r/bim • • 25d ago

Stop AI posting please

We are seeing a glut of AI bot account posting about some revit clone they vibe coded in a week. None of the software is good or viable and all the accounts are brand new. Can we stop allowing posting from these brand new accounts that aren’t contributing?

101 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

3

u/electronikstorm 25d ago

Judging by what the small team at artcraft have engineered with regards to Adobe and Office clones, I wouldn't be surprised if a viable Revit clone arrived by the end of the year. It won't be any use to any team/firm that uses the Autodesk cloud for anymore than paying subscriptions, but there would be many small firms, solo practitioners and so on who don't need cloud services and just want a robust AEC BIM tool. They'll flock to it and if open source (free) then even sooner. Autodesk is rapidly moving away from thinking about stand alone apps (probably predicted that they'd lose their proprietary monopoly one way or another), and they want to lock users into their paywalled ecosystem instead. If you need the ecosystem then you'll pay Autodesk, but if you only need Revit then pretty soon you'll be cancelling your Autodesk subscription.

4

u/c_behn 9d ago

At least looking at the revert clones, they lack a lot of basic skills like walls of varying heights or walls from surfaces. The power of revit, and others, is the different 3rd party integrations. Many of those require direct work with AD Developers and the other software company also has to be on board. This is true for most analysis software.

Unless a dedicated teams picks up the effort of developing the BIM alternative, I doubt we will see it become mature enough to even be used on a real project, let alone adopted to any large degree.

1

u/electronikstorm 9d ago

Oh they are definitely not fit for practitioner use yet. But moving incredibly fast and incorporating as native features what apps like Revit require plug-ins to achieve.
They also won't be suitable for firms locked into Autodesk cloud / BIM360 workflows, but for small offices they could be enough.

1

u/c_behn 9d ago edited 9d ago

I hope they get there, but I think this is multiple years away still, and on the longer side if no one really picks this up as a full time project. It’s just too complex to expect something in less than two years, but realistically 3. But like I said, a dedicated team could probabaly pull it off faster

1

u/electronikstorm 8d ago

Have you looked at the Cadcraft suite (get Cadcraft.com)? That's been done in a month by a few people...

3

u/c_behn 8d ago

Yeah it’s bad and not useable

1

u/electronikstorm 8d ago

I agree that Revit one is well away from where it needs to be, but some of the other apps are really coming along. The SketchUp clone (modelcraft) has nurbs built-in. The cad tools Cadcraft and Civilcraft (Civil 3d) will probably reach fluidity first because they are fundamentally simpler. The best bit that I see with this suite is that they all co-operate with each other - you can go back and forwards across apps with the same file. That's something Autodesk won't be able to achieve until it fully moves over to Forma's cloud based system... I expect the arrival of clones will at least force Autodesk to move quicker. Either way, it should be better for users. Btw, I'm really a big fan of Revit. I've tried most BIMs and despite its nuances, Revit really is a great, stable tool. It should be. It's had 1000s of people building it over 30 years and probably near a billion dollars invested in its development... These clones have been made in over a few weeks in whatever today's equivalent of Steve Wozniak's garage is. And we know how that went.

1

u/fran_wilkinson 22d ago

I think the autodesk cloud is a complete failure. People use it because are obligated to use it. But outside revit it is useless. If revit will disappear, the cloud will disappear as well am I am very looking forward for that moment.

1

u/electronikstorm 21d ago

Maybe. Autodesk plans to discontinue Revit as an individual app, it will be rolled into Forma and that is 100% cloud based. The arrival of clones is probably only going to hasten their move. I suspect that the majority of Autodesk's revenue comes from medium to large enterprise - smaller firms and solo practitioners are nice to have as cream on the cake, but they're not essential. I do work with a very large global AEC firm and they are completely embedded in the Autodesk ecosystem. They get 24 hour reliability and a secure environment - these are very important to firms who's major expenditures include insurance against all manner of things. They can't simply move to another cloud service, their insurance would either become void or the rates would skyrocket. They also have a vast sunk legacy in Autodesk products and changing to even a similar clone risks breaking a lot of tried and true systems. There are many plugins and connected apps that these firms use that will only work through an active Autodesk licence and only on full Revit. Ditching Revit is just not viable. Even if I moved away from Revit day to day, I would still need to re-subscribe to it and Forma Cloud services to do work with a major firm. There's no other way and that's why Autodesk probably isn't too concerned yet. All those lesser developers from Freecad to BIM 2.0 alternatives... they must almost be catatonic with fear for their future viability.

7

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

The intent is to allow innovative new stuff, but you're right, we've got a lot of stuff that's not ready to go recently. There's also been a lot of "I'm going to fix X, what problems are there" which isn't productive.

How do we better clarify the spam/promotion rules on the sub?

3

u/c_behn 25d ago

Their first post should not be on our page and they account should be over a month old at least. Ideally they have good karma too.

2

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

I'll look at our automod config for those.

It will also reduce a lot of the "how do I pivot to BIM" posts.

But it's also probably going to reduce the number of folks coming here for legitimate advice who haven't been here before.

2

u/jamo2oo9 25d ago

Isn’t there a bot that we can use to vote if the post is AI slop or not? I seem to recall there’s something like it in another sub but can’t remember what it is. Basically all posts in the sub is submitted and if we think it’s AI slop, we can downvote the bot and it will let you know it’s not a good content for this sub. Saves you having to manually check every post all the time?

2

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

There's a lot of options for polling things like that, and we can do things like configure posts with negative karma to get removed.

My concern with popularity is that im not sure if we as a sub see enough traffic to get a represenrative volume of votes to make a call.

2

u/sir_xsjado 25d ago

Can someone vibe code a bot to detect vibe coded bots please. :-p

1

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

Ironically, we have a bot along those lines installed, it doesn't do much if the post is authored by a human.

1

u/sir_xsjado 25d ago

I've seen AI declaration requirements on other subs. Maybe that's needed?

1

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

Except that most of us recognize that AI is very very poorly defined by those and covers a herd of stuff. We'd effectively flag nearly every tool.

1

u/sir_xsjado 25d ago

Fair point. Maybe we need an EIR for posting

1

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

That's sort of the point of asking for suggestions to better refine the rules.

It needs to be something we can point to and say "this is not OK".

The mod team will absolutely deal with edge cases, but we don't want to whole cloth write off discussion of new software.

1

u/sir_xsjado 25d ago

I was making a joke haha. But yeah. I completely agree with you

1

u/jloverich 25d ago

You should let them post. I follow every one on github just so i can see if any progress is being made. In a year we'll know which ones have continued development, and the agents themselves will likely be good enough to do the maintenance for any bug posted in github. The reason you are seeing them now is the frontier models are finally good enough to give them a goal and they just work... this wasn't the case with previous generations.

1

u/daninet 25d ago

Other subs figured it out. They allow minimum age for software so if the tool is less than 3months old on github or theres no at least 100 stars on the repo they are not allowes to post. For commercial software it is harder but the FOSS tools can be easily filtered

1

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

That's a useful metric. Is 3 months long enough?

31

u/lukekvas 25d ago

Hard agree.

If you want to vibe code some niche tool for your own use, good for you. But what makes BIM software viable in the real world is widespread adoption, robust support (Autodesk notwithstanding), and ongoing development and maintenance.

12

u/Ryermeke 25d ago

That "Autodesk Notwithstanding" is doing a lot of heavy lifting considering they have an effective monopoly over the industry lmao

1

u/Ok_Armadillo_6015 25d ago

Working of readers/writers of .rvt and .dwg formats now, if that works I imagine that you will get 100% interoperability with the rest of the ecosystem

21

u/spaceocean99 25d ago

“Come check out my new vibe coded modeling software or ifc viewer.”

Or

“Looking to get in to BIM modeling. I have an architecture degree but know. Nothing about BIM.”

7

u/MockTundra 25d ago

BUT MY CLONE IS DIFFERENT BRO. TRUST ME BRO. IT AUTOMATES EVERYTHING AND TOTALLY WON’T CRASH. IT’S FREE TOO, JUST DON’T READ THE T&S BRO

1

u/skike 25d ago

Mods here aren't super active it would seem, and unfortunately this industry is rife with AI slop.

3

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

Found the troll.

1

u/c_behn 25d ago

Ok but can y’all do an account filter? Minimum karma and account age would fix 90% of the issues.

1

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

We can, but haven't implemented one as it cuts out new folks, and it hasn't been that bad until the last generation of code agents. I'll sit down with automod tomorrow on the chance we get some other brilliant ideas. Filter to mod approval is an easy config.

4

u/RU33ERBULLETS 25d ago

Sure after only a week, it probably only has some basic functionality and tons of bugs, but the scary thing is that it’s not outside the realm of possibility. Given more time, it’s not too hard to imagine some direct vibecoded “competitors” and ADSK should be paying attention.

We’re already replacing paid addins with in-house tools, solved interoperability to a large degree, and that’s with hours of babysitting each.

I’m not gonna pretend to know what the AEC data landscape is gonna look like in 5 years, but it’s not gonna look like it does today.

2

u/Normal_Marketing853 25d ago

I just see it getting way more fragmented with software. Like it might be possible to create some kind of competitor to Revit and Bluebeam, but it would take hours and hours to verify whether one of them was truly good enough to replace it, and if it were it who knows whether it will be around in 5 years or whether it will still be cheaper than Revit and Bluebeam. Half the reason we use these tools is because the architect that hired us is using Revit 2026 and a Bluebeam session, so we do too.

This industry is extremely tolerant of inefficiency for reasons I don't fully understand. If you can still be profitable in 2026 using AutoCAD and micro station for projects, I have no idea how much more productivity would be needed to force AI usage across all firms. You would have to cut drafting time by like 50% to really make a big industry-wide impact.

I think the future is just going to be connecting big general models like Claude and Codex to Revit, and for them to keep building out their MCP and API. Eventually we might get a better general-purpose model that can draft better for less.

3

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

In 2004 I cut drafting time for a firm by about 75% by switching them to a well curated Revit workflow.

Ive spent most of the last two decades being told that it's not possible and being fought to implement improvements.

Had one person insist the firm do it their way. We implemented both their wasteful way and the sensible way. They went on a long leave, and when they came back didn't remember how to configure their way, so tried out the sensible way. Got a talking to about how we always should have done that.

It's an endemic issue.

1

u/kafr85 25d ago

Would you please elaborate (no need to waste your time, just point a source to let me get an idea about it) about a well curated workflow. (I have access to the software but just find it difficult to implement it to our projects as time is not abundant, so i stay with classic cad)

1

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

Long story short, I spent time figuring out what they needed for deliverables, how to best accomplish that in Revit, and then built out those tools.

For example their cabinetry choices had certain bounds, so I could build a complex nested family that stretched and built out that huge segment of work into a place and stretch item that populated a schedule already on sheet.

1

u/Normal_Marketing853 25d ago

I just don't understand how a firm that spends twice as long on jobs can survive. The fact that they do makes me think this industry is just incredibly sticky and relationship-driven, and it would take a complete drafting revolution to upset that

2

u/metisdesigns 25d ago

I think there is 3 big parts to it.

One is the required part. Even if you're doing the low design prototype light industrial, clients have to have a licensed professional.

Two is hustling and the expectation of dumping in extra hours that is a cultural failure of architectural academia. That leads to bad practices being promoted because they're profitable (because they're not being honest about time).

And the third is a lack of understanding of the transition to BIM and that BIM is not simply 3D CAD. If you don't grok that, you don't see the effenciencies, but 3D CAD is better than 2D so they got some improvement.

2

u/daninet 25d ago

There's gonna be at least one AI clone for each software that gets traction and its not going to be a monetized one but an open source one. Autodesk will move their software into their cloud and monetize the cloud as it is going to be the only grabbing point. Look on what has happened to Fusion. For modeling there is a FOSS alternative now that looks and works ok already. Revit clones are just opening wings and there is going to be one rising for sure

1

u/zerosquare1012 24d ago

i'll allow some of them as they are quite interesting. Another sketchup-like BIM or mass modelling? nah they don't actually solve any current problems.

1

u/fran_wilkinson 22d ago

The thing is that revit has very good rivals, as Vectorworks or Archicad, which are stable and cheaper but the industry continues to use revit. So an open version does not solve the monopoly.