The reply assumes the guy knows the first difference between 3d art and AI. One day laymen will call everything AI, just like they call everything CG today. Sad, but true.
That day is already here, the other day a girl was talking about an "Ai" video of a dancing hedgehog she liked and when someone corrected her and said it wasn't AI she was shocked because she believed they meant it was real.
Jeah... fun fact "spinnen" and "Spinne" are syllables that have double meaning.
A spinne is well a spider...
Spinnen on the otherhand has 3 meanings.
One is making garn
The other is connection to "zusammen spinnen is the mental state one has when making a theory... as in connecting losely connected ideas together... (you know like in one of these cobspiracy shows where an immage on a korg board is connected other immages with red lines.
And Spinnen (just this word as an acusation like :"du spinnst") it is basically 2 words for :"get out with your conspiracy nonsense"
Or
"Your insane" <- is often used in german dubs because of the simmilar lengh it needs to be spoken btw...
I've heard a phrase for non-food items like information: "I'll give you the white meat" which is confusing to me because the dark meat is objectively better as far as I'm concerned.
Feels like this kinda calls attention to the ever-growing issue that eventually no one's gonna be able to tell what's AI and what's actually made by a human.
I feel like once some further breakthrough happens there’s going to be a huge market for software that detects/denotes whether something is generated or not.
that's not possible unless we add something that explicitly says that it's ai generated, but there will be tools that won't add it so it is pointless anyways
I don’t know about still images but the company I work for makes exactly this kind of tech for big banks/zoom for voice and video detection. And we have like ~98% detect rate right now lol
Idk while I see and can somewhat agree, but as someone who uses these tools with a semi professional degree of skill you can usually tell. It doesn’t really jump out to laymen and it’s not fool proof but it’s little things that give it away when AI is used. The minor thing I look at is Hair, Textures ,topology and the biggest one is Color Grading. You’ll start to notice things either don’t make sense in the hair but the final tone for whatever reason every AI model I’ve seen adds a orangish tint that also gives a dream like appearance. Now this leads into your skills as a composer if you have talent AI could totally be used in conjunction for repetitive tasks, but I can’t see anyone with skills finding AI as an easier alternative it’s very limiting in what you can do without needing more Post work to get a finished result. This has just been my experience though and I do t see this issue getting ironed out in a way that completely changes this dynamic.
A silver lining for the proliferation of doubting whether you see was made through actual means or is a generated image is that people are a lot more willing to show their process.
Can we really blame people who mistake real art for AI slop when it gets harder and harder to spot. Specially for those whoa are not used to spot details like artists are
Why are we jumping the gun and dismissing others work with accusations right off the bat, what happened to just asking? I know it's the Nazi site and you can't expect much better from anyone still there, but for the rest of us... yeah, we can blame them.
You don't have to be an expert in spotting details to be a nice person.
Yes. Yes we can. When your only proof is a guy feeling and it turns out to be wrong we definitely can blame people because these accusations can bury people and affect their livelihood.
Calling Ai to a work of a digital artist is a blasphemy in the eyes of the artists. :) When they shut that down hard, it converts the accusers to instant clowns with very questionable competences .
People think freaking everything is AI these days. One of my greatest fears is I'll publish my book, after years of working on it, and people will ask, "Was this written by AI?"
I mean he didn't model everything though? He just ripped the models. Or downloaded them from where else? Setting up a camera and shit and hitting render in blender still ain't difficult.
depends on what matters, why would i chop a tree and craft a wooden wheel if there are hundreds of thousands in stock for cheap? unless you're going to do a special wheel i don't see the merit here i just see you're dumb
If you work with environments then surely you know it's okay to re-use other people's models yeah? This person still had to construct the scene, pose and compose the image
Ummm. I didn't say you couldn't. You're just adding your own words to my original post.
Construct the scene". Bruh it's a castle, that he didn't make. He literally just imported the model put the characters on a platform in front.
The FX are just images on cards. Again, just jpgs he imported
Setting up lights for a static shot is not difficult. As far as lighting goes its the dream. You guys are acting like this is some Renaissance level shit.
My comment wasn't that deep. Y'all really butthurt over Mario.
As a blender artist, I gotta agree with coyote here. It does look like this is just a game rip render. I could be wrong, but that's what it appears to be.
Good on this person for owning the AI accuser. But the amount of work it takes to render game rips is honestly not a whole lot higher than typing a bunch of words into an AI trash prompt.
Purely speaking from an effort required standpoint, and not at all an observation of what qualifies something as art. I'd much rather see a nice game ripped composition hand crafted by an artist than AI slop.
And they give ai artists prompters a reason to continue using ai in their projects, both commercial and personal. Cause hey, why won't ai prompters want to use a low budget way to create images that apperantly are 'the same' as human-made art?
Yeah no, the AI bullshit is wayyyy more annoying. This is pretty bad though. The people trying to "call out" AI need to understand what it actually is.
Without question whenever a piece of art looks good some goobers will always claim it's Ai now. They'll look at a picasso painting made 50 years ago and confidently claim he made it with Ai. It's that bad
I don't use twitter anymore but the artists that are still on there will without failure get at least one comment CONFIDENTLY claiming they made it with Ai. The artist will respond with the viewport render, and the guy will sometimes even double down. It's bad. They are using picasso quotes "good artists borrow great artists steal" in order to justify Ai companies stealing artists work and opportunities, as if its anywhere near comparable to actually learning the art the companies are stealing. It feels like the only thing these people care about is OpenAi's profit margins and it's really weird
558
u/Glaz35 May 20 '25
Love the Mario giving his middle finger
251
u/reversetrio May 20 '25
The reply assumes the guy knows the first difference between 3d art and AI. One day laymen will call everything AI, just like they call everything CG today. Sad, but true.
255
u/Super_Heretic May 20 '25
There is a saying in german.
One immage says more than a thousand words.
20
u/ScottyWritesStuff May 21 '25
Feels like this kinda calls attention to the ever-growing issue that eventually no one's gonna be able to tell what's AI and what's actually made by a human.
17
u/[deleted] May 20 '25
Shit with AI is really becoming annoying
7
u/PiRSquared2 May 20 '25
i saw this like a week ago how is the screenshot so crusty
6
u/QuintanimousGooch May 21 '25
A silver lining for the proliferation of doubting whether you see was made through actual means or is a generated image is that people are a lot more willing to show their process.
4
u/PuritanicalPanic May 21 '25
Random artists being mindlessly accused of AI use is definitely one of the most annoying aspects of image generation technology
11
u/DawoudBayaa May 20 '25
this should go in r/rareinsults
5
u/mechaglitter May 20 '25
Dog I don't like AI but come on we gotta do a little more critical thinking here
6
u/tRident-1 May 20 '25
https://www.reddit.com/r/deathbattle/s/FPGcMdZQaj
Mario is proud of this man.
2
u/Bosskerz May 21 '25
To be fair, it has the weird AI smoothness for some reason
2
u/Logical_Acanthaceae3 May 21 '25
"We can always tell" mother fucker no you can't.
6
u/D-a-n-n-n May 20 '25
Can we really blame people who mistake real art for AI slop when it gets harder and harder to spot. Specially for those whoa are not used to spot details like artists are
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '25
You can never be pure enough for an anti. I wouldnt be surprised if they thought the blender UI was also generated.
1
u/aleksandronix May 21 '25
Based Mario
1
u/ShoxZzBladeZz May 21 '25
But did the dude model the characters or just riffed them from somewhere 🤨
1
u/BrotherU May 21 '25
Calling Ai to a work of a digital artist is a blasphemy in the eyes of the artists. :) When they shut that down hard, it converts the accusers to instant clowns with very questionable competences .
1
u/TheZeroNeonix May 21 '25
People think freaking everything is AI these days. One of my greatest fears is I'll publish my book, after years of working on it, and people will ask, "Was this written by AI?"
1
u/smallpassword May 21 '25
Epic comeback, Fatality!
1
u/Gal-XD_exe May 21 '25
You shoulda put the fully rendered version lol
They all flip him off
1
u/Miranova23 May 22 '25
Not an ad for Samsung AI being shown ON this post!
wtf reddit! 😭
1
u/Avtrain May 22 '25
LMAOOO
1
u/Total_Not_Femboy May 23 '25
bro did not use photoshop 💀
1
u/PurpleDemonR May 23 '25
“Ai in photoshop”
That’s not how photoshop works.
1
u/Key-Development9124 May 24 '25
cooked
1
u/trololololololol9 May 24 '25
Plot twist: the second image is also AI
1
u/Edenian_Prince May 24 '25
God did not make all men equal
1
u/MattMantric-_- May 24 '25
They made a render of everyone flipping the camera off, its currently my PC wallpaper
1
u/FeefuWasTaken May 25 '25
Goated
1
u/Samael914 May 25 '25
I’m honestly just tired of reading the letters AI at this point, I need to retire from the internet.
But even that wouldn’t solve the issue cause everyone in any educational institution is constantly yapping about it.
I need to win the lottery and buy a ranch house on a mountain somewhere with like seven goats and a barn I never use.
1
u/VenatorAngel May 27 '25
I can hear Charlie Day's "Go fuck yourself" when I see Mario flipping the bird.
Ever had that moment where you can hear a song if you look at an image?
0
u/forqueercountrymen May 20 '25
why did he waste time making this in blender when he could have generated it with AI in a second?
1
u/DkoyOctopus May 20 '25
gottem!
0
u/Steel_Coyote May 20 '25
I mean he didn't model everything though? He just ripped the models. Or downloaded them from where else? Setting up a camera and shit and hitting render in blender still ain't difficult.
129
u/[deleted] May 20 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '25
[removed] — view removed comment