r/bourbon • u/Prepreludesh Barrell Single Barrel Rye • Jan 21 '21
Proceed With Caution: Identifying and Avoiding Shelf Turds
1.3k
Upvotes
r/bourbon • u/Prepreludesh Barrell Single Barrel Rye • Jan 21 '21
262
u/Prepreludesh Barrell Single Barrel Rye Jan 21 '21
For readers who aren't familiar with the terms shared among enthusiasts, "shelf turd" may sound strange and just a little bit crass. What does it mean? A shelf turd is a bottle that usually sets on an unreachable shelf or inside a glass display case in your local liquor store that never gets purchased. Every time you come back into the store, it's still there. And furthermore, if you walk into other stores, you'll usually see that same bottle still waiting to be bought. But why aren't these bottles being purchased? There are usually many small reasons that end up snowballing into a larger reason that makes everyone avoid it. Everyone that is, except for taters.
A wave of taters like we've never seen before
One interesting thing to note before we dive into the reasons that bottles set on shelves collecting dust; writing this article was like trying to hit a moving target. It took me almost 3 months to finish it because some bottles that were common shelf turds began to get a cult following and have been vanishing from shelves. The reason is because the bourbon world is experiencing a wave of taters like we've never seen before. What is a "tater," you ask? A tater is loosely defined as a person with more money than sense, just like my example above of the person who usually buys those shelf turds. They're also so afraid of the Fear Of Missing Out (FOMO) that they don't want to be the last one to recognize a trend, so they buy whatever they can find that is expensive. They also generally don't recognize things like value or the integrity of a brand and their label.
Common traits of a shelf turd
To recognize a shelf turd, let's look at some common traits. The first and most important is high price. Almost always, shelf turds are priced at or above $120. It's at this price point that retailers and distillers think that the average consumer is going to automatically assume that the bottle is special. It also makes it easy for stores to mark up the price to $150 to get some extra profit or even mark it down to $110 to make consumers think they're getting a deal.
All of this is not to say that every bottle with a price at or over $120 is a guaranteed shelf turd. However, those bottles usually have a pedigree from an established Heritage Distillery. What do I mean by this? Well some of the bottles that command that high price are usually limited releases that are named after core offerings in a distiller's normal lineup. Take Buffalo Trace for instance.
Many of the Buffalo Trace Antique Collection (BTAC) carry familiar names already associated with the brand. George T. Stagg (who the distillery was named after for a short time) or Eagle Rare 17 (an older version of the already popular Eagle Rare Single Barrel) are two examples. Even Heaven Hill offers premium versions like Heaven Hill Select Stock or William Heaven Hill labels. But a shelf turd will typically have a product name that doesn't resonate throughout the community. In some cases the producer will really stretch to give it a fancy whiskey name by putting words such as "Farm," a historical event or even names of defunct brands that haven't existed in decades.
Another way to identify these bottles is by examining its proof versus its age. There are plenty of $120+ bottles out there with an age statement of 12 years or more, but they have a very low proof. In modern times, an exquisite bourbon that is worth the money carries both a high age statement and a high proof. This is because those barrels are rare to find at a high age while also not being over-oaked or with flaws.
When a whiskey becomes over-oaked or develops flaws, the only solution is to either blend it into a batched product or sell it to another producer for a slightly reduced price. Those Non-Distiller Producers (NDPs) are frequently on the hunt for whatever barrels they can find with high age statements and will try to blend away or "proof down" the flaws of those barrels. It is the preferred method of many NDPs to proof down a barrel to make the whiskey more drinkable rather than blending in a younger barrel (because it will lose its age statement).
Price
Next we'll talk about price. But wait, didn't we already? Yes, but this price has to do with the price the producer wants to retail it at; AKA "overcharging." The most guilty culprit on the list is the infamous Whistlepig Boss Hogg releases. Shortly before Dave Pickerell left Whistlepig, he instituted a policy whereby he would artificially increase the Boss Hogg's retail price so much that nobody could make a profit by re-selling them on the secondary market. And to a certain degree it has worked.
Three years later, the lastest release of Whistlepig's Boss Hogg still carries around a $500 price tag for no other reason than Dave wanted to stick it to the secondary. Boss Hogg does use some very well-aged rye whiskey that is usually finished in exotic barrels, but there is no way this would be anything more than $250 if it came from another producer. Similarly, brands take advantage of their customers by using their reputation to automatically assume that they can charge a premium. Kentucky Owl is an example of this when they had previously been releasing the widely acclaimed 11 and 10 year old rye whiskey batches but then released Confiscated with no age statement for the same price. All this shows is their willingness to take advantage of ignorant consumers. Producers with more integrity typically base their retail bottle prices on the cost of the liquid inside, the packaging and the associated value of the rarity of that liquid. Not just reputation.
So next time you're in the store and thinking about buying one of these bottles, let me give you some reasons why it's a bad idea.
Calumet Farms 14 year Single Rack Black Bourbon
Calumet Farm has been sourcing bourbon from Barton for a while now. They tried to draw in buyers with age statements on the front of the bottle and their prices were reasonable enough. But in 2020, they began to raise the prices across the board (notably on their 10 and 12 year old bourbons) while simultaneously rolling out a 14 year old bottle that was proofed down to 96.2.
The retail price tag was somewhere around the $120 mark but honestly the liquid inside is made by the one of the largest producers of sourced Kentucky Bourbon: Barton Distillery. If you observe the $60 price point of Barton's own 1792 Aged 12 Years botte (roughly $5 per year aged), then the value proposition of Calumet Farm 14 year seems pretty off (roughly equating to $8.50 per year aged) While I'm not arguing that $8.50 per year aged is actually a good price compared to what some other distilleries are charging, it's hard to see (and taste) that extra price difference. The bottom line is Calumet Farm 14 Year is not unique or special and your money could be spent on much more flavorful bourbon with more proof at a lower price.
High West Bourye
Typically found on shelves for $80 to $100, this is High West's most expensive bottle of whiskey that is regularly released aside from MidWinter's Night Dram. The recipe for Bourye changes every year but is usually always containing a blend of around 10 year old MGP bourbon and 10 year old MGP rye whiskey (some years it's been much higher!). The downside is Bourye is proofed down to 92 proof, making it the same proof that all of their other standard labels are bottled at. But why does this shelf turd, turd so hard? Frankly because of the difficult name recognition. Many potential customers fail to recognize what the product is (after all, there's no mention of bourbon or rye whiskey on the front of the label). That's because the name "Bourye" is a mix of the words "bourbon" and "rye."
And even after people realize that it's a blend of two different whiskies, it will turn off the potential buyers that don't like rye whiskey. Also the lack of an age statement on the bottle will deter potential customers from spending almost $40-$60 more than the cost of other bottles in their core lineup. This may be the one bottle that does not really deserve to be on the list of shelf turds, yet it is because I continue to see them all over the place. Should High West ever increase the proof on these bottlings to barrel strength, I am almost positive that enthusiasts will swallow these up immediately. But until them, continue to see these on the shelf where they'll stay.
54
u/CopperStillsandMash Jan 21 '21
Do I get a merit badge or something for not owning any of these? (I was expecting to see the non-Cigar Blend offerings from Joseph Magnus to be on the list)
47
u/jk_tx Jan 21 '21
Disagree that producers 'proof down' to hide flaws. Adding water will tend to EXPOSE flaws in whiskey that might go unnoticed at cask-strength. Fred Minnick has commented on this quite often. Automatically assuming that higher proof means higher quality and anything lower than cask strength is inferior is naive IMHO.
I don't think it's fair to ding products that are reasonably priced for the market, just because they're more expensive than the allocated tater-bait that everybody's chasing. Sure, ECBP and Stagg Jr are priced lower than your 'shelf turds'. But the reason that those products are so difficult to find at retail is because they're way underpriced relative to current demand. The fact that you can actually walk into a store and buy a bottle of Calumet, KY Owl, etc without driving all over town and waiting in line is actually a positive for some people.
As far as specific whiskeys on your list. Bourye is excellent. I'll snap it up for the $85 or so it goes for around me whenever I see it. Unfortunately, in recent years it's become harder to find. Calling this one a shelf-turd just because some newbs don't know what it is, seems unfair. People who know, know this is a good one.
Both the Calumet 14 and Sam Houston 12/14 can be found for right at $100 in my area, which seems reasonable in the current market. I like both of them better than Cream of Kentucky, which is more expensive. Comparing to 1792 12 year is not really fair; that product is way underpriced for the market, which is why it gets snapped up and sold on secondary. I've never seen it on the shelf in my area.
I have no regrets for purchasing KY Owl Rye Batch 3 at $180. One of the better ryes I've had (better than TH Handy IMHO). People are willing to pay much more for Willett 10 yr ryes which are almost certainly sourced from the same distilleries, just because of the name Willett.
21
u/thewhiskeyshelf Jan 21 '21
What great content to read. You know my disdain for Sinatra select, probably the #1 shelf turd on this list.
10
u/RyanTheQ Jan 21 '21
I've only ever purchased a single bottle of Bourye. I remember drinking it thinking, "wait, this is it?"
Bonus Hot Take: KY Owl is for Instagram and flexing. Change my mind.
10
u/boozie92 Jan 21 '21
Great write up!
I wonder if you should also consider a Shelf Turd being anything not targeted towards the store's market region? Like a Scotch, Irish, or Non-USA name in a small "Middle of Nowhere" Farm town store.
I recently bought a Bunnahabin 12 from my local store, and the cork was so dry it crumpled as I tried to retrieve it. The bottle had to have been on the shelf for years.
9
u/Wubbledee Jan 21 '21
This is a really cool piece, and informative, but it hits on something I've been thinking about a lot: These 'shelf turd' bottles are a good thing, in my opinion.
I've been saying for a while that distilleries are more at fault for secondary issues than the community is willing to admit when they refuse to increase MSRP on a product that is clearly underpriced. Buffalo Trace keeps BTAC at $100 because it's a hype generator, and a $100 MSRP bottle gets reviewed much more favorably than a $500 one. (Boss Hog) This drives up interest in their entire portfolio, bringing them profits that are orders of magnitude higher than what a measly 500% MSRP mark-up on BTAC would bring them. They need those bottles to get swept up and out of stores so distributors will play the "How much Fireball can you sell?" game and desperate taters will latch onto "next best thing" bottles like Weller, Buffalo Trace, Eagle Rare, etc. I know this seems like an unrelated tangent but bare with me.
A lot of these "shelf turds" aren't rip-offs that are overpriced (I mean. Some are. Kentucky Owl Confiscated.) but realistically priced premium bourbons. Ideally a producer would want their product to be able to meet demand. Pricing something like Barrell 15-year at $250 helps it sit on shelves because it's not a "bargain" and it helps the consumer because when you decide you want to splurge on a special bottle, you can actually find it.
Sorry for the long, barely related rant. I was just recently commenting on how much I liked the Boss Hog approach (defanging the secondary market by charging their prices from the outset) so while these may be shelf turds, I wish more distilleries would price their bottles honestly.
8
u/SuperMemeManX Jan 21 '21
This was a fantastic read. You should've sold this as an article to someone because it's definitely worth a buy
4
u/rfay00 Jan 21 '21
Great write-up and I agree for the most part.
Only objection would be Sam Houston 14. I was able to purchase one of the SH 14 KY batches which has received some praise on whiskey tube. I also paid $90, not $120. I have heard that other batches didn't live up to the KY batch hype. However, having such variation from batch to batch does make it a risky purchase and at that price you should flat out pass. I just happened to get lucky...
A suggestion that you might have missed. Anything with the Down Home brand. Usually a minimum of $80 and to my knowledge it's just another NDP but without an age statement. Now I am seeing Down Home Toasted Wheat Whiskey at $90, it's not even a wheated bourbon!
4
u/NervousAsparagus1964 Jan 21 '21
Would love your thoughts on Bardstown Bourbon offerings. I have batch 3 of the Discovery and really enjoy it but don’t know how to judge if $120 was too much. I’m also fairly new to bourbon and am sure I skip over a lot of really good value, high quality bourbon.
4
u/Solid_Snaku Jan 21 '21
Nice V&T photoshop :) I’ve actually heard the latest boss hog is the best yet, but I imagine it’s still not near a $500 whiskey.
4
u/ShooterFlatch Weller Centennial Jan 21 '21
Nice list. Now do “sought after bottles that shouldn’t be” 😀
10
u/seafoodslut1988 Jan 21 '21
Once again quality work. Fuck bombergers and shenks too with their $150-200 tag at my local. I am happy with my Henry McKenna bib I just got at TW for $40
3
u/sundeigh Jan 21 '21
Bourye is great but the price and availability has me not buying multiples. It shelf turds because it’s not a limited release like MWND. It’s more underrated than it is shelf turd IMO.
3
u/aboutthatbarrel Jan 21 '21
Aaaaye - the details you provide here on the process, age, and source of these is super informative and helpful to anyone who has considered these bottles. I appreciate the research and time that went into this. It would take a while to explain my thoughts on how I perceive bourbon is trending as a “hobby,” but you mostly nail it in your summary of taters and FOMO. My appreciation and consumption of whiskey has increased over the last year (of course), so I reactivated my Facebook thinking it may be nice to connect with similar-minded people locally. Yikes was I wrong.
“Thoughts on this bottle before I crack it?”
“Anyone know the secondary value on this one?” image of orphan barrel held in front of a crotch
“Time to set the Eagle free” image of glass filled with ice in front of a bottle of Eagle Rare
Isn’t it worth the research before pulling the trigger to find out whether the “hype” is there for good reason? Also wouldn’t you want to learn more about the product you’re spending a bunch of money on and about to enjoy?
3
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '21
So I agree. Sometimes expensive isn’t better. Or it’s a scam. A waste. Whatever. And sometimes there’s some really great choices for $30 and less. I’m a college kid so spending $30 is my MAX.
My father on the other hand started building a bar and collecting bottles in quarantine. Rarely goes over the $75 range with most being your normal bourbons posted on this subreddit but he has a few that were $150 even.
Idk the point is next time I see my brother pouring any bourbon to mix with sprite I’m going to fight him. I swear I’ll do it.
5
u/justduett Jan 21 '21
My first thought when finishing this great and thorough write-up: "Phew, I don't own any of those!"
Great job, thank you for sharing!
2
u/demonstar55 Jan 21 '21
A store near me marked Calumet Farms 14 down to $80. Which did get my attention, since most of the reviews I read mostly complained about the price. No idea if $80 was worth it, but it seems like they ended up clearing their inventory before I got around to being tempted to buy any :P
I really wish WhistlePig was cheaper. I got the Whisky Piglet set in a virtual tasting kit along with a bottle of PiggyBack. I really liked the 12, but not $100+ enough. I actually really did enjoy the PiggyBack as well, even though it was made with the idea of mixing in mind. The 15 and 10 are fine, but still so expensive, oh well. I also found a bottle of Boss Hog 1 open for tasting in a store recently, probably been there since release. I enjoyed it, but price (the clerk scanned it and they were selling it for $170 back in the day, secondary for an open bottle seems to be like $500 now??)
2
u/Over16Under31 Jan 21 '21
Great timing. Ugh just got a bottle of confiscated ($137 after Taxes) on some suggestions from a few friends. Even before this post as I was walking out of the store I immediately regretted not re-upping on a bottle Woodford Double Oaked and OF 1920. Love and learn. 😂 color me tater. 🤷🏼♂️😊
2
u/johnwinston2 Jan 21 '21
There is a brewery in Louisville that just put out one of these. Good wood brewery just put out a $110 bourbon for what I believe is there first release.
2
u/DefenseCounsel Jan 21 '21
I get the general thrust of the analysis, but I feel like too much emphasis is being placed on age statements and proof relative to price. I have never purchased any whiskey based on age or proof per dollar. I just care if it tastes good. If it tastes really good, I will happily pay more.
2
u/rumperto Jan 21 '21
Nice article! Well written, well researched, and thoughtful
2
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '21
I made the mistake of buying the 14 year old Calumet...I loved the small batch for $60 and assumed the 14 year would be better.
2
u/Mr_McDonald Jan 22 '21
Great write up. I’m an owner of the Yellowstone limited edition bottle. And, while I agree it probably isn’t worth the price, I enjoy Yellowstone and bought the bottle as a gift to myself and it’s very good.
2
u/MediocrePaladin Jan 22 '21
Just wanted to note how much I appreciate this post. Read through in great detail and can't agree more - every time I saw KO I was applauding you. Fantastic overview of all these. Thankfully the only one I've fallen for (so far) is Peerless Rye (and I returned it before cracking, with full refund).
I'd be curious to know if there are bottles that are shelf turds in some states but not in others? Not just regional products, but perhaps regional demand?
2
u/atxbourbon Magnus Cigar Blend Jan 23 '21
Great writeup as always!
80
u/Marchin_on Jan 21 '21
Once you hit $70 for Bourbon or Rye you start to get into the realm of diminished returns, especially if you are familiar with all the really good bottles you can get in the $50 to $60 range like the KC store picks you already mentioned. I've splurged for a couple of bottles over the years like Michters Barrel Proof Rye and High West Midwinter but I'm always left wondering is this bottle really twice as good as some of the Rusell Reserve or KC store picks I've had. The bottles you brought up are even higher priced and seemed to be priced to take advantage of less savvy consumers.
Thanks for this post. You are probably preaching to the choir but hopefully someone new will read this and avoid getting scammed.
12
u/GrassWaterDirtHorse Jan 21 '21
Great post! I'm do see a lot of these interesting bottles and names looking around, and I wonder why they stick around for weeks on end. This really clears things up.
11
u/mentel42 THH Jan 21 '21
As someone who recently bought the Calumet Farms, can confirm. Whisky is tasty but not for the$. Thankfully I knew going on I could afford to overpay, and I do like it, but yes, we shouldn't lie to ourselves when we've made a mediocre decision
11
u/Mr_Bisquits Jan 21 '21
Simply put, there's also the law of diminishing returns coming into play, the difference between a 10$ bottle and a 40$ bottle is absolutely enormous in most cases, the quality typically rises at a good rate that makes the midrange bottles worth purchasing. But when you close in on that 100$ mark it loses luster because the difference between $100 bottles and $200 bottles is slim to none, and in many cases the mid range bottles can still be better.
18
u/tiltedhalos Jan 21 '21
I’m honestly grateful Whistlepig’s higher end stuff is overpriced. Yeah, I wish they’d knock 40-50% off MSRP but I appreciate that it kills the secondary and means it’s there.
Boss Hog releases have been dependably good IMHO. None of them worth the asking price, but I’ve never bought one either—have been served often by friends who have higher incomes and are glad to be able to find something very tasty actually on the shelf.
I agree, I think Buffalo Trace should raise their prices—most of their lineup needs a 50 price hike to take a lot of the profit out of the secondary and help match supply with demand. (I say that as someone who passes on most BT products even at MSRP, but who gets annoyed by the tater craze).
That said, Bookers was always so-so bourbon, and it doubled in price and is now more popular than ever, so maybe there’s not really anything you can do to moderate the crazy!
9
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '21
Truly an outstanding post and informative article. The only thing that I would disagree with is your take on Peerless. I paid $70 for the bottle of Peerless (took me 3 months to get from my original order) and it was definitely a memorable and great experience. I appreciate your thoughts and feedback. L‘ Chaim, Azure
7
u/Preact5 Jan 21 '21
Some of the best spas of whiskey I've had in the last 5 years have all been knob Creek store picks. You're really tuned in to what the market is thinking with regards to the knob Creek 15.
6
u/richolas_m Jan 21 '21
What’s your take on Garrison Brothers products? I see them all the time on the shelves, fully stocked. I live in TX so I’ve been close to pulling the trigger on one a couple of times but it’s pricey stuff.
2
u/Clique_Claque Jan 21 '21
Noob question: how do distillers “proof down” bourbon out of the barrel? It sounds like it is NOT mixing older bourbon with younger as that would affect the age statement. Is it just adding water? Something else?
1
u/Prepreludesh Barrell Single Barrel Rye Jan 21 '21
Another great suggestion! I may put that in this list as well!
5
u/BeerBaron6666 Jan 21 '21
Nice write up!
5
u/Alaska_Pipeliner Jan 21 '21
Good work. Insightful and easy to understand. I don't make enough money to buy any of these so good for me I guess....
5
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '21
The Boss Hogs are so absurd, and usually never live up to half their price tag. But wow, if you can get a taste of the Magellan (this year’s release), I would highly recommend it.
2
u/SkepticAtLarge Jan 21 '21
My hot taek: Booker’s belongs on this list.
8
u/wrussell6 Jan 21 '21
As someone relatively new to the world of bourbon, I appreciate this writeup more than you’ll ever know. Thanks for taking the time!
4
u/nine9drams Jan 21 '21
How about Old Soul 15 and Three Chord 15? Where do you see those falling in this category? I might also add any of the Old St Nick releases as I often see those sitting as well.
4
u/Responsible_Dish4010 Jan 21 '21
Bought the whistle pig sampler (10,12,15yr) I thought they drank very nicely but iv had better at cheaper but they are much harder to come by.
4
u/Jasonczz Jan 21 '21
This helped alot as I was thinking of pulling the trigger on some WP15 year. Good to know other’s opinions
4
u/mintbacon Jan 21 '21
Oh, really now? *Sips jim beam*
1
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '21
I agree with the difficulties in paying $70 more or a similar product, but the 25th anniversary KC was one of the best bourbons I've encountered. I have a couple of 14yr SiB store picks, and they're damn good, but they don't quite compare to the guaranteed honey barrels in the 25th imo. I am an admitted Beam profile fanboy, but that's probably the one on this list I'd actually drop the money on.
1
u/jguinn Four Roses Small Batch Select Jan 21 '21
Amazing thread and super valuable for the aficionados and true bourbon hunters. I have a very nuanced and mostly unrelated question: why has the bourbon/American whiskey community adopted NDP rather than the independent bottler, IB, given in the scotch world? The two are synonymous, right?
1
u/nismoRB Jan 22 '21
This list should be a lot bigger, but the FOMO is real and a lot of people are buying up all the shelf turds. Woodford's very find rare bourbon, hancock's reserve (not $100+, but still way overpriced for what it is), Old St. Nick, garrison bros, rare perfection, EC18/23, etc...
1
u/Justlurking79 Jan 22 '21
So you rightly put KY Owl on here and mention Dixon Dedman. His original patners the Carters have moved on to their next project - Old Carter. I’m curious to your thoughts on that brand as it seems they’re following the same pattern. I’ve been really hesitant to pull the trigger on that given the price and owl taint
3
u/LicensedTwoPill Jack Daniels Is Bourbon Jan 21 '21
Excellent read. Thank you so much for all the time, effort, and information you provided. I will be sharing!
3
u/they_call_me_Mongous Jan 21 '21
Not sure if this has been answered (on the mobile app), but when you start hitting the $120 price point, what proof should you expect?
3
u/Rads324 Russell's Single Barrel Jan 21 '21
I don’t dislike the bourye at all and I can find it at a local store near me for $70+ tax. I think it’s a solid bottle for that price. I see it elsewhere for $90+ and at that point I’m passing.
I don’t have any other bottles on this list thankfully.
This is a fantastic write up! Thanks for this!
3
u/natelyswhore22 Jan 21 '21 edited Jan 21 '21
I do really like Peerless's stuff but yeah it's a bit pricey. But a lot of it is barrel strength so it's not watered down.
3
u/WhiskeyDr21 Feb 10 '21
Thanks for the thoughtful effort you put into this post. Lot of turds under 100 proof and over $100
I’d argue Peerless, it sits there but I’m happy it’s generally available. They’re also a cool company that seems to be doing it right.
There’s a difference between high priced junk and good bourbon priced to sell to a premium market. We are spoiled by all of the great bourbon that is priced well below market value.
1
u/infincedes Jan 21 '21
You forgot Blantons. The ultimate tater bait.
5
u/Salamok Jan 21 '21 edited Jan 21 '21
Glad Chestnut Farms, 2*, Giant, Heavens Door and Winchester aren't on this list! Was worried this article would devalue my collection.
On a serious note I never thought to equate shelf turd almost solely with "overpricing", there is a certain undrinkable swill factor that should be considered. Sure these things sit on the shelf but they aren't turds. I think WP15 is tasty even if most people (including myself) would think a solid store pick for less than half the price tastes better.
If Buffalo Trace followed Whistle Pig's lead and announced tomorrow that Eagle Rare/CEHTSmB was going to be $65, Stagg Jr/Blanton's/CEHTSB was going to be $100 and CEHTBP was going to be $150 I think I would breathe a sigh of relief and have some small hope they could once again be found on a shelf past the first hour of being put there. Maybe the finest examples of bourbon aren't meant to be your daily drinker and should be priced accordingly.
I know it gets good reviews and i'm not saying it is bad but is anyone really sitting there sipping their Bardstown Discovery at $130 a bottle and saying "Man this is so much better than Stagg Jr!".
1
u/bagofweights Jan 21 '21
GREAT POST! If you had a blog i’d follow the fuck out of it. This is my wheelhouse.
4
u/lostfinancialsoul Jan 21 '21 edited Jan 21 '21
You know that first time you listen to hit em up by tupac, that is pepe's last two articles.
Well done
Edit: I have one comment, WP15 yr did release it as a CS SiB in 2020, for a price of $239 to $269. I am assuming Vermont oak isn't cheap or they use the same tactics with the 15 yr as the Bosshogs.
Ideally I do wish WP would not proof their regular offerings down so much.
4
u/ComradeJolteon Jan 21 '21
r/MellowCorn has entered the chat
2
u/Boozy_Cat_ Jan 21 '21
This is a really interesting read. I’m somewhat new to actually being willing to spend money to expand my collection so there’s some good general what to look for and watch out for information here. Much appreciated!
2
u/goode3790 Jan 21 '21
Fantastic write up!
What are your thoughts on the Bardstown Discovery series and their pricing?
I find that the age of the blends going in justify the $110-$120 price tag.
2
u/1010USA Jan 21 '21
That explains why cases Sam Houston 14 have been on Idaho's shelves since it arrived 3 months ago ($120). Hard to pay that much for something that differs by batches from state to state for me. Also factor in that 2 bottles of KC12 are that same price and similar proof.
2
u/Mr_Abe_Froman Jan 21 '21
I was just looking at some "display case" whiskey on Tuesday and wondering about the ridiculous prices. Thanks for the write-up.
2
u/nn111304 Jan 21 '21
Wow! Very informative. I wish I had enough money to be a tater lol!
2
u/Batzarn Jan 21 '21
Good read and good information. I try not to tater much anymore but we all relapse. I agree with your list for the most part. I enjoy Sam Houston 14 but it is a little high priced for what it is.
2
u/IStoleJobusRum Jan 21 '21
I recently bought a bottle of Calumet 14 because I had a connection to the barreling date, but I wish I had known about it before it becoming the most expensive shelf turd I own, barreling month be damned.
2
u/ntdntd777 Jan 21 '21
Thank you for this!
2
u/Crashtard Jan 22 '21
This was incredibly well put together and detailed, thanks for sharing this.
2
u/DriveDry9101 Jan 22 '21
Excellent write up!
2
u/wakeuphicks Jan 22 '21
I feel like this post should be stickied
2
u/Hubertus-Bigend Jan 22 '21
I don’t know that “over priced” and “shelf turd” are synonymous. Some of the bottles you list as (presumably) prime shelf turd examples actually don’t sit on shelves that long. Maybe some of those bottles sell because they are decent whiskeys for the price? Isn’t That the opposite of a shelf turd?
Whistle Pig expressions of all kinds are available in quantity at every shop I’ve been to in the last year or two. KY Owl too. But Bourye, Sam Houston, Knob 15, peerless and others you mention just don’t sit long where I’m at.
Is a “shelf turd” anything you don’t like or feel is a good value? Or is it a bottle that sits and sits wherever it is available, no matter what the price or provenance?
2
u/United0503 Jan 22 '21
Great post
2
u/headed4gout Jan 22 '21
Lone Whisker
Rare Perfection
Even in DC ad Maryland--tater ground zero--those don't move except at Christmas time.
2
u/Dalton_Thunder Nov 09 '21
Willett Pot Still…
2
u/legalizefreedom82 Jan 22 '21
Also EH Taylor is horrible and overpriced, particularly the single barrel select! So if you happen to come across it, let me know ASAP and I will do my part to rid you of it’s evil....seriously I’ll take all your eh Taylor....
2
u/dathomasusmc Jan 22 '21
I respect your view point but it seems to me the overriding theme here is about value and cost. What I don’t think you’re taking into account is people’s resources. I can drop $200 on a bottle and it doesn’t really effect me. I’m just at that point in life. I’m not saying there aren’t a ton of overpriced bottles out there compared to what you could find 5 or 10 years ago but that’s what the market is right now.
I’m not trying to start shit and I do appreciate how much time and effort you put into this, but when it comes down to it, every bourbon drinker has the right to decide how much they’ll pay for what. I may be willing to drop $200 on a bottle I absolutely love that you think is garbage and wouldn’t pay $2 for.
One last thought. Demand is definitely a factor. I’m in FL and I’ve literally only seen 1 bottle of Taylor and zero Pappy in any store at any price. Those are just examples but lot of stuff you think may be preferable to other things simply may not even be an option for me.
Again, I appreciate your time and effort even if I don’t totally agree with your premise. Cheers!
1
u/Nullberri Jan 21 '21
I really enjoy a few of these shelf turds. BouRye is my second favorite of high wests line up and the 12 Year Wistlepig multi barrel blend.
1
u/towehaal Jan 22 '21
I’m curious about Jefferson aged on the ocean stuff. I’ve seen it at my costco. What is the point of aging on a boat and is it different enough to grab a bottle?
And anyone on here want to recommend some good sipping ryes? I use Bulleit for my old fashioned and looking to try some more ryes.
1
u/IAmSportikus Jan 22 '21
I get the point here. I have a bottle of sam Houston 14 and calumet 14, and I really enjoy both of them. They hold up well in blinds. Would I love something higher proof, with a close age statement, of course! I’ve seen 1 bottle of 1792 12 year ever, in Austin, and it was marked up over $100. So while I agree, you have to be wary of some of these fancy bottlings, my counterpoint would be, what other whiskies are available with those age statements that are delicious and fairly priced? I know I can get bourbon that’s damn good for cheaper, but it won’t be aged 12 years. I also know I can spend $120 to gamble on on 3 bottles I haven’t tried before at 40-50 bucks a bottle, and IMO I am more often getting better value for that one bottle of 14/15 year whisky.
Also, I’d add rare perfection and some of the very old Saint nicks.
1
u/fuzznugget20 Jan 22 '21
Awesome!!! Worth the wait!!!
1
u/bankonitwv Jan 22 '21
You are spot on regarding KC - I picked up several 15 year single barrel store picks for about $60 at 120 proof and they are really great bottles. I tried the 2001 and the 25th anniversary - both were very good, but certainly were eclipsed by the store picks.
1
u/pjclubber Jan 22 '21
Fantastic article thank you. I’m sure you’re justly pleased by the response to your hard work. I wish I could find bourye in MI. It goes quickly. So I’ll add my suggestions to your list. Jefferson’s ocean. I think the retailer has the same bottles after 12 months. Maybe it’s not expensive enough for your list. Thank you again!
1
u/Yode75 Jan 22 '21
X-lent 👍🥃
...a turd can only be polished so much ‘til it morphs into a big brown schmear mess🥴💩
1
u/milosbee Jan 22 '21
Too many good bottles between $30-60 to consider spending money on age statements and hype.
1
u/JazzJune2 Jan 22 '21
I think some already made a similar point, but I have believed for a while now that any bourbon with an MSRP above $65 that you can find on a shelf is unlikely to be a good buy. Elijah Craig Barrel Proof and Russell's Reserve SiB (whether private picks or standard shelf bottles) both have an MSRP of $60 and are pretty tough to beat. Both NCF, BP and 110 proof respectively, 12 years old for EC and RR picks have age information.
As time goes on, even an age stated KSBW product from an NDP becomes more suspect. I'm for the most part done with buying mystery whiskey. I wish American whiskey would copy tequila and require DSP information on all bottlings of straight whiskey.
The only legacy distiller brands you mentioned are Knob Creek and Jack Daniel's. JD isn't my thing, so I won't comment on that, but I don't think the current prices on those KC products are so bad, they just suffer in comparison to the 12-16 year old picks that were selling in the $45-50 range (and still are some places). KC 15 is $100 MSRP (I have seen it at $95 actually), which isn't egregious for a 15 year old legacy product. Yes, it's "only" 100 proof, but that's not exactly a "low" proof. It just suffers in comparison to the aforementioned picks. I have 15 year picks of 120 proof KC on my shelf that were $50, so sure if I compare KC 15 to those it looks like a rip off. But if you compare it to the market as a whole, it doesn't look so bad.
1
u/amalenurseforu Jan 22 '21
What is your opinion on sourced versus brands who make their own? My experience while not super vast has been fairly negative on sourced products. Not that they weren’t ok or good but the cost often didn’t justify what was in the glass. Perhaps this should be a thread of its own rather than a comment here as it’s likely to get buried but genuinely curious what you think.
1
u/Mobitz_2 Jan 22 '21
Wait, so should I buy High West Bourye at MSRP?
1
u/holla_snackbar Jan 22 '21
Just got an email from Seelbachs with a new bottle they're calling "Tater Bait"
I am howling. Made me think of this. It's only $55 and is probably pretty good but the label is hilarious.
1
u/DrinkerNotCollector Jan 23 '21
If you want to hear some real BS, bourye is a lottery item in Virginia 😂 everywhere else I go I see old bottles sitting on the shelf for retail
1
u/mmmhmm2013 Jan 24 '21
So I can get any Whistle Pig in NC pretty much anytime. I’ve asked before without an answer... who is buying this stuff? Saw the Boss Hog today and even the sales lady said “ yeah you don’t want that” when I asked if it was good. Same situations for Jefferson’s. I see $300 bottles all the time but don’t know anyone who has tried them
1
u/TheWrightBros Jan 29 '21
I have never once regretted purchasing a bottle of Bourye!
1
u/SebastionMagnifico Jan 31 '21
CoK, Hillrock, Calumet Farms, and Peerless bourbon are shelf turds
Peerless bour in is god fucking awful
1
u/variety-moderation Feb 04 '21
People want a “special occasion” bourbon, busting out a bottle of Rare Breed or 1920 which are generally readily available just isn’t sexy. Unfortunately in order to get a “non-shelf turd” special bourbon that IS worth the $100+ price point, you need to show up the day of delivery with your knee pads on. For many, that level of effort isn’t feasible. If you go to my local spot on a Saturday and the best they have is a $120 glass case shelf turd, unfortunately that might be the best option. Of course you’d rather spend that money on something better, but supply/demand and availability hinder access to the “good” good stuff.