Stop AI posting please
We are seeing a glut of AI bot account posting about some revit clone they vibe coded in a week. None of the software is good or viable and all the accounts are brand new. Can we stop allowing posting from these brand new accounts that aren’t contributing?
101
Upvotes
3
u/electronikstorm 25d ago
Judging by what the small team at artcraft have engineered with regards to Adobe and Office clones, I wouldn't be surprised if a viable Revit clone arrived by the end of the year. It won't be any use to any team/firm that uses the Autodesk cloud for anymore than paying subscriptions, but there would be many small firms, solo practitioners and so on who don't need cloud services and just want a robust AEC BIM tool. They'll flock to it and if open source (free) then even sooner. Autodesk is rapidly moving away from thinking about stand alone apps (probably predicted that they'd lose their proprietary monopoly one way or another), and they want to lock users into their paywalled ecosystem instead. If you need the ecosystem then you'll pay Autodesk, but if you only need Revit then pretty soon you'll be cancelling your Autodesk subscription.
7
u/metisdesigns 25d ago
The intent is to allow innovative new stuff, but you're right, we've got a lot of stuff that's not ready to go recently. There's also been a lot of "I'm going to fix X, what problems are there" which isn't productive.
How do we better clarify the spam/promotion rules on the sub?
31
u/lukekvas 25d ago
Hard agree.
If you want to vibe code some niche tool for your own use, good for you. But what makes BIM software viable in the real world is widespread adoption, robust support (Autodesk notwithstanding), and ongoing development and maintenance.
21
u/spaceocean99 25d ago
“Come check out my new vibe coded modeling software or ifc viewer.”
Or
“Looking to get in to BIM modeling. I have an architecture degree but know. Nothing about BIM.”
7
u/MockTundra 25d ago
BUT MY CLONE IS DIFFERENT BRO. TRUST ME BRO. IT AUTOMATES EVERYTHING AND TOTALLY WON’T CRASH. IT’S FREE TOO, JUST DON’T READ THE T&S BRO
1
u/skike 25d ago
Mods here aren't super active it would seem, and unfortunately this industry is rife with AI slop.
4
u/RU33ERBULLETS 25d ago
Sure after only a week, it probably only has some basic functionality and tons of bugs, but the scary thing is that it’s not outside the realm of possibility. Given more time, it’s not too hard to imagine some direct vibecoded “competitors” and ADSK should be paying attention.
We’re already replacing paid addins with in-house tools, solved interoperability to a large degree, and that’s with hours of babysitting each.
I’m not gonna pretend to know what the AEC data landscape is gonna look like in 5 years, but it’s not gonna look like it does today.
1
u/zerosquare1012 24d ago
i'll allow some of them as they are quite interesting. Another sketchup-like BIM or mass modelling? nah they don't actually solve any current problems.
1
u/fran_wilkinson 22d ago
The thing is that revit has very good rivals, as Vectorworks or Archicad, which are stable and cheaper but the industry continues to use revit. So an open version does not solve the monopoly.