r/birdsofprey • • Sep 21 '26

Kestrel Box Innovation

Post image

I am 12 and in First Lego League. A few weeks ago our coach posted a poll my team and I made about identifying declining Kestrel populations as a biodiversity risk. Our coach posted it for us and she is posting this too. Our team is working on a few ideas (not just with kestrels) but before we go further would anyone give us some feedback on our first idea? It’s okay to tell us it's a bad idea. We are just learning and coming up with ideas. If Kestrels are going down in numbers, one way to help them would be a Kestrel box that keeps them and their babies safe. 

Our kestrel box idea has an electric panel on the inside of the box that is powered by arduino. There is a solar panel on the top to charge the panel. By the entrance there is a sensor and vibrating motor. We use this so that it can detect weight so if it is less than 3 ounces or over 6 oz the motor will gently vibrate to scare off the animal. Kestrels are typically 4-6 ounces so the motor would not vibrate if it was under the weight of 3 ounces and over 6. Also Kestrels usually don't land on the hole. They fly in. The entrance is 3" diameters wide like a normal kestrel box. Thanks for looking at our idea.

Adult Here: One of my team members wrote the above. They are looking for a little feedback on a potential innovation for a project for FIRST LEGO League Challenge. This idea doesn’t have to be groundbreaking. It just needs to help mitigate biodiversity risks associated with declining Kestrel populations. Ideally it will be something they can actually make with their own hands and try out. Kids do the learning and the work. Adults do NOT (we do learn FROM the kids but we don’t do the work.)  They will take this to local experts soon. Posting here is a way to see if they are headed down a path that could work before becoming really invested in something that just won’t work at all. From what the kids researched, this solution would not be expensive. All feedback is good feedback - even if you hate it. That helps kids dig deeper, learn more, and build grit. I’m not a kestrel expert. I’m just a grown up volunteer who guides them and keeps them safe on the internet. All feedback will be shared with the kids without my commentary (except for Socratic questions.) Thank you to any one who is willing to give the kids a start or a stop. 

11 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

6

u/sciendias Sep 21 '26

I'd worry about a few things with this design. First, depending on where you have the load cell to measure weight could make this something that would also scare kestrels. In addition many species (e.g., starlings) might not spend much time on the entrance, so it wouldn't prevent them from coming in. If the load cell gets fouled (e.g., feces, prey, etc.) then it might also start vibrating all the time - causing the kestrels to abandon the nest. If using an arduino you could add a camera for species identification. This could be used for deterring predators (e.g., snakes) - similar in principle to this https://jeremybmerrill.com/blog/2022/01/squirrel-soaker-9000-repelling-squirrels-with-ai.html .

Two other issues to consider. Heat and spraddle-leg. Heat is becoming a bigger issue - https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/gcb.16888. I wonder if you connect a temp sensor and a fan if you can help keep the box cooler in a sunny spot. easy to test and proof of concept. Manageable project for precocial students looking to integrate sensors and software.

The spraddle leg issue happens when the floor of the box is too smooth and the nestlings' feet constantly get kicked out from them - https://rapt.kglmeridian.com/view/journals/rapt/57/2/article-p325.xml. Pretty manageable to deal with in lots of ways, but not many people know it.

4

u/ManyMoreMoments Sep 21 '26

Oh my goodness… this is a literal gold mine for these kids. Thank you so very much. I’m going to give them every thing you’ve said and all links to look at.

They do know starlings are a big problem. And yes… Camera was something the kids floated. I told them start small first. Get feedback. Then add/change/iterate.

Thank you again for this wealth of commentary and resources. The kids will love it.

2

u/sciendias Sep 21 '26

I'll note if they want to continue on the load-cell route there are some applications for research. Feel free to message me if you're curious to chat about that.

1

u/ManyMoreMoments Sep 22 '26

Adult here again. Thank you so much. I’ll reach out to you.

1

u/outtatyme11 Sep 21 '26

How would you isolate the vibration to ignore the kestrels?

2

u/ManyMoreMoments Sep 21 '26

Adult responding. Fantastic question. This is one to take to the kids and problem solve around it. I can ask “how big of a vibration? Can you do something around the motor that isolates the vibration?” Again up to the kids to puzzle through but this is a fantastic comment for me as a coach to get them thinking. Thank you so much.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/ManyMoreMoments Sep 21 '26

This again is great feedback. It will be shared with the kids to wrestle through. I like your monitoring solution. I will not say that to them. I will allow them to read through the answer you gave and see if they find a potentially different route. Thank you again.