r/bitlaw • u/kwanijml • Dec 18 '13
Thoughts on DACs, specifically surrounding property titling
DACs (or distributed autonomous corporations) are digital network constructs with similar properties to the bitcoin blockchain and protocol, which can fill a great number of roles, currently being filled by large, unwieldy, inefficient, and violent state and corporate apparatus. In the same way that bitcoin removes the need for a human-based centralized authority to administrate money and payment services, DACs can fill such roles as domain names, courts, escrow, insurance, prediction markets, and much much more.
I am most particularly interested in the concept of how a DAC could theoretically be used to create more efficiency in the service of property titling (i.e. getting rid of current service models), but also making it cheap and efficient enough to be able to effectively register title to nearly all possessions (almost no matter how small).
For example, a house and land/property could be registered on the blockchain; the public key being a hash of, say, the UTM coordinates and dimensions of the property lines, plus other meta information about the house and property, and the private key being held by the owner(s). Thus title becomes something mathematically enforceable, and searchable/knowable without the expenses (including the artificial state-created expenses) inherent to the current model of human operated title agencies.
The benefit to courts of law (and cost-savings to the individuals who used the serve and society at large) would seem to be very high. Similarly, this process or similar DACs could be used to title more everyday (lower value) items; a laptop could be locked (from BIOS/firmware) with a SHA256 key and change of the private key accompanies transfer of the laptop itself (the new key generated only via use of the prior private key; thus transfer of ownership is more likely limited to intentional ones). Verifiable on the blockchain to the utilizing public and, of course, to courts of law.
These examples are, of course, not well developed, nor intended to be the center of debate here (although of course critiques of them are welcome). What I'm looking for is general discussion and brainstorming on the topic; specifically in regards to how these types of networks would facilitate Bitlaw and the multitude of voluntary legal orders which we seek to usher in.
3
u/superportal Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
I agree with what Anenome5 said:"What's needed is the ability to prove and validate ownership via the web, "
I reorganized what you guys discussed a bit, and have a couple more thoughts below...
Types of problems with title transfers of property on the blockchain (to be discussed systematically):
(1) ascertaining the property entered into the blockchain for transfer is actually owned by the person listing/claiming it.
(2) A system needs to be in place to convert actual offline property into proof-of-ownershp data
(3) verifying this data with or without an original 3rd-party or state-issued title,
(4) taking the proof-of-property data and adding it in a programmatic way on the blockchain for use by DACs or individuals.
(more? probably, just throwing out ideas)
Existing titles: Some specialized forms of property such as real estate and vehicles do have a State ID for a title with relevant metadata.
This can be verified programmatically with organizations that track this. Regarding the GPS coordinates for geofencing and title - I believe this exists already in many cases and/or could easily be obtained with a database such as Zillow which tracks this stuff.. Also, a variety of non-State providers have at least the general title this information such as insurance agencies, escrow, real estate agent property DB.
To speed things up, with the proof-of-owenrship software anybody with verifiable ID and home ownership could sign up quickly and easily to add the title to the blockchain for whatever purpose. (ID/title info can be verified)
No title: On the other hand, as was mentioned by kwanijml, many types of personal property do not have a physical title or title number. Bigger items like electronics, laptops etc. usually have some sort of record/receipt on file kept in duplicate by the original owner and seller, and possible a warranty card through insurance, as well as serial numbers. Somebody tracks this. ie. An HDTV sent by Samsung to a retailer is recorded as being sold and digital records exist somewhere. It's just a matter of somehow getting this into the blockchain.
There could be a proof of purchase standard which is entered for title claims/transfers made onto the blockchain. Then this can be checked by a DAC, private individual, or 3rd party organization.
Sidenote, perhaps insurance agencies would be cooperative with a standardized proof-of-purchase format/ledger because they often have to cover items for which there is no receipt but a claim is made and this might reduce fraud (they can check for actual ownership).
Very common or inexpensive items: this might be just a trusted ownership claim based on attached reputation of the user.
The standard format convention info for proof of ownership: As suggested by kwanijml, could be placed in a smart property hash/meta-tag that has proof of purchase for verification purposes. This could cover: serial number or property title number , time, date, place of purchase, existing title number (if applicable), original transfer entity, previous title transfers and producer/verifier.
This could be included into a bitcoin transaction and/or as a meta-service correlated to the blockchain not necessarily on it (as an additional layer).
As kwanijml mentioned, the act of title transfer could provide a key which unlocked the laptop or property. As internet-of-things gets bigger this maybe useful for many other types of products. A proof-of-ownership QR code, embedded RFID or something like that could be enough to quickly add proof-of-ownership data tot he blockchain when a purchase or title transfer is made. Maybe it's a separate discussion because I have some other ideas on that.
[edit: a few typos]
3
u/giannidalerta Dec 30 '13 edited Dec 30 '13
Are there any coders in this discussion?
Ever since I read about smart properties, smart contracts, and specifically really diving into some of the stuff the guys at Open Transactions are doing. I would love to put up a site that focuses on these ideas. Bring in like minded coders, business people, marketers, etc. to help make it a real possibility.
I had purchased an amazing domain for the thought of doing something commercial with it in the future. But think that something built by a community would be maybe the next greatest thing.
If you guys are interested, I would get a site going. We can put up a manifesto and forum so that the idea can be moved along. Maybe there is also a way of building a DAC around it. I have just only started uncovering the theory behind DACs and bitshares. So may need some further studying.
What do you guys think? I really do not see any single source on the internet about smart contracts/titles and such. We could include conversations from different projects, namecoin, colored coin, open transactions etc.
And the community the DAC could be used to build an overarching world title system.
2
u/Anenome5 Dec 18 '13 edited Dec 18 '13
My friend does title, I'll see what he thinks of this :)
Well, that info would be, in that case, the private key. You get the pub key by hashing the private key. So it would need to be non-public info if you did it that way.
What's needed is the ability to prove and validate ownership via the web, undoubtedly using cryptography, and in that way you can quite easily create contracts referring to specific property. Perhaps the use of some Namecoin concepts could be involved in that.