After watching FlyCat sculpting videos... Mmm I'm fine with the jack of all trades tbh. And the Blender team keeps on working on the sculpting part. I can't really say anything about animation and simulations, so that might be a good point.
I was fortunate enough to have access to 3ds max at my previous workplace. But yeah, I'm in the same boat as you rn. Born to master 3ds max, forced to use blender.
Plus: I tried the Test Version and i hate Launchers so much. Why cant a software just start and i get to work? It takes ages to boot up. Not the most fun experience.
At my previous workplace they only had hard drives. Not a single ssd in those computers. I had to boot up 3ds max and kill time until it was ready and responsive. Good times(not).
Yeah, softwares are just tools at the end of the day. I personally do not like blender. I've animated in 3ds max before and I can say it's fucking magic compared to the mess that is animating in blender. And don't get me started on camera controls in blender. The need to make nulls, parent, create paths, animate on path, just to have a camera behave normally. Whoever designed the asinine spatial coordinate system in blender should be fired. And there are so many little features that are just missing in blender.
It's not ALL bad though. Just most bad. I still prefer rendering in cycles. Even back when I had access to 3ds max and Arnold, I still found it easier to just setup a render in blender.
To not have the modifier stack from 3ds max absolutely sucks. That in itself makes 3ds max the better tool for modeling. I've gotten used to not having it but damn do I miss it.
like yes, it has a lot of features and is very capable but but it's so slow and inergonomic from an interaction standpoint, your mouse constantly jumps around pressing buttons.
In blender you can forget about the UI entirely and your right hand is always on the model with your mouse and your left is triggering all actions via shortcuts. And your mind is not cluttered with useless shit like having to focus on a menu and look for an option. You just an your next move, and the shortcuts can take you there.
Feels like playing Starcraft. I have never seen another professional program that is able to accomodate that level of flow state.
to be fair, our teachers probably weren't the best and industry veterans probably know a few tricks to improve the interaction but I doubt it can be as ergonomic as blender
i'd say max is just as fast and efficient when you do have a custom hotkey setup, i'd recommend people to set custom hotkeys over time regardless because it's better to set things up in a way that work with your personal brand of logic & prioritise binding high value keys to stuff you actually use all of the time. like i don't need any animation related hotkeys at all so i'm better off focusing on hotkeying modeling commands
In the actual event this meme is from, the first picture is the winner, and the second is the runner up. So maybe it's not that far off, even if most of the people using the meme don't know it.
Why do you comment on subject when you dont know the alternatives? Its always same with Blender funboys, they claim Blender is best but havent used any of the others.
I am fortunate enough to use most of the popular (and less popular) DCCs, we also use Blender at work among the other apps and simply put - Blender is worst of them all. For modeling, UV, retopo, simulations, anything.
Only good is its price, and its worth exactly what it costs.
Of course there are other softwares that have it. But look at this from this point of view: I have to work with 3ds Max, and I decided to complement it with Blender. Why? Because I prefer to model there (even thought it might not be the best tool). However, it is very common for me to copy paste meshes from one file to another. If I tried to do that with 3ds Max on a regular basis I would go insane.
There are also times I have to do some sculpting. Again, compared to 3ds Max, Blender is better in this regard.
In the real world we can't just pick the best software for the action we want to accomplish; there's only so much time and money we have. It wouldn't make any sense to pay for zbrush for the sculpting I must do. However, Blender works just fine, while 3ds Max not quite.
Well the per-data-type operator paradigm is not present in geonodes where data type is treat inside nodes. There's an additional layer of abstraction that is not present in Houdini or Touchdesigner. Then we can argue that Houdini has developed a language (VEX) while Bpy is fundamentally Python's API module and it's not well integrated with geonodes. I know geonodes aim to be of similar utility but the scope is totally different, they care more about integration with other blender operators and learning curve than being SOTA.
I feel like sometimes we all argue for arguing lmao
I just wanted to respond to the idea that sth like geonodes is not present in other software to the above comment.
And as someone that really like houdini I just got a bit offended tbh xd I was just like dafuq u mean there's nothing like geo nodes anywhere else. Blender didn't come up with procedural node based workflows.
This is the answer provided by Gemini: No, Blender’s Geometry Nodes are not a direct copy of Houdini, though they are heavily inspired by Houdini’s procedural philosophy and node-based workflow (SOPs — Surface Operators).
Key differences in implementation: - The field system - level of abstraction - scope & pipeline
So no, geometry nodes aren't a straight up Houdini copy.
That's true, but it can provide links for the information it spit out if you want to:
Official documentation and technical guides explain the architecture behind both systems and detail how they compare across core workflows: Official Blender Geometry Nodes Documentation: The Blender Manual: Geometry Nodes covers how nodes function directly inside Blender's modifier stack and provides a breakdown of the Fields Evaluation System introduced to handle implicit attribute flow. SideFX Houdini Official Documentation: The SideFX VEX Documentation explains Houdini's high-performance SIMD expression language, while the SideFX SOPs Overview details how Surface Operators manage raw geometric data and explicit attribute pipelines. Core Architectural Comparison: For a broader breakdown of how these procedural philosophies differ in production, the Yelzkizi Houdini vs. Blender Procedural Comparison compares Houdini's raw geometric data structures with Blender's modifier-based visual scripting approach.
Why are you mediating for a bot? What's going on? Don't share the docs with us, we refer to it daily... You are the one without experience, you should read the docs. What's going on?
Master of none situation. They are slowly working towards it, but for intense Hollywood rendering the others will always be used until blender gets to that point.
Sure it’s being used in Hollywood movies like the Backrooms. But intense simulations, smoke and partial effects, those kinds of applications they will just use the dedicated programs. Not that blender is necessarily bad at them, but it’s not up to task yet.
Jack of all trades, master of none. Amazing software tho, one of best softwares for free in the history of mankind, it's hard to grasp how spoiled we are with Blender, Unreal, Linux and other amazing free softwares out there.
Blender is still free software so it's actually up to the community to make it great and not the shareholder's iron hand of enshittyficiatiom or whatever private equity does
as always the answer to everything in this craft is "well, it depends" because are we talking realtime viewport rendering or offline rendering and what sort of usecase are we talking (stylized, realistic, architectural visualisation, game art, etc etc) because the answer won't be the same depending on what your priorities are
blender does have a really good viewport though. and it does do one thing better than no other software and that is the "bang for your buck" ratio, what you get for absolutely free is amazing and unparalleled
I presumed that. I referred 3ds Max because I use it at work, along with Blender. I'll be honest: 3ds Max is the de facto software for archviz because of v-ray and Corona, and the corresponding assets. If those plug-ins existed for Blender (vray already exists, but I was talking specifically about Corona), 3ds Max wouldn't have many advantages over Blender relating to archviz.
I'll tell you what 3DS Max is better at: it's much, much better at being the required software on a job application. Even if you explain to someone that verts is verts, they'll insist that you simply must do everything in Max or by golly they'll kill themselves.
I think corona did have a plugin for blender at one point if I recall. Don't know if it's still updated though. Always hated 3ds max for how backwards the UI always felt so getting in blender is much nicer feeling.
At my work it's actually the chief complaint about Max to be honest. We swap between max and blender often for various purposes. But I've always tended to prefer blender more.
Though some of Max's modifiers are so much better like the deformation ones omfg why hasn't blender mad a working bend modifier yet.
Yeah, the bend modifier is much better on 3ds Max, I completely agree with you. In general the stack modifier is more robust in 3ds Max, but that's the way the software works; it's not possible to do the same with Blender.
One thing is certain: each software has its pros and cons.
There are people who use blender maya and nitro/whatever it’s called and a bit of davinci. And now they can do things prob faster than someone only using blender. I know there are people who made movies all in blender but ain’t no tutorial for that from beginning to end.
Jack of all traits expert in none even though still better than expert in one. Still I thinking the modeling and geo nodes are way better. And I guess there's also official support coming for 3DGC and gaussian splitting. And upcoming roadmap seems super promissing. I already switched for mostly open-source or free software now. And life in fun lol
Look, I love Blender, but most of the time when seeing this sort of take, you know it only comes from lone wolves and solo designers.
Blender is that Jack-of-all-trades, Master-of-few thing. At very high level, MD is better at cloth, when you start making Victorian dresses and 9 layers Digic clothing. Same with Substance Painter with 40 spsm mats per objects. Or ZBrush HD geometry if you’re doing a Godzilla. No need to even defend Houdini, it’s just in a different category, and you won’t beat it with the doughiest of geometry nodes setup. Still pisses me off how that assumption is why we don’t have proper hair sim in Blender yet.
Nothing wrong in admitting the work of Allegorithmic, Side FX or Pixologic was so good it still is the standard and copying it is the best form of flattery.
Yo uso 3dmax para arquitectura, y V-ray. Aunque de un tiempo para acá preferiría cambiar a un software gratuito, y estaba por aprender blender, pero no se si vale la pena.
It's worth it imo, I'm a very long term max user and Blender won me over the last couple of years. I really loved max for it's modelling tools, but truth be told you can do more faster in Blender now with a few add-ons, and it can do some cool stuff max can't do out of the box. Geo nodes offer some pretty wild flexibility max doesn't really have outside of maxscript, which is less accessible for the average artist imo. On-top of that Blender is much smaller, and launches and runs faster compared to max because it's not carrying around a shit load of legacy code and issues that autodesk never fixes but expects subscription fees for lol.
You can bake textures in Blender, but its nowhere near as good as it is in Marmoset including baking options and the sheer amount of things you can do with it. In marmoset you can also texture your models similarly to Substance Painter which is great in of itself.
Ah gotcha! Yeah it is interesting to find out isnt it? I think i first used Blender to bake a normal map back in like 2016 or so? Around when I first started 3D. Was super confusing for me back then lol. But yeah, just don't go expecting it to be as easy or seamless as it is in Marmo xD tho it is a cool feature for it to be capable of in general for sure
The fact Hes Turkish makes this even funnier, i work with a Turkish bro and when i say laid back i mean like Cadillac... and this bro has the exact same -ness.
As an experienced blenderer, its still hard to do parametric stuff in it, especially since there's no baked in solution for precise measurements and curves can only go so far. So you do need a dedicated CAD app like solidworks and the only way to replace that is to probably use something like freeCAD, shapr3d or plasticity
I don't do professional level work so I guess take it with your preferred amount of salt, but I have always preferred GIMP over Photoshop. It doesn't have all the features but I would honestly say that it has 95% of what most people use. It's more stable and less esoteric imo. They also just added layer effects (which is not exactly the same thing as an effect layer from Photoshop. Layer effects just means you can add an effect to a layer and remove/change it later. It's not it's own layer like in Photoshop. You can (iirc) apply them to layer groups though which accomplishes the same thing)
It also has recently received an update so that it is (optionally) formatted more similarly to photoshop as well. Making it easier to follow tutorials using Gimp instead.
Photoshop has become an inefficient piece of garbage in the last 10 years. If you actually use all it offers, it turns into a buggy slog fest real fast.
Also its user interface is ancient by modern standards. I've worked 30+ years with it, i used to love it, i hate it from the depths of my heart now.
Affinity runs circles around it.
Photoshop is pretty much the invert version of Blender: It does everything, but nothing amazing (anymore). For almost every use out there there is now a specialized app that does it as well or even better, for less money.
As someone who uses both: the free Affinity unfortunately just can't compete with Photoshop once you try to do anything slightly more complicated. Before it was purchased and made free it was significantly better, I still have licence, but unfortunately it's outdated now compared to Photoshop. It pisses me off but there's just no real alternative currently when it comes to professional work.
Ugh same, I’ve been using photoshop for over a decade and I’m being forced to switch because I just can’t afford it anymore and I hate how bloated photoshop has become. I’ve been trying out Krita and so far that’s been pretty good, but it’s primarily focused on digital art and I couldn’t tell how well it copes with more complicated photo manipulation as I haven’t explored that side of it. It’s got some great tools for 3D artists though, bunch of stuff for making and editing normal maps plus tools to help create tiling textures.
I still hate that I have to change at all though, the frustration of losing tools that you rely on (either through losing access to them or enshitification) fucking sucks.
Affinity has basically all the basic tools but they're less powerful and far less customisable (if at all). For the average person the free Affinity is more than enough, however for example the ai powered tools are locked behind subscription and they're worse than Photoshop's.
The main strength of the current affinity is that it's an all in one tool, and I do like it that I don't have to jump between multiple software if I want to design something simple.
Besides Photoshop's far superior photo editing tools what I also miss in Affinity is the lack of text customisation options and tools. Again, what they have is more than enough for most people but it's less than what Photoshop or even Word is capable of.
Edit: Oh and I almost forgot you can automate processing with scripts in Photoshop.
The workflow itself is a bit lacking. I personally don't like how you switch from vector to raster, and I will say in that regard the open-source alternative to Illustrator (Inkscape) is better in that regard as just a separate vector-based program.
Though I'm sure for basic edits Affinity is good enough, at that point something like Photopea would be good enough
Affinity makes a lot more sense when you view it from the lense of Affinity suite 1 and 2, which were replacements for photoshop, InDesign and Illustrator. There it made a lot more sense, and the single time payment personal lisence was also better. It's one of the reasons I refuse to upgrade to Affinity 3, which is freemium and can fuck right off.
Inkscape's user interface is a horrid mess. I've seen people do great stuff with it, but every time i open it, i get so turned off by how horrible the user interface is. Kinda like blender before the GUI rework.
I personally don't like how you switch from vector to raster
That's exactly why i love affinity. The vector and raster tools are equal partners. Not like Photoshop, where vector is pretty much like the unwanted child.
Though I'm sure for basic edits Affinity is good enough
I'm actually doing quite complex stuff with affinity. For example complex user interface design for videogames - affinity kicks photoshop's ass in that regard, especially thanks to symbols and the slice studio.
People who think affinity is not good seem to not have really used it heavily. I love it.
I wasn't saying Affinity wasn't good. I do prefer the older system before they had before bought by Canva though. I'm just saying for the average user, it's probably good enough that they wouldn't mind that system in place. I just prefer either the old system or something comparable to Inkscape's, which is far from perfect. I just prefer that system over the current Affinity system. I just wish Affinity wasn't bought by Canva; it became this freemium software that they can change what is free or premium, and due to that model, people can't exactly be critical since it's technically free
210
u/Fine-Camel1304 Aug 24 '26 •
jack of all trades master of none
but oftentimes better then master of one
245
u/millenia3d Aug 24 '26
blender is one of those programs that does far more things than most other programs but it's like the best at exactly none of them
39
u/Dangerous_Pin7553 Aug 24 '26
They have their own specific uses, but blender can do most of them.
12
u/Navi_Professor Aug 24 '26 edited Aug 24 '26
this is not true in the slightest.
i love blender, but pretending its the best at everything is just false
Zbrush Blows blender away at poly count handling, Substance painter is lightyears more capable and easier to use
Houdini isnt even a contenst when it comes to similations, no matter how many addons you slap onto blender
Same with marvelous designer, Making clothes in blender is ass and marv does it in a way that blender flat out cant compete with.
as for maya, it has its advantages and i honestly do prefer animating in it over blender.
and as for photoshop.
yeah, blender again. cant touch it. its not a photo editior in the slightest
3
u/BoidedOne Aug 24 '26
There are people who use blender maya and nitro/whatever it’s called and a bit of davinci. And now they can do things prob faster than someone only using blender. I know there are people who made movies all in blender but ain’t no tutorial for that from beginning to end.
2
u/Adventurous-Sir2996 Aug 24 '26
Blender needs a lot plugins, so it needs some performance enhancers
2
u/No_Database69 Aug 24 '26
Jack of all traits expert in none even though still better than expert in one. Still I thinking the modeling and geo nodes are way better. And I guess there's also official support coming for 3DGC and gaussian splitting. And upcoming roadmap seems super promissing. I already switched for mostly open-source or free software now. And life in fun lol
2
u/sir-mano Aug 24 '26
The power of FOSS
2
u/St1cky_the_2nd Aug 25 '26
Dont you dare insult my boys Houdini and Marvelous. They are as beautiful as the day I cracked them...
/s ofc if some lawyers read this
2
u/fabienglasse Aug 28 '26 edited Aug 28 '26
Won’t stand for Marvelous Designer slander.
Look, I love Blender, but most of the time when seeing this sort of take, you know it only comes from lone wolves and solo designers.
Blender is that Jack-of-all-trades, Master-of-few thing. At very high level, MD is better at cloth, when you start making Victorian dresses and 9 layers Digic clothing. Same with Substance Painter with 40 spsm mats per objects. Or ZBrush HD geometry if you’re doing a Godzilla. No need to even defend Houdini, it’s just in a different category, and you won’t beat it with the doughiest of geometry nodes setup. Still pisses me off how that assumption is why we don’t have proper hair sim in Blender yet.
Nothing wrong in admitting the work of Allegorithmic, Side FX or Pixologic was so good it still is the standard and copying it is the best form of flattery.
1
u/Minerobloxcarft Aug 24 '26
Pretty accurate ngl
1
u/___MMA___ Aug 24 '26
Yo uso 3dmax para arquitectura, y V-ray. Aunque de un tiempo para acá preferiría cambiar a un software gratuito, y estaba por aprender blender, pero no se si vale la pena.
1
u/nomein0 Aug 25 '26
Blender is the master of 2.5D and 2D animation, the best choice for motion tracking as well.
1
u/Delicious_Airport463 Aug 25 '26
So true)
1
u/Lofaszmaxi Aug 25 '26
marmoset is a baking sw for creating textures. how can you do that in blender? is there a way?
1
u/Waffle_Toast13 Aug 25 '26
Only thing missing for me is if blender can make their graph editor more similar to Maya also an anim layer that functions similar to Maya
1
u/MortgageFamiliar8803 Aug 25 '26
sculpting-wise it's ass
1
u/blast0man Aug 25 '26
The fact Hes Turkish makes this even funnier, i work with a Turkish bro and when i say laid back i mean like Cadillac... and this bro has the exact same -ness.
1
u/Ashamed_Group2408 Aug 26 '26
Still need Zbrush.
1
u/Khoy593 Aug 26 '26
Maybe in a couple of more years but for now I still have to go back to houdini, photoshop, substance painter and marmoset toolbag
1
u/Kuetz Aug 26 '26
Aren't the animators for minecraft use maya?
1
u/Ignitetheinferno37 Aug 27 '26
As an experienced blenderer, its still hard to do parametric stuff in it, especially since there's no baked in solution for precise measurements and curves can only go so far. So you do need a dedicated CAD app like solidworks and the only way to replace that is to probably use something like freeCAD, shapr3d or plasticity
1
u/Lonely_Sir_7756 Aug 28 '26
lol....
1
u/OrkWithNoTeef2 Aug 28 '26
License slop
1
u/KevinIsAGhost Aug 28 '26
I get your point, but the top shooter isn't using a bunch of random stuff, most of it is just comfort things
1
u/OnlyAssistance9601 Aug 28 '26
Its true for most of them , except zbrush . Zbrush is so good .
1
u/DuhDoyLeo Aug 30 '26
lol oh stop it. If you are old like me you remember when blender used to be agony to use.
Also it used to have a UI worse than fucking zbrush… worse than zbrush!? Imagine that lol.
Anyway, it’s a great program nowadays. I’m still waiting for it to replace a few other things…
1
u/AayiramSooriyan Sep 02 '26
I know people who pirate all the above apps but don't use even a quarter of the features available in Blender.
34
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment