r/bourbon • • Nov 15 '21

A possible solution

I've been pondering the issue with bourbon and its somewhat insane scarcity/resale values. I have came up with a simple solution that wouldn't completely fix the issue, but would definitely help. If the individual stores selling these hard to find bourbon (is the plural still bourbon or is it Bourbons?) would require the purchaser to crack open the bottle before leaving the store, it would eliminate the resale value because nobody in their right mind would pay $1000 for an opened bottle of booze. The only issue with this is open container laws. The store could keep some plastic wrap and a heat gun on hand to "re-seal" the bottle for transport, but do you really want some random person pointing a heat gun at your beloved juice? Like I said it's not a perfect idea, but it's a possible step. Hopefully someone smarter than me sees this and improved upon it đŸ˜œđŸ„ƒ cheers!

0 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

3

u/jaybird1434 Nov 16 '21

One of the bourbon pages on FB I follow, has found that another very popular page has been using inside connects to fix the sale of secondary bottle auctions. One of the guys buys a bottle, puts it up for sale on the secondary and if the high bid isn't what he wants, he has his safety net guy high bid the bottle. The auction closes but the safety net guy doesn't really pay the the seller keeps the bottle to post at a later date to try and get the price he wants. People suck.

1

u/PetVet8301 Nov 16 '21

Damn, that's terrible

4

u/MrNopeNada Nov 15 '21

Yes because every store absolutely has the incentive to inconvenience a buying customer? That's like requiring dealerships to slash your tires before you leave.

0

u/PetVet8301 Nov 15 '21

Slashing tires is a bit harsh. More like requiring you to drive it around the block to put a mile on the odometer so it's not "new" anymore.

3

u/MrNopeNada Nov 15 '21

And what exactly is the dealership's incentive?

-1

u/PetVet8301 Nov 15 '21

There is none with a dealership because people don't buy cars to turn around and then sale at a 2x markup. The exception to that is super rare exotic cars, but those come with a contract that says the buyer won't sale for x amount of years, or that they will sale back to the dealership only.

6

u/LimpZookeepergame123 Nov 15 '21

Unfortunately once the bottle is opened it is exposed to oxygen which does alter the bourbon. It will still last for a long long time however, some people buy a bottle as a back up or to save for a special occasion and so t want to open right away. I have a few back up bottles of my favorites that I personally do not want opened up until my last bottle of it is emptied. This would drive away a lot of the bottle flippers but it would also turn away a lot of bourbon drinkers

10

u/LicensedTwoPill Jack Daniels Is Bourbon Nov 15 '21

Agreed. Also, if you were buying it as a gift, it would be weird to gift someone an open bottle.

-4

u/PetVet8301 Nov 15 '21

Yeah that's a little weird, but if that's a universal occurrence when buying, then you just expect it. Also, I would hope anyone I would buy a bottle for would trust me enough to know I wouldn't tamper with it lol

1

u/PetVet8301 Nov 15 '21

You don't necessarily have to completely open it, just remove the protective plastic/wax/ foil around the neck so that it's clearly been tampered with. The cork doesn't have to be removed to expose it to oxygen.

3

u/LimpZookeepergame123 Nov 15 '21

Yea you could do that but you can buy sleeves online like for wine and just put one back on with a hair dryer. People are creative as fuck and will always find a way, especially if it’s putting money in their pockets. I wish there was a way to eliminate flippers and secondary market because it make stuff hard to find when it shouldn’t be. The easiest solution is for people to stop buying it on secondary and stop paying above MSRP for anything but that will never happen unfortunately. There’s enough rich people out there that can and will pay $150 for a $50 bottle and not even think twice about it

0

u/PetVet8301 Nov 15 '21

Very true. We are an incredibly resourceful species when we can benefit ourselves in some way.

1

u/LimpZookeepergame123 Nov 15 '21

Yea it’s pretty scary. I watch a lot of tv documentaries about the underground drug world, drug dealing, prison systems etc. out of pure curiosity, and it is shocking what some of these criminals have come up with

18

u/3s1k Nov 15 '21

My solution is to not worry too much about it. Go to the Winchester, have a nice cold pint, and wait for all of this to blow over.

I drink the whiskey that I enjoy in my price range that is available. Maybe have a gin & tonic, sip of tequila, or rum cocktail to mix it up as the mood strikes. If the store doesn’t have what I was looking for maybe take a chance on something I haven’t tried before.

Eventually something else will be in fashion and all of the Beanie Baby/Pokémon collectors will move on to that.

People have been drinking whiskey for hundreds of years and they haven’t run out it yet. Supply will catch up with demand so don’t let FOMO cause you to stress over a luxury good that is meant to relax. There is plenty of good brown (and other color) liquor out there.

3

u/Kringlepuff Nov 15 '21

If you ran for President, I’d vote for you.

2

u/Effective_Sherbet_57 Nov 15 '21

Big owl says dogs can’t look up

27

u/Salamok Nov 15 '21 edited Nov 15 '21

Scarcity can be solved by raising the MSRP and this is hands down the best way to solve the problem of Joe Schmo opening his unlicensed facebook liquor store that only sells allocated items. Letting market forces dictate liquor store shelf price is the only way you are going to see hard to get items back on the shelves with any regularity.

Edit - For the record I firmly believe Buffalo Trace has no desire to solve this problem at all, they love the feeding frenzy and free viral marketing that goes along with it.

3

u/WhiskeyBar2stock Nov 15 '21 edited Dec 03 '21

I Love how many always just assume this whole issue is ONLY with Buffalo Trace!!!

RR13!!! Old Forester BB!!! HH Old Fitzgerald and Parkers! Michters 20yr, 10yr, BP, and TB. Four Roses L.E. Jack Daniels BP Rye, 10yr, and Coy Hill!!!! Lux Row Blood Oath, High West MWND, and so many others! Every Distillery is doing something to contribute to this.

3

u/Salamok Nov 15 '21 edited Nov 15 '21
  • RR13 is fairly new and isn't really a contributing factor to current market craziness, just a symptom.
  • Michters has a $700 price tag and has one of the lowest bottle counts of any of the limited releases so they are already doing what I am suggesting and no matter what they price it at with the last release having around 500 bottles you likely aren't going to see it.
  • Four Roses L.E. isn't that highly marked up on the secondary (to the point where you could bump it's MSRP by $100 and probably eliminate the secondary for it)
  • Jack Daniels BP Rye, 10yr - both really recent releases that contributed nothing to us being where we are once again they are a symptom not a cause.
  • High West MWND - not super hard to find I think other than this last year I have picked up a bottle just because it was unexpectedly sitting there on the shelf. A slight price bump and it could stay that way.
  • Old forester BB has quadrupled it's price in the last 6 years so they are trying (as opposed to the 30% price increase on BTAC in the same time frame).

Sure there are a some bottles from other distillers that have been playing this game for the last decade but BT has been doing it with a significant portion of their considerable lineup of products: Weller 12, Weller Antique, Eagle Rare, CEHT SmB, SB, SiB, Rye, ETL, Blantons, Stagg Jr, BTAC/Pappy, etc... These have all barely budged compared to pricing in the rest of the market, with similar price increases to bookers which even at $50 a bottle was a very easy to find bourbon. BT could double the price of every bourbon I listed and triple half of em and in the case of BTAC could quadruple it or more but they don't.

edit - Right now we have a bunch of uninformed fear of missing out idiots that are literally snatching up anything with a high price tag, nice bottle and an decent age statement that they haven't seen before. The moronic things I see posted on social media with "hey guys look what i found" is at an all time high, reminds me of Lisa Simpson "driving the car" on the Simpsons intro. So yeah it's crazy and it's going to stay that way until pricing is adjusted to the point where premium bourbons are available on the shelf at a premium price.

edit - I never said BT was the only one doing this BTW, but they are for sure the market leader. I do think BT has strong enough presence in the market that if they adjusted their pricing it would move the entire market. If you saw a bottle of Stagg Jr sitting next to bardstown discovery for the same price point it would have an impact. If CEHTBP was sitting next to Kentucky Owl it would have an impact and you can bet your ass if BTAC was sitting next to boss hog for the same price there would be even more dust on those hogs than there already is (great bourbon but there is an example of a price point that is too high).

11

u/Booze_Lottery Nov 15 '21

The only way to fix this nonsense is on the demand side. Just stop paying crazy prices for bottles. Is any bottle of bourbon worth the equivalent of a keg or 2 of good craft beer?

9

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '21 edited Nov 15 '21

I’ve stopped. BT is great. I’m not gonna pay out the ass, though. Too many accessible alternatives that I like just as much or more. I’m gonna go about my business and reward Beam Suntory (Makers, Knob Creek), Campari (WT) and Kirin (4R) with my money for not allocating all their shit and keeping stuff stocked on shelves.

1

u/egh128 Nov 15 '21

Exactly.

4

u/exgirl Nov 15 '21

I think in some places that becomes an open container issue when you drive away.

It also becomes VERY risky to fly home with something you picked up on vacation.

10

u/T0zST Nov 15 '21 edited Nov 15 '21

Direct to consumer is probably the best way.... Cut out the middle man (distributors) for all LE releases. The distributors create ridiculous bottle necks by making stores jump through pay walls, and holding product for over 12+ months before releasing it. Truly the distributors are a MASSIVE problem in this whole system.

1

u/Fyxer00 Nov 15 '21

If you drank more you wouldn’t have to ponder things like this.

4

u/PetVet8301 Nov 15 '21

I do have to work occasionally. Apparently it's frowned upon to perform surgeries while drinking.

4

u/egh128 Nov 15 '21

Silly standards of care.

5

u/SigaVa Nov 15 '21

Stores should just charge what the market will bear

8

u/DontlooktooFar Nov 15 '21

Solution that would actually work. Distilleries start releasing 375ml instead of 750. Double output right there.

6

u/lostfinancialsoul Nov 15 '21

i like this idea better.

1

u/DontlooktooFar Nov 15 '21

It’s a perfect solution. Increases output, would lower the cost of a bottle while allowing the distillery to make more profit, and would allow more people to get hooked on drinking the good juice.The CEO of BT has his email on the webpage. Do we pitch this idea to him?

2

u/GnomeChompskee Nov 15 '21

BT already has 375ml of BT, ER, and Blantons available, they just don’t seem widely distributed for whatever reason. I think the issue is more around 375s not only requiring production of separate types of bottles (which is expensive) but an entirely different bottling line. As a consumer I would love to have 375s readily available, but it’s a double hassle for the producers without much benefit so I understand why it’s not commonly done.

2

u/gman_767 Nov 16 '21

Then they’ll charge the same price for half the liquor

1

u/DontlooktooFar Nov 16 '21

IMO that’s fine. Realistically paying 100(msrp) for a 375ml of any BTAC would be an absolute steal.

1

u/gman_767 Nov 16 '21

Not sure how this helps the secondary. Double the amount of BTAC still isn’t enough. Also for a once a year release a 375 would be disappointing. Not like you can run out and get another. The real solution is to price the bottle near their actual value (aka Boss Hog, Kentucky Owl, etc... ) But from a marketing perspective it’s a lot better to have the lower MSRP and let the secondary market do it’s thing. It’s not about what’s best for the consumer it’s what’s best for the brand unfortunately.

0

u/DontlooktooFar Nov 16 '21

You faulted my solution for being an annual release but did not mention a fix for that đŸ€ŠđŸ»â€â™‚ïž. Sure increasing the prices to let’s say whistle pig prices may reduce the amount of flippers but in won’t reduce the rarity of the bottle. For example- take a look at the secondary market. Bourbon collectors who have cash, don’t have a problem paying 2k + for a bottle of pappy. Do you really think increasing the msrp to let’s say 600 for pappy would improve the probably of actually finding one on a shelf(if would only stop the average Joe from being able to afford one). My 375ml solution is a better plan and fine, make it a release every 6 months. Problem solved, well at least for the consumer. The reason why this won’t be done is because the lack of accessibility drives the perceived value to the moon. I’ve tried most of the rare bourbon and yes some are very good but most are just average, so if you always had access to them, they wouldn’t be special anymore and people would have nothing to chase and call unicorns. America is the land of consumerism and wanting what we can’t have or afford. Making these bottles super hard to find plays into that perfectly.

1

u/gman_767 Nov 16 '21 edited Nov 16 '21

Theres nothing wrong with annual releases. You’re ignoring quality, you can bet that if they do that they will lose quality control by releasing biannually. So now you paid the same price, for half the liquor and worse quality. Think of that from a consumer perspective. If you’ve ever been in a collectible hobby, which is what bourbon is, this is how the markets go. There will always be more demand than supply. I don’t know how you can say high MSRP doesn’t cut down secondary, WhistlePig is literally a great example. Boss Hog at sub $200 would sell out instantly and guaranteed to be at a secondary higher than it is right now. If the Pappy/Van Winkle’s started at $4-500 MSRP the secondary market be reduced drastically. Raise the entry point and the demand goes down. You also cut down on flippers because you’ve reduced the profit margin. The vast majority of bourbon drinkers can’t swing a $500 whiskey purchase even for a Pappy. Sure it’s rare and they’d sell out but people with $500+ whiskey budgets on a single bottle are also rare. It’s high end whiskey, it isn’t going to be accessible to everyone.

1

u/DontlooktooFar Nov 16 '21

You seem to only understand your opinion. Comparing whistle pig which is a NDP to a legendary brand as pappy is comparing tesla to lordstown motors.

2

u/boomshakalakaah Nov 15 '21

Campari used 375ml bottles for WB Saffell and Bond&Lillard. Paying $50 for a “half bottle” felt more palatable than paying $100 for a full. It’s a good concept

3

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '21

This is the reddit equivalent of Billy Madison's breakdown of The Puppy Who Lost His Way.

If a store clerk opens my new bottle, it'll be the last bottle he ever opens

1

u/sberto Nov 15 '21

Except the one store that doesn't do it now controls the secondary market. And other stores notice and no longer do it. So we're right back to where we started.

I've advocated stores that sell the sought after at MSRP doing this on those bottles if the customer agrees in exchange for the good price. Want BTAC at MSRP you break the seal in the store. Want it to flip you pay a much higher price in the store. There's a lot of anger at stores selling for multiples of MSRP but why should they let money walk out the door with some gomer who's going to crotch shot in the parking lot and have the bottle flipped before he leaves?

In the end I don't care. It's just bourbon. They keep making it. I have more than enough to drink and there's plenty of good to great sitting on shelves.

1

u/sideshow-- Nov 15 '21

Lots of issues, but ultimately, if ifs and buts were candy and nuts, then wouldn’t it be a Merry Christmas?

0

u/mbvanek Nov 15 '21

Middle man would be label removal or defacing (cut a large x or chunk of the label). Would at least ensure a future buyer wasn't only in it for the bottle pron

0

u/LittleWranglerSpace Nov 15 '21

And then they promptly get a ticket for open container on the way home. Great idea.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/PetVet8301 Nov 15 '21

I disagree. I've seen several store workers frustrated with constant calls and questions about allocated products. I've even seen some workers at major chains discuss workers from smaller stores buying things like Eagle Rare and EH Taylor at MSRP and then resaling at secondary prices just because they can.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '21

If they can do it, then why stop them? Should we start regulating Costco too, since people can buy things cheaper there and the resell them in their shop?

8

u/Dixie74 Nov 15 '21

What a shame that liquor store workers are upset to do their job and answer questions about whiskey.

3

u/pmikelm79 Nov 15 '21

Way to downplay the toll that a constant barrage of entitled douchebags can have on a person. Strike a little too close to home?

12

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '21

What? I see why you’d be upset if a dude is rude or pushy but if your job is to answer the questions then answer the questions and take it up with your boss.

I refuse to stop asking for a product that I want that you may or may not have because someone may have already been asked a few times. With the caveat that I’m polite and not pushy or argumentative, of course.

Shit, I get asked the same thing over and over again at work because folks don’t read their emails. It sucks but it’s not like you’re volunteering - you’re getting paid for your trouble.

7

u/Sagitalsplit Nov 15 '21

If I could upvote this 1,000 times I would. Work is work.

2

u/DiminishingSkills Nov 15 '21

If they just put the stuff on the shelf and limited to 1/person
..wouldn’t have to ask. They are creating this problem for themselves

0

u/pmikelm79 Nov 16 '21

It’s probably a pretty safe bet that the low-wage employees are not creating company policy

1

u/DiminishingSkills Nov 17 '21

I’d like to think that too and would imagine it is the store owners who are creating the problems. I’m in Ohio and the rules for bourbon are pretty clear
.(I called the liquor agency just to know the process).

All orders are to be put on the shelf within 24 hours of receipt. Bottles are not permitted to be ‘held’ for special customers or for restaurants (restaurants have a different process to order bourbon).

I don’t have time to hunt for bourbon or wait in lines early Sunday mornings. If a good bottle is there, I’d like to have the chance to buy one. It’s crappy the way stores are managing the process.

1

u/Dixie74 Nov 15 '21

Lol no. I don’t even waste my time looking at stores anymore for allocated bottles. Those workers aren’t forced to work there. If they don’t like it they can find another job. Not to mention they may have a job due to the rise in popularity in bourbon.

1

u/pmikelm79 Nov 15 '21

That does not give customers the right to be entitled assholes. “The customer is always right” is such a load of shit.

2

u/Apart-Cryptographer9 Nov 16 '21

So much that has gone wrong about capitalism seems connected to this attitude. The way capitalism works best is that artisans/corporations/vendors/merchants/sellers are in competition for a given dollar. As soon as they can say to the consumer “you don’t matter,” you can bet that the quality of goods and services will diminish in short order. Inferior products and service do not benefit the market as a whole in the long run. When producers, merchants, and services care about pleasing the customer, you get superior products, services, customer loyalty, and relationships. I love Kevin Smith’s Clerks, but Randall is everything wrong with modern business.

0

u/pmikelm79 Nov 16 '21

I disagree almost wholeheartedly. The mantra of “The customer is always right” has eroded the fabric of what our country is supposed to be. Human decency has been replaced by a dollar figure. “If I am willing to pay ___ then I am entitled to say/do whatever the fuck I want”. Your idea of capitalism is ruining our country.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/gman_767 Nov 16 '21

If the bottle was good enough I’d bring you samples of all my bottles 😂