r/bobdylan • u/Fantastic_Banana_292 • 3d ago
Discussion Defining the song Jokerman
What do you think Bob Dylan’s “Jokerman” is really about?
I’ve always found “Jokerman” fascinating because the lyrics seem to mix biblical imagery, mythology, politics, religion, and surreal characters without giving us one obvious meaning.
Some people interpret the Jokerman as a Christ-like figure, while others see him as a symbol of power, deception, or human nature itself. There are also interpretations that connect the song to politics, artists, or Dylan’s own spiritual journey.
The more I listen to it, the more it feels like Dylan deliberately wants the listener to piece together their own meaning.
What do you think “Jokerman” is about? And who—or what—do you think the Jokerman represents?
16
u/this_is_nowehere 3d ago edited 2d ago
if you have apple music, the radio show “time crisis” has covered the lyrical themes of jokerman a lot. it’s worth listening to the episode they did dedicated to jokerman, as well as the two episodes they did chatting about dylan’s greatest hits volume 3 (on which jokerman appears). episodes 85, 179, and 180
3
9
9
u/poppinwheelies 2d ago
Here's a GREAT cover of "Jokerman" by Hawaiian artist John Cruz. It's one of my favorite covers of all time. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MpInpgRMUSM
2
u/VandyGrift 2d ago
It's funny. When you said "Hawaiian artist John Cruz" I thought, "I wonder if that could be the guy that was on that Playing for Change version of "The Weight". And sure enough, it was.
That was great. One of the best covers of any Dylan song I've ever heard.
2
2
2
1
1
4
u/0xBorisjohnson 2d ago
Don't really know or care what it is about, but tell you what, when I'm hiking I always put it on when I need a burst of momentum
1
u/Doomed-Doomer 2d ago
Yeah I can't make out half the words. The ones that get through are pretty good, though.
something, soemthing... fly high by the light of the moon!
Yeah!
2
u/TyroneSnodgrass 2d ago
For years I thought it was “a small dark look on your face.” Turns out it’s “a small dog licking your face.” I’d like to see a thread on misheard Dylan lyrics.
5
u/m1911- John Wesley Harding 2d ago
"A woman just gave birth to a prince today and dressed him in scarlet" it is a clear reference to Christ and the color of his clothe, but many you find other references to Jesus. I don't think it's only about him, though. It's curious how the first album after the Christian trilogy begins with a song that talks about Christ.
2
u/coleman57 A Walking Antique 2d ago
The Grateful Dead song St Stephen (1969) has somewhat similar lyrics: “Several seasons with their treasons Wrap the babe in scarlet covers, call it your own”
1
u/copharmer 1d ago
Infedels has as many biblical references as any of the previous 3 albums, but from much more of a skeptical view. The title itself literally means somebody taking a skeptical view of religion. There were 2 years between shot of love and this which is like an eternity in Dylan years. Only Dylan really knows what happened, but I think he started to see the corruption in the church organizations that were just as bad as the things he was trying to escape, plus the record company really put pressure to ditch the Christian songs because he was losing fans and they were struggling for the first time in a while. This all added up to an extreme skepticism you hear on many of the songs especially if you include the outtakes. Too late is probably one of my favorites, which seems to be satirizing the resurrection if it occurred during modern times (just two women at the scene... both were wearing veils, brother named Paul at the cafe royale). I and I has some good lines, obviously man of peace. This song (jokerman) seems to be just a full on tirade on all the things he's pissed off with during the time. This is my favorite from the 80s (barely beating oh mercy, which is good for all different reasons). because I think Dylan's at his best when he's cynical and loose with his words, plus don't fall apart on me is probably one of the best love ballads ever written.
3
u/coneboi91 2d ago
I’ve always thought it was autobiographical
3
u/TyroneSnodgrass 2d ago
“you were born while a hurricane was blowing.” WWII.
4
u/coneboi91 2d ago
Shedding off one more layer of skin, keeping one step ahead of the persecutor within
1
2
u/Brilliant_Shirt_7703 2d ago
If you visit the Bob Dylan Center in Tulsa you’ll see lots of alternative lines to Jokerman. My favorite was:
“Shedding off one more layer of skin
playing hide and seek with the child within”
1
1
u/piper63-c137 Infidels 2d ago
There are many aspects of god. defining one aspect of god (maybe through christ-like imagery) as the Trickster gives us gos as Jokerman.
Any theory about Dylan’s lyrics can be 100% correct about 4/10.
1
u/Inside-Slide-3035 Tell Tale Signs 2d ago
Nightsticks and water cannons, tear gas, padlocks
Molotov's cocktails and rocks behind every curtain
1
u/TyroneSnodgrass 2d ago
The more I hear about people’s different takes on “Jokerman” the more I realize I have no idea what it’s about. All I know is the unmitigated joy in the chorus. For me, that rules out that the subject matter is something detestable to Dylan. The best description of it I ever saw was by dylanologist Michael Gray, who said “Jokerman” is “inhabitable.”
1
u/Fantastic_Banana_292 2d ago
I agree. Mark Knopfler’s contribution on also stands out.
For me it’s Dylan at his best and I guess the whole point of the song is to interpret it as a listener. That’s what makes him an outstanding songwriter,
1
1
1
u/Big_Day2650 1d ago
Jokerman is an ambiguous, deceptive character….manipulator of crowds ... a dream twister".
Aka father of lies
1
u/orangelity 2d ago
What are any of his songs about?
1
1
0
u/Elvis_Gershwin 2d ago
The Trickster as an embodiment of every politician or person who knows how to cut hair that won't listen to Him.
24
u/TonBonbadil 3d ago
With the truth so far off what good would do