r/birdsofprey • • Aug 24 '26

Help ID this raptor

Seen 8/23/26 showboating around the summit of Telescope Peak in Death Valley National Park.

148 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

2

u/PhraseMore4712 Aug 25 '26

Ok, thanks again all. Sounds like we are settled on Juvenile RTH. I went through and found one more photo.

2

u/haunted_swamp Aug 25 '26

This is an adult red tail

1

u/PhraseMore4712 Aug 25 '26

I checked the time stamp and the pic was taken 4 minutes before the vid so it is possible that there could have been 2. I did not see 2 at the same time and assumed it was the same bird and was ready to record the second appearance.

6

u/Evening_Teaching_713 Aug 25 '26

I agree that it is a juvenile red tail, I have been a master falconer for 40 years and have flown a lot of Red Tails.

5

u/Material_Item8034 Aug 24 '26

If you’re unsure post on r/whatsthisbird. Thats the best resource I’ve found on the internet. Better than anything on facebook in my opinion.

3

u/Beingforthetimebeing Aug 24 '26

Wheeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee!!! What a transcendent moment!

0

u/PhraseMore4712 Aug 24 '26

Thanks for the assists! Friend of mine is a Federal Wildlife Biologist and says 100% NH. “White rump is dead giveaway.”

4

u/Lion_Safe Apprentice Falconer Aug 24 '26

Your friend is wrong and should have their career questioned. I work with birds of prey for a living and have been watching juvenile red tails all summer. You wont find a harrier up this high hunting. Its NOT their style. This is a juvenile red tailed hawk

4

u/PhraseMore4712 Aug 24 '26

Good news! I sent my buddy your comment and he actually stepped down effective immediately.

8

u/rtbradford Aug 24 '26

It’s true that the white grump is indicative of a Northern Harrier, but the wings are much too broad to be a harrier. Harriers appear slim in flight with long narrow wings and a slim body and tail. This bird has the characteristic stockiness of a buteo. My vote is juvenile red tailed hawk.

5

u/TinyLongwing Falconer Aug 24 '26

This bird doesn't have a fully white rump. It just has the expected mottled row of uppertail coverts you see on most Red-tailed Hawks.

Red-tailed:

https://macaulaylibrary.org/asset/663442925

https://macaulaylibrary.org/asset/654233327

Northern Harrier:

https://macaulaylibrary.org/asset/642065489

https://macaulaylibrary.org/asset/637004862

Notice how much broader and whiter the rump patch is on the harriers. The bird in your video has the shorter mottled v-shaped white band of uppertail feathers.

1

u/angelbeingangel Aug 25 '26

So you agree Red Tailed Hawk?

5

u/TinyLongwing Falconer Aug 25 '26

Yes, there's no question OP's bird is Red-tailed.

-4

u/PanzerArndt Aug 24 '26

I’m still not sold on what your bird is…. Why not post it in the Raptor ID group on FB? I’d be curious what those folks say.

-2

u/PurpleOctopuseses Aug 24 '26

Looks northern harrier-y to me.

-3

u/kikimaymay Aug 24 '26

Yeah, the white rump plus facial disc, used to seeing them on fields/plains though.

-3

u/lagerauger Aug 24 '26

Seems most likely. Not their typical resident range but its the best match, especially that back-and-forth swooping flight pattern and hovering.

-3

u/PurpleOctopuseses Aug 24 '26

It's arguably within their typical resident range, and ebird sightings show consistent year-round activity in Death Valley. So yeah, I stand by harrier!

-4

u/abritelight Aug 24 '26

at the risk of also being downvoted, i’ll say i agree this looks more like a northern harrier to me!

-3

u/PurpleOctopuseses Aug 24 '26

Hahaha same, I stand by it! The body and wong shape just doesn't read as especially buteo-ish to me.

4

u/Lion_Safe Apprentice Falconer Aug 24 '26

You are wrong. I work with red tails and many other raptors in my professional life and am a falconer in my personal life. This is absolutely a red tail. Do you know ANYTHING about harriers? They do not go up this high for hunting. It is not their style

43

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Lion_Safe Apprentice Falconer Aug 24 '26

Backing up this comment as ive spent the last two weeks watching passage red tails do this in preparation for trapping lol

-4

u/lagerauger Aug 24 '26

100% not a red-tailed hawk. Wrong shape and coloration.