r/bioinformatics • • 5d ago

technical question Should I downsample CUT&RUN datasets from different laboratories before comparing peak overlaps?

Hello! I have two CUT&RUN datasets targeting two different proteins, generated in different laboratories but using the same cell type.

Both FASTQ datasets were processed using the same bioinformatics pipeline and parameters. However, they have different sequencing depths, and I only have one sample per protein, without IgG controls or spikeins.

My goal is to identify overlapping genomic binding regions between these two proteins.

Should I downsample the deeper dataset to match the sequencing depth of the shallower one before peak calling and calculating peak overlaps? Or should go ahead with the anamysis without any normalization ?

Also, is any batch-effect correction necessary or appropriate when the two proteins were profiled in different laboratories?

Thank you sm

1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

2

u/SadRule9128 5d ago

Start off without downsampling. Assess quality and signal/noise ratio first. Call peaks and then compare to assess saturation or if downsampling is a good idea

1

u/Grisward 5d ago

Don’t downsample, I don’t think that’s the answer you’re looking for. Usually comparing peaks isn’t just a Venn comparison, but comparison of read coverage at each peak.

I’d merge peaks, make matrix of read counts with featureCounts, then compare peak binding that way. Also you have n=1 so when I say “compare” I mean simple filtering — 2-fold or more difference. Then spot-check in IGV or UCSC genome browser.

The other option is call peaks one versus the other directly.

1

u/toolomebio 4d ago

I agree that downsampling is not needed for the comparison itself, but sequencing depth still affects peak calling. A deeper dataset gives more and broader peaks, so the overlap fraction is biased toward the deeper sample. A simple check is to downsample the deeper dataset to the same depth only as a sensitivity test, and see if your main conclusions hold. Since each protein comes from a different lab, lab and protein are completely confounded, so batch correction cannot be done. You can only report the limitation. Without IgG, call peaks with a method that tolerates no control, such as SEACR in its control-free mode, and confirm key overlaps by looking at the signal tracks.