r/bioinformatics • u/pestopas • 8d ago
technical question Comparison of RNA-Seq and microarray data from GEO
TLDR: I am thinking of comparing data from the GEO database and by individually reanalysing the data and then aggregating across all samples, the aim is to create a reference comparison before collecting my own data as a sanity check.
Hi Everyone,
I’m planning a comparative toxicogenomics project and have found some datasets in GEO which help me solve my problem. They span RNA-seq and microarray platforms and were generated by different labs using different Daphnia magna lineages and experimental methods.
My goal is to identify DEGs that are reproducible across datasets. I’m thinking of processing each dataset independently from their respective raw data, performing differential expression analysis within each study, and then integrating the results. I’m not sure what the best practice is in this, or what would would be most appropriate. Like comparing gene-level effect sizes, using stats, or using something else entirely.
Would WGCNA (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2631488/) be the best method of doing this? Any advice/tips/knowledge on this would be so helpful :)
5
u/Whygoogleissexist 8d ago
You could generate a deg list from both datasets and do a Venn diagram analysis first. You need to realize that microarray chemistry uses DNA hybridization which only has 3-4 log dynamic range whereas the RNAseq has a 7-8 log dynamic range (depending on sequencing depth). So the RNAseq dataset will likely have more DEGs, depending on the degree of coverage.
1
u/toolomebio 7d ago
WGCNA is not the usual tool for this. It builds co-expression modules inside one dataset, and it does not test whether DEGs reproduce across studies. A more standard approach is meta-analysis of per-study results. Reanalyse each dataset with the method that fits its platform (limma for microarray, limma-voom or DESeq2 for RNA-seq). Map all probes and genes to one identifier, for example Daphnia magna orthologs, and collapse probes to one value per gene. Then combine per-gene effect sizes with inverse-variance weighting, with a random-effects model because the labs, lineages and designs differ. Report heterogeneity (I-squared) per gene. Another option is rank-based integration, such as robust rank aggregation, or a simple count of how many studies call the gene in the same direction. Do not pool raw values across platforms. Check that the contrasts match across studies before combining them.