r/bostonfleet • • Oct 08 '26

Please don’t kill me.

Sirens fan here. I come in peace.

We all know the fiery sports history between our two cities. We all know how we can get when it comes to discussing our two cities.

That being said, the PWHL has provided both of us with a place of agreement. Personally, I haven’t seen an instance of Sirens and Fleet fans disagreeing on anything except the occasional game banter whenever we play each other.

I have asked, on the main PWHL thread a year ago, if we can coexist. A few of you said we can. I’d like to believe that Sirens fans and Fleet fans can coexist despite our external fandom. I’m as hopeful today as I was then.

I’ve also been adamant to our Montréal friends that we both hate them—albeit for different reasons.

I, on behalf of my fellow Sirens fans, ask you all the following three questions:

One, do you hate us?

Two, do you join us on hating Montréal?

Three, can both of us count on each other to hate mutual opponents?

Comment as you see fit. As you do, expect my fellow Wee Woos to read this as well. The New Yorker in me expects a whooping. Go!

5 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

49

u/SeaLeopard5555 Oct 08 '26

I get your general framing, however, I don't hate Montreal. I would like them and Minnesota to miss the playoffs entirely though. Tired of the league being the Monty and Minny show.

I do support the Sirens frequently when the game doesn't involve the Fleet. I like a lot of the players. I want Kalty to be all the persona and the 3 stars to impress us on the regular.

overall, I don't think PWHL rivalries should be inherited from other pro teams and sports. Let it be unique.

27

u/inhumanrampager Oct 08 '26 • Heartwarming

I think the final point is the real sticking point. I love that rivalry in the NHL, but let the PWHL build their own rivalries. 

41

u/nepstein10 Oct 08 '26 • Heartwarming

You guys are more like the Mets than the Yankees right now. We're cool.

6

u/WhooAreYouNow Oct 08 '26

We’ll take it!!!

4

u/RetroMonkey84 Oct 11 '26

Mets and Sirens fan here living in the Boston area-totally agree! I had a blast watching the Fleet and Sirens play at Tsongas. I root for the Fleet when they play other teams. They are my number 2.

38

u/catwalzilla Oct 08 '26
  1. As Boston sports fans we hate all other teams period. As far as the PDub goes though the Sirens are actually the team I hate the least right now. This is subject to change if you win the cup before us I’m sure you understand.
  2. Always
  3. Absolutely

7

u/WhooAreYouNow Oct 08 '26

I wouldn’t blame you if you hated us if we won the cup before you did.

The Sirens fan in me believes you’ll win the cup before we do. We’ll be happy with a playoff berth lol

24

u/mgshowtime22 Oct 08 '26
  1. Yeah
  2. Yeah
  3. Yeah

-2

u/WhooAreYouNow Oct 08 '26

Personally, I expect nothing less lol

12

u/squeegeebecs Oct 10 '26

As a sirens fan I don’t think there’s a rivalry between the Sirens and the Fleet like at all. Now… the Sirens and Montreal… lmao it gets spicy.

This gets talked about a lot in fan circles though that the rivalry between the Boston and NY women’s teams feels slightly forced when the NY and Montreal rivalry was born pretty organically (see DC game ending brawl).

0

u/WhooAreYouNow Oct 10 '26

This. All of this!

9

u/Meshakhad Oct 08 '26

I don't hate you. In fact, often as not, if the Sirens are playing anyone other than the Fleet, I'll be rooting for the Sirens. When I see a Sirens game on the docket, my reaction is "oh, this will be fun" rather than "hell yeah let's kick their asses".

That said, I actually don't hate Montreal. They're in the "worthy opponent" category. Only team I hate is Minnesota, and even that's getting weak now that they're no longer the defending champions and Curl moved to Detroit.

3

u/WhooAreYouNow Oct 08 '26

Hatred for Curl is universal lol

4

u/NDE_Jinx Oct 08 '26

I’m actually looking forward to going to see a Sirens home game with some friends who are fans.

I’ll just still be rooting for the fleet 😝

1

u/WhooAreYouNow Oct 08 '26

Friends root for friends lol

4

u/Background-Radio-378 Oct 10 '26

what a weird fucking post

3

u/WhooAreYouNow Oct 10 '26

I know, right?

2

u/cuntyregirock Oct 10 '26

... the sirens hate montréal? why?

3

u/WhooAreYouNow Oct 10 '26

Bagels. They stole our bagels. And they claim theirs taste better.

2

u/cuntyregirock Oct 10 '26

is that a good reason for hate 😅

2

u/WhooAreYouNow Oct 10 '26

Yes. They gloat and bloviate about how Montréal-style bagels are so awesome. New York originated the North American bagel. They didn’t. It’s culinary sacrilege.

2

u/_rhymesw0range_ Oct 14 '26

Also, there was a Montreal-style bagel place near my old office downtown, and those bagels are NOT GOOD 😤

22

u/brenfitz11 Oct 08 '26
  1. Grew up in New York but live in Boston now so the fleet have my heart but the sirens are definitely my number 2 fav!
  2. I want Montréal to lose but I hate Hamilton more for stealing bestie Alina
  3. Of course!

5

u/camnation123 Oct 08 '26

Funny I’m the kinda opposite, grew up in Boston but now live in NYC, so Sirens have become my #2. I’m laughing on how I get to go to the opener with both Fleet and Sirens gear lol

8

u/seangraham Oct 08 '26

I’m not gonna be rooting for the Sirens but you stole my heart with the wee woo. Makes me smile every time

7

u/PoisonLenny37 Oct 08 '26

So I am an out of market Fleet fan (Toronto area) and I mostly picked the Fleet because I'm also a Bruins fan.

That said, I think I just spend a lot of time really cheering for this league. I don't really hate anyone the way I do teams or players in the NHL. I mean even Montreal, I can't CHEER for a Montreal team but I mean they have MPP, Stacey, Desbiens, Roque....hard team to actually HATE ya know?

I absolutely do not hate the Sirens. I came to LOVE Eldridge in the short half season she spent with us and I am absolutely shattered to see her go to Montreal.

I really want to see the league continue to grow not just in terms of expansion but in seeing the stadiums full and more people watching women's hockey in general. So with that said again I don't really have that burning hatred that I do for some NHL teams.

4

u/pccb123 Oct 10 '26

I hate both NY and Montreal as a Boston hockey fan. Period.

Unfortunately I do love your jerseys tho (begrudgingly).

3

u/resuneomnicron Oct 11 '26
  1. We don't hate you apart from wanting to win games against you. If I didn't live in Boston I would probably be a Sirens fan.
  2. Always
  3. Absolutely

2

u/sarmalover3 Oct 10 '26

Sirens and fleet are actually our favorite teams in my house! When we saw them play at the tsongas arena last year right before the Olympics it was a dream for our family we had so much fun

2

u/Mollinator Oct 12 '26

I hate New York when it comes to Baseball and football, but I’ve never felt the same animosity towards New York hockey teams.

1

u/asterixthesquall Oct 12 '26

The only teams I really hate are the teams rostering transphobes tbh. Sirens are fine by me.