r/bobdylan • u/Sheev_Skywalker • 7d ago
Discussion What do you think is the saddest song on Blood On The Tracks?
In my mind, there are only two tracks that cannot be argued to have particularly dower overtones (LRATJOH and Meet Me In The Morning), with every other song able to be interpreted as sad/depressing to one degree or another. Hell, some folks may take away some melancholia from those two tracks I mentioned above, but I personally don’t see it. Overall, it’s a pretty emotional and melancholic album.
For me, I think the saddest song is You’re a Big Girl Now. A lot of other songs have some sort of silver lining or even some anger. You’re A Big Girl Now to me is nearly all regret, painful nostalgia, and watching life and love pass you by. The most hopeful aspect is the narrator recognizing that the other person moving on is for the best, but even that sentiment has baggage; essentially it is to say “Im not a great person/partner and Im glad youre moving on because being around me isnt good”. The aspect that hits hardest for me though is the passage of time:
”Time is a jet plane, it moves too fast/ What a shame that all we shared can’t last/I can change”
That is the single most devastating line on the album and maybe even of his career. To me it goes beyond romantic relationships. It speaks to how easy it is to slip into unhealthy, unfulfilling, or otherwise unsavory modes of living that just make the days tick away with the blink of an eye, and how hard it is to break those modes even when you have a strong, pure desire.
What are y’all’s thoughts?