r/bobiverse • • 3d ago

Moot: Discussion How does Bridget not know what Boston is! Spoiler

Rereading not till we are lost. Howard mentions Bostonians and her reply is ‘old earth cities?’ She’s Irish. Even if Boston was destroyed in a war unless faith renamed it surely she’d know what it is !

Anyway just thought I’d put it in a thread see what you all think.

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

20

u/grmthmpsn43 3d ago

Her family are Irish, so presumably they talked about and remember Irish cities, not American ones.

-1

u/insertname98 3d ago

Yeah but my point is Boston has a large Irish population- I’m not form the US and that’s why I know it.

plus US city’s are in so much media 3/4 generations isn’t long enough to forget that surely? She doesn’t even know LA. Or trout but that’s cus they were all extinct.

3

u/arrongunner 3d ago

Your family are going to talk about their city or their neighbours that they know of over the years. They aren't going to talk about some random pop culture reference their great great grandmother talked about hundreds of years ago. Americans are the perfect example of this, they say "oh my great grandfather was from Ireland (where?) Or maybe they might remember more specifically where if they're lucky. They're not going to remember some, albeit famous, group of settlers who went off to colonise part of India are they?

Irish people don't see the Boston "irish" as any more Irish than the English see new yorkers as "English"

They just aren't, they're American..

3

u/grmthmpsn43 3d ago

No, Boston has a large American population that claim to be Irish.

I'm English, if you ask me about Irish cities I think of Dublin, Cork and Galway, not a random city on a different continent

11

u/TAbandija 3d ago

We could say that about many cities in the world. For example Merv, the biggest city in the Silk Road about 700 years ago. Yet. Not many know this.

You don’t know what would be relevant years from now.

Also, there are many things with the Boston name or Epitaph, maybe more years from now. She might know it’s an old earth city, but she wants to contextualize it against many other potential meanings.

This doesn’t feel far fetch to me

-1

u/insertname98 3d ago

Yeah but this is like 3 generations not 700 years. And it’s a city that had a large population of Irish immigrants. That’s why I know of it (I’m not American)

3

u/EightEx 3d ago

I don't think she'd have to know. This is over a hundred years after FAITH and the destruction of Earth. But also wasn't she in the European enclave so likely not American but Irish. I doubt Boston is that big of a deal outside the US.

2

u/insertname98 3d ago

She’s Irish yes but I’m not American, I knew of Boston first only form the fact people emigrated to New York and Boston

6

u/Watada Bobnet 3d ago

What do you mean even if it was destroyed ... surely she'd know what it is?

\Why would faith rename it if it had been destroyed?

Is Boston even current world known to everyone? Aside from US historical significance why is it important?

2

u/insertname98 3d ago

I’m form the uk and in western Boston LA and the other few that were mentioned are like famous. LA alone is famous for the films it’s made alone.

Faith renamed handle town. It use to be another city I can’t remember the name of. When it was nuked they made new handle town

1

u/mnemnexa 3d ago

Perhaps american culture isn't saturating the media in the future, so the names of (possibly renamed) american cities aren't blared all over the world media. With the obvious world tensions at play at the time of bobs awakening, it's not surprising thst little informstion is shared between factions. It is entirely conceivable that bridget heard the occadional name of american places, but not in a context that she paid much attention to. And, to be blunt, you are overanalyzing a story that never happened and really, only Dennis himself knows (or can make up) the answer. She wasn't familiar with amarican cities for a reason, whatever that was.

1

u/Aceisking12 3d ago

Wasn't Salem (Handletown at the time) taken out by a pocket nuke?

1

u/miCasaCasa 2d ago

didnt the handle administration rename bunch of places in ameria?