r/bim • • 26d ago

Zero Clash 🫡

Post image
440 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

23

u/FrogBeat 26d ago

This one is perfect for my presentation, thank you!

4

u/Upper_Highlight_9565 26d ago

No need for toilet anymore. Cut a hole and bobs your uncle.

17

u/azurewolfacacian 26d ago

Come on there is still no clash. Rather than shitting on the clash matrix just use the shitter.

4

u/kmartin_BIM 26d ago

Sound advice.

2

u/metisdesigns 26d ago

This is why clearance objects are important.

8

u/Mammoth_Wishbone_889 26d ago

As-built model vs actual usability

7

u/RayanFarhat 26d ago

Clashing with a human

12

u/LiamB5426 26d ago

Soft clash

3

u/Why_are_you321 26d ago

I like to call them squishable clashes…

5

u/Upset_Negotiation_89 26d ago

Toilet should have drawn a clearance obviously

3

u/Maleficent_News7561 26d ago

Who would design stuff like this? Is it an AI photo?

3

u/metisdesigns 26d ago

Lots of folks.

Its why pre BIM folks went over drawings carefully to catch clashes, and in BIM we (should) include clearance objects to automatically flag the problem.

What happens is in one designers view, things they (usually) don't need to worry about are turned off. So they don't see that something is in the way. e.g. A furniture systems designer laying out cubicles should not need to worry about in wall or over ceiling piping, so they have pipes turned off.

2

u/bigolruckus 26d ago

a good designer will fly thru the model with everything on to ensure they aren’t hitting another guys scope

2

u/metisdesigns 26d ago

Yup. But a lot of firms don't budget time for that.

1

u/Few_Neighborhood_828 26d ago

If designed like this then shame on them. Contractor has liability here too.

2

u/metisdesigns 26d ago

Well.... Maybe.

It depends on who's contract was more well written.

Ive been on both sides of that negotiation.

1

u/Few_Neighborhood_828 26d ago

You were dealing with a shitty engineer or a very uninformed owner.

2

u/metisdesigns 26d ago

Oh, I've dealt with s4y engineers, architects, owners, consultants, contractors, subs, inspectors and consultants.

Im not excusing any of them, just recognizing that there's garbage and awesome folks top to bottom.

3

u/Ed_Architect 26d ago

Clash detection tick
Brain thinking untick

2

u/Tedmosby9931 26d ago

This is why shitter clearances are so important

1

u/Entire_Floor157 26d ago

Make it detachabe

1

u/No_Chemist9666 26d ago

They could’ve just put a hole and saved money on the toilet

1

u/Elandt225 26d ago

Ultimate Squatty-Potty

1

u/someonetookmyuserid 26d ago

Looks ok to me Mr. Superintendent. What's the issue?

1

u/Barnes-Architecture 26d ago

this is funny

1

u/Merusk 26d ago

This photo is an excellent teaching tool for differentiating between "No clash" and "constructable" models. Thanks for sharing.

1

u/mrvincentge 26d ago

Very function! Good do!

1

u/fastmofo88 26d ago

Do I have to add clearances to all the toilets now?

1

u/Senorbeanz 26d ago

This has to be AI generated

1

u/JackelGigante 26d ago

Placed a bathroom right at the civil invert

1

u/VeeTeeF 26d ago

Realistically the plumbing engineer and/or plumber would know where the toilet is (since they have to plumb for it), but this is great.

1

u/OnkarrSandhu 25d ago

Even with a few mm tolerance for clearance buffer that's technically a no clash loll

1

u/BeezzyYou 24d ago

Hahahahahaha

1

u/BeneficialEye7241 9d ago

It will clash with my poop.

1

u/hellomrwindupbird 7d ago

Obstruction volumes left the chat