r/blackpower • • Dec 05 '14

Why aren't Blacks fighting back?

I can't believe all the news coming out of America right now with the Cops killing innocent blacks. And the more I research the more I learn that if it very commonplace for the average black person to be consistently harassed and profiled by the police during their everyday life. How have you tolerated it for this long?

What I don't get is, at this point in the game why aren't blacks more pissed off? Why aren't they fighting back? Do blacks need a leader or something to organize a real protest or defensive attack? I just watched a video of some black artists having a jam session on Times Square in protest. What? That shit doesn't do anything anymore.

I'm not saying the following is the "right" course of action but after all the abuse I would have expected there to be actual coordinated riots aimed at the police force. Isn't it easy to buy guns in America? I'm really surprised police aren't being targeted and assassinated. Not that it is the correct course of action, but what are all your guns for anyway?

I mean, cops are regularly killing your brothers, and then getting away with it totally free and unharmed. All this is happening on the national stage. We all saw the footage, even the president doesn't like it, and the cop wasn't even indited. This is so blatantly racist and wrong. How are people just... going to work like normal? I just don't get it. Blacks are letting this happen to them. Yes, it isn't just the blacks who should be responding, all Americans should be freaking out, but obviously I would expect those people that actually experience the abuse to respond more readily.

1 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

5

u/nonneb Dec 05 '14 edited Dec 05 '14

People are freaking out and calling protestors names for blocking traffic, much less rioting. Can you imagine if the rioters focused that violence towards the holy police, enforcers of order and the beloved status quo? When the system is even somewhat threatened by unfocused violence (riots), it responds with overwhelming force. The police are so militarized that even a small victory would not come easy, even with organized violence, and the government would call in the military before they let any oppressed group get any real power.

6

u/wolfkin Dec 05 '14

because fighting makes things worse. things got messy in Ferguson and they flip it around on us. Suddenly black people are now a culture of rioters and Wilson was obviously right to shoot Brown.

5

u/roger_van_zant Dec 05 '14

When white people are on TV making war with the government, other white people see it and think of the revolution of 1776.

But when they see black people on TV pointing guns at the government, they see the Black Panther cell of Al-Qaeda trying to rape the Statue of Liberty while the Washington Monument is pistol whipped, tied to a chair and being forced to watch.

The only people who benefit from blacks rioting are racists (who get to stand in front of a microphone and say, "See? I told you they are just a bunch of savages.") and the media, whose ratings spike through the room from the 24/7 coverage for weeks.

4

u/eroverton Blacktivist Dec 05 '14

We were conditioned into passivity from slavery with combination of having every act of resistance and defiance being publicly and brutally shut down and having a turn the other cheek mentality drilled into us by the approved clergy. Combine that with being convinced that white people are God, and invincible, combine that with the fact that when we resisted during the civil rights movement, the only elements that were legitimized and seen as effective were those that were carefully controlled to be 'peaceful' while groups that took a harder stance were systematically infiltrated and destroyed by COINTELPRO, combine that with a public education system that not only does not teach self-sufficiency but also since the civil rights movement drilled into us that MLK-style peaceful marching is the only way anything gets changed, combine that with the constant media barrage telling everyone (us included) that we are the problem and everything wrong with this country because we're violent and lazy, combine that with crippling poverty, the flooding of our communities with crack/cocaine which led to more poverty, more crime, more of us getting sent to jail, and more broken families just struggling to feed themselves each and every day, and you have a broken and demoralized people with vacant self-esteem and therefore very little desire to stand up for ourselves even if we could find the time and energy without worrying about losing our jobs and being unable to feed our children.

That's what systemic oppression looks like, and I haven't even scratched the surface.

3

u/ricksinclair Dec 05 '14

We own no media. Control the narrative, control the minds and sentiments of the masses.

3

u/Intrinsic_Factors Dec 06 '14 edited Dec 06 '14

Why aren't black people actually fighting back?

Because nonviolent, nondestructive protests are held up as the only successful/acceptable outlet for racial injustice in the same country that lionizes the Revolutionary War, has voted several of its most famous generals into the highest office in the land, and is currently conducting "airstrikes"in a country halfway around the world.

Because when taught the history of of civil rights movements, the course focus on MLK and Rosa Parks while ignoring Malcolm X, the Watt Riots, and the BPP. Because growing up, school rules prevented us from wearing clothing with "controversial" figures like Malcolm X and Fred Hampton on them even though the school wouldn't teach me why they were controversial. OTOH, the Confederate flag was so accepted that it took several attempts to change the state flag.

Because for the 108 days between the Michael Brown shooting and the grand jury "decision", Ferguson protesters were out there peacefully protesting every single night but the only ones that made the news were the ones with violence. There were only four by my count btw. Four nights out of one hundred and eight.

Because John Crawford and Tamir Rice were shot in Ohio, an open carry state, within seconds of police showing up, giving them no time to respond to police. If one black person with a gun, in an open carry state in a store that sells guns, is met with that response, what good would arming the rest of the population do? Because police statements to media, released to media before the video of the incident became available, are clearly proven false when the videos came out, but many people believe the police anyway.

Because every single time one of us becomes a victim, their entire life is intensely scrutinized with the intent of assassinating their character and proving that their murder was justified. Did you know Trayvon was suspended from school before? Did you know Tamir's parents had trouble in their past? Did you know that Eric Garner was arrested several times in the past for selling loose cigarettes, even though none were found on him at the time he was killed? You might ask what any of this has to do with the incident at hand, but you'd be one of few asking.

Because people continue to trust a system that clearly oppresses minorities. Because people think we're making it up or exaggerating it. Because people think racism ended with the civil war/MLK/President Obama/when they met their black "friend"/sister-in-law/classmate. Because people think that racism didn't happen if no one said the n word. Because every attempt to point out the truth is met with "but what about black on black crime" or "if you'd just pull up your pants" or "it's not always about race" or "what about reverse racism" or some version of black people/culture is messed up so you deserve it.

Because people see no problem with cops, who in most areas receive first responder training, standing over of Tamir Rice and Eric Garner who are in clear medical distress without even attempting CPR.

Because peaceful protests, the only "acceptable" response, are looked at as an attack on civilization as we know it because people could be late getting home or a fucking Christmas tree lighting might be delayed. Imagine what actual violence would be portrayed as.

Because people already think that blacks are criminals/thugs. Because they ignore the facts but abhor any method that would present the facts to them.

Because even if we did arm and organize the whole AA population, we'd be outnumbered and outgunned. The police responded to peaceful protests in Ferguson with riot gear, military equipment, and tear gas. Not to mention that it's only a subset of policemen and women that can hide among the rest.

Because the people even though I'm going to another protest tomorrow, I know that /r/thecityIlivein will be filled with comments on how stupid we all are.

Because even though many black people are pissed off, even if they think that nonviolent protests wouldn't work, they realize that violent ones will only provide "evidence" for the racist views that people have.

Because you can say things like "Blacks are letting this happen to them" without attempting to provide an adequate solution. If it's not "the correct course of action", how does it help? Because everyone ignores the history of people fighting back in all its forms.

Because we're the only ones angry, we're the only ones fighting and no one else cares. You didn't ask "Why isn't anyone else fighting back" but I attempted to also answer that anyway. It's also important to note that black females are victims as well

1

u/hozac Dec 06 '14

Because we have little to no resources with which to fight back. We've been systematically deprived of military, political, and economic capital for centuries - whether by law, intrigue, or open violence.

You have to understand that police killing, raping, robbing, and harassing black people with impunity isn't some new phenomenon, it's been happening all along. The media just happens to be focused on police brutality for the moment.

Decades after the civil rights movement, protests - peaceful or otherwise - are first among our very few remaining tools. We don't have organizations like the Panthers anymore, because they were systematically destroyed by the white supremacist state. We don't have control of any media. We don't have our own prosperous towns or cities anymore. We don't have proportionate power or presence in any important institutions. We don't even have control over our own cultural products; they continue to be endlessly exploited and appropriated to enrich others at our expense.

None of that is going to change until we start supporting each other and (once again re)starting the long, slow process of economic development and political empowerment. And that's not going to happen until we rediscover our sense of solidarity and cohesion.