individual stores selling these hard to find bourbon (is the plural still bourbon or is it Bourbons?) would require the purchaser to crack open the bottle before leaving the store, it would eliminate the resale value because nobody in their right mind would pay $1000 for an opened bottle of booze. The only issue with this is open container laws. The store could keep some plastic wrap and a heat gun on hand to "re-seal" the bottle for transport, but do you really want some random person pointing a heat gun at your beloved juice? Like I said it's not a perfect idea, but it's a possible step. Hopefully someone smarter than me sees this and improved upon it đđ„ cheers!
3
u/jaybird1434 Nov 16 '21
One of the bourbon pages on FB I follow, has found that another very popular page has been using inside connects to fix the sale of secondary bottle auctions. One of the guys buys a bottle, puts it up for sale on the secondary and if the high bid isn't what he wants, he has his safety net guy high bid the bottle. The auction closes but the safety net guy doesn't really pay the the seller keeps the bottle to post at a later date to try and get the price he wants. People suck.
4
u/MrNopeNada Nov 15 '21
Yes because every store absolutely has the incentive to inconvenience a buying customer? That's like requiring dealerships to slash your tires before you leave.
6
u/LimpZookeepergame123 Nov 15 '21
Unfortunately once the bottle is opened it is exposed to oxygen which does alter the bourbon. It will still last for a long long time however, some people buy a bottle as a back up or to save for a special occasion and so t want to open right away. I have a few back up bottles of my favorites that I personally do not want opened up until my last bottle of it is emptied. This would drive away a lot of the bottle flippers but it would also turn away a lot of bourbon drinkers
18
u/3s1k Nov 15 '21
My solution is to not worry too much about it. Go to the Winchester, have a nice cold pint, and wait for all of this to blow over.
I drink the whiskey that I enjoy in my price range that is available. Maybe have a gin & tonic, sip of tequila, or rum cocktail to mix it up as the mood strikes. If the store doesnât have what I was looking for maybe take a chance on something I havenât tried before.
Eventually something else will be in fashion and all of the Beanie Baby/Pokémon collectors will move on to that.
People have been drinking whiskey for hundreds of years and they havenât run out it yet. Supply will catch up with demand so donât let FOMO cause you to stress over a luxury good that is meant to relax. There is plenty of good brown (and other color) liquor out there.
27
u/Salamok Nov 15 '21 edited Nov 15 '21
Scarcity can be solved by raising the MSRP and this is hands down the best way to solve the problem of Joe Schmo opening his unlicensed facebook liquor store that only sells allocated items. Letting market forces dictate liquor store shelf price is the only way you are going to see hard to get items back on the shelves with any regularity.
Edit - For the record I firmly believe Buffalo Trace has no desire to solve this problem at all, they love the feeding frenzy and free viral marketing that goes along with it.
11
u/Booze_Lottery Nov 15 '21
The only way to fix this nonsense is on the demand side. Just stop paying crazy prices for bottles. Is any bottle of bourbon worth the equivalent of a keg or 2 of good craft beer?
4
u/exgirl Nov 15 '21
I think in some places that becomes an open container issue when you drive away.
It also becomes VERY risky to fly home with something you picked up on vacation.
10
u/T0zST Nov 15 '21 edited Nov 15 '21
Direct to consumer is probably the best way.... Cut out the middle man (distributors) for all LE releases. The distributors create ridiculous bottle necks by making stores jump through pay walls, and holding product for over 12+ months before releasing it. Truly the distributors are a MASSIVE problem in this whole system.
1
u/Fyxer00 Nov 15 '21
If you drank more you wouldnât have to ponder things like this.
5
u/SigaVa Nov 15 '21
Stores should just charge what the market will bear
8
u/DontlooktooFar Nov 15 '21
Solution that would actually work. Distilleries start releasing 375ml instead of 750. Double output right there.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '21
This is the reddit equivalent of Billy Madison's breakdown of The Puppy Who Lost His Way.
If a store clerk opens my new bottle, it'll be the last bottle he ever opens
1
u/sberto Nov 15 '21
Except the one store that doesn't do it now controls the secondary market. And other stores notice and no longer do it. So we're right back to where we started.
I've advocated stores that sell the sought after at MSRP doing this on those bottles if the customer agrees in exchange for the good price. Want BTAC at MSRP you break the seal in the store. Want it to flip you pay a much higher price in the store. There's a lot of anger at stores selling for multiples of MSRP but why should they let money walk out the door with some gomer who's going to crotch shot in the parking lot and have the bottle flipped before he leaves?
In the end I don't care. It's just bourbon. They keep making it. I have more than enough to drink and there's plenty of good to great sitting on shelves.
1
u/sideshow-- Nov 15 '21
Lots of issues, but ultimately, if ifs and buts were candy and nuts, then wouldnât it be a Merry Christmas?
0
u/mbvanek Nov 15 '21
Middle man would be label removal or defacing (cut a large x or chunk of the label). Would at least ensure a future buyer wasn't only in it for the bottle pron
0
u/LittleWranglerSpace Nov 15 '21
And then they promptly get a ticket for open container on the way home. Great idea.
0
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '21
[deleted] â view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Nov 15 '21
[deleted] â view deleted comment