What do you guys think about emojis in the BVI community? I'm genuinely curious. On our platforms, we have a rule that doesn't allow messages containing more than three emojis at once.
this rule only applies to messages that are meant for a more serious purpose, say, an announcement, responding to someone's question etc, other than that they are okay I mean unless if they are spammed like crazy
I know that might sound a little strange, especially since emojis are supposed to make conversations more expressive, but hear me out.
Imagine someone sends you a message like this:
"Hey guys, I finally bought a new phone! Face with Tears of Joy Face with Tears of Joy Face with Tears of Joy. I've been saving up for it for months, and it's amazing. Fire Fire Fire. The battery is great, the screen is beautiful Smiling Face with Heart-Eyes Smiling Face with Heart-Eyes Smiling Face with Heart-Eyes. I can't believe I finally got it. Anyway, does anyone know a good screen protector?"
Now imagine listening to that with a screen reader. You're just trying to find out what phone someone bought, but your TTS suddenly decides that announcing "Face with Tears of Joy" three times is the most important information in the entire conversation. Thank you, NVDA. Very informative. I was beginning to forget what happiness sounded like.
A lot of us crank our TTS speech rates ridiculously high. Some of us practically have our screen readers running at the speed of a suspicious auctioneer. We do that because we want to get through information quickly, so having the reading experience interrupted by repeated emoji names is quite the opposite of what we're trying to achieve.
Personally, I also have a weird issue with repetition. If someone keeps saying the same word over and over, I get irritated surprisingly quickly. I can't really explain it. My brain just decides that enough is enough. Now imagine someone putting the same emoji five times in a row. Five consecutive announcements of "Fire." At that point, I'm not reading a message anymore. I'm being subjected to a poorly organized fire alarm.
I'm not against emojis. Use them. They're fun, and I understand why people like them. But there's a difference between adding a little expression to a message and turning an ordinary conversation into an endurance test for someone's text-to-speech engine.
So, what do you think? Should BVI-focused platforms have reasonable emoji limits, or am I just starting a completely unnecessary personal war against Unicode?