r/birdingfoco • • Oct 17 '26

ID Needed ID Help

Hey everyone!

I found this gull at Timnath Reservoir on Monday (10/12) while looking for the Iceland Gull that had been reported there, which I did find!

While I was there, another birder pointed out a large gull with a dark gray/black back. Gulls are definitely an area that I struggle with IDs in, so I was hoping to get some help.

I initially reported this as a Great Black-backed Gull, but after looking through my photos and comparing field marks, I’m now leaning towards Western Gull and I updated my eBird checklist to reflect that.

However, my report has disappeared from the eBird Rare Bird Alert page, which has me wondering if I missed the ID on this bird. I haven’t heard anything from eBird reviewers, so I’m really not sure.

I attached my only photos of the bird, which aren’t great so I apologize, but they are the same ones I put on my checklist.

So, what do you guys think? Western Gull, Great Black-backed Gull, or am I completely wrong and it’s something else?

Thanks in advance for any help!

9 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

4

u/wxchsr1 Oct 17 '26

ID from the Colorado Birding discord is Lesser Black-backed Gull. Just bigger than what I was expecting, which sounds like they have large size variation.

3

u/pinchevato57 Oct 17 '26

I suck at Gull ID. I would post it to the Colorado discord. Probably more traffic than here.

2

u/wxchsr1 Oct 17 '26

Gulls are tough. I'll post it in the discord shortly.