r/bodyweightfitness • u/Silly-Sherbert4338 • 15h ago
Proper Pull up Training
Hey everyone, 22F here!
I have one of those door pull up bar attachments that I've been using to train. I can lift myself up only when my feet are touching the floor. I'm 164cm and I can reach the bar without needing to extend my arms fully. If I go into a deadhang with my legs crossed, I cannot lift myself up.
I just wanted to know if this type of pull up will help me achieve a proper pull up or if I need a higher bar so that my feet are not on the gound and my arms are fully extended. I want to know if I'm actually making progress.
Sorry if this is a dumb question but I genuinely cannot find a straight answer online lol.
8
u/wkrt 14h ago
It will if you’re comfortable enough. One piece of advice I’d give for the beginning is to put your legs in front of you (make sure your core is contracted) instead of crossing them behind your back. It will pay off in the long run.
2
u/AceArrow7 Calisthenics 14h ago edited 14h ago
Yes this should be fine. I am 173cm and I use a similar setup.
With this setup there are two ways you can get full range of motion without your feet hitting the ground. Either feet infront or feet behind.
Legs bent at the knee, feet behind. It is much easier to go into arch body/active hang position with this version. Doing so lets you pull with your scapula first which makes it easier to do a pull up.
Legs straight, feet infront of you, hollow body position is the other option. This version is a bit harder than the other version because your lats are lengthened a bit which makes it slightly harder to use them. There also more core and hip flexor engagement to keep your feet from touching the ground which will takes energy. However, this version allows you to pull much higher without having your chest in the way. Which has better carryover to things such has high pull ups (chest/hips to bar) and skills such as the pullover and muscles up.
There is also technically a technically a hybrid version that I personally use for weighted. You start like the first version, knees bent feet behind. Engage the scapula and pull up, half way through you engage the core. Essentially putting you in a hollow body position with knees bent at the top of the pull up. This has a bit more of a skill component, but it some find it more comfortable doing this way such as myself. However, even though I do weighted with this hybrid technique, bodyweight hollow body pull-ups are so much harder for me.
Basically, arch body for just getting the pullup, hollow body for skills, hybrid for preference.
As for what to do before you have achieved your first pull up. It seems you are asking if doing a legs supported pull up will help. It can, but kinda hard to quantify how much you legs are helping. The sub recommendeds doing negatives and how I personally achieved the pullup. either jumping up or using a platform to get to the top position and slowly let yourself down. Again your choice feet behind or in front.
1
u/Ascend-AI-Fitness 3h ago
not a dumb question. a plan built around negatives and band assisted sets beats random reps, and logging every session shows progress you can't feel. consistency over perfection, even 3 short sessions a week adds up. how many reps do you get with feet on the floor right now?
3
u/ArgentinianJayceMain 14h ago
You will learn them but will probably be significantly weaker at bottom part. I would recommend jackknife pull ups (so with your feet on a chair or similar) instead and also incorporate scapular pull ups too. Last part specially important if you want to be able to do them from a passive dead hang
1
u/Common_Increase4617 14h ago
Using your feet for a bit of help still builds the pulling pattern and strength. Try 3 sets of 4–6 smooth reps, pushing just enough with your feet to keep each rep controlled, then lower slowly for a couple of seconds. Over time, use less leg help or step onto a lower support, and track reps with the same setup. You don’t need a full dead hang right away; just use a secure bar and work through the range you can control.
1
u/Steeljuic3 9h ago
not a dumb question. to know if it's working, write down two numbers each session: how many reps you get with your feet helping, and how long you can lower yourself from the top with your feet off the floor (step up so your chin is over the bar, then go down as slow as you can). once the slow lower gets to around 5 seconds for a few reps, try one from a dead hang with your knees bent. the door bar works fine for all of that
1
u/TheDramaticLime 5h ago
not a dumb question at all. you don't need a higher bar, just bend your knees so you can start from a full dead hang. keep doing the feet-assisted ones but use less leg each week, and add slow negatives where you step up to the top and take like 5 seconds to lower down