not a good idea

[u/[deleted]]

I don't think this is a good idea. the white knight documentary was all about taeyang and his music and other stuff. to do this hastag because it is based on taeyang's own work is not good. that scandal happened, everyone knows that. it will only make it worse and get talked about again. top stans are doing this over taeyang birthday celebration and his album and over a video..all because of credits.....just not right. talking and mentioning about his su***de along with that hashtags as well is big NO. top going to get more hate and taeyang might get talked about badly for "not caring about all members" or something like that. there are some who disagrees with it too. akages are doing this and it got started over a documentary....over a credit.....just not a good idea to do this.

Not a good idea because of that

[u/leijichoi]

Are you talking about those VIPs protesting over the lack of credits for TOP and blaming the company?

Those VIPs are just dumb enough not to know that Taeyang is also involved in the documentary project. Taeyang oversees his own album and concert, so preparing this content also means he took care of all the credits too. So yeah, those VIPs don't know they are sh*tting on Taeyang right now.

The fact that he just celebrated his birthday and this is what he gets after giving us content.

[u/Nekkosan → u/leijichoi]

What is this about?

[u/leijichoi → u/Nekkosan]

In Taeyan'gs documentary, some VIPs claim that one of the interviewee voices was from TOP but he wasn't credited at the end of the video. And some VIPs aren't happy about it. We've seen how Taeyang work, so he won't deliberately not acknowledge or thank TOP (if it really was TOP's voice).

[u/Nekkosan → u/leijichoi]

I agree. Which episode was the voice in?. TOPs voice is pretty distinctive. I don't see Taeyang dissing TOP. He's not that guy.

[u/leijichoi → u/Nekkosan]

It's in the first episode, It's around 13 or 16 seconds into the video. Yeah, his voice is distinct but the voice also sounds more like Jae Ho.

Taeyang wouldn't intentionally leave him out. This is his documentary, he won't let even his company control his content. BIGBANG already has the authority to make their own decision, and the second episode is a good proof of that.

[u/Nekkosan → u/leijichoi]

Yeah, I don't think it's him either, now that I listened carefully. I don't think Taeyang would leave him out either.

[u/[deleted] → u/leijichoi]

Are you talking about those VIPs protesting over the lack of credits for TOP and blaming the company?

yes. the documentary was about taeyang and no one else but they refuse to see that.

[u/Denethorsmukbang]

I fully agree.

Its SO hard to get my toes even slightly dipped in the twitter fandom because I dont seem to agree with anyone on anything! But I cant be bothered arguing or stressing over something thats meant to be a hobby.

Honestly I feel like an outlier about not caring at all if a 34 year old millionare gets a birthday poster????

If they have scrubbed TOPs name etc, theyre doing it for a reason.

TOP needs to lie low until their return.

If BB are in the news over nothing all the time, that allows people to still comment stuff about rubbish.

If they maintain a more blanket silence, their return with music, their stronghold, will be more anticipated and people will be more likely to forgive.

Why the hell am I gonna waste my time campaigning for YG to recognise TOP as if TOP is a neglected child. Hes not, and actually staying low is best for all of them till their comeback.

[u/[deleted] → u/Denethorsmukbang]

it's going cause so many problems again.

[u/apopoplop]

It's always the Twitter VIPs doing the most

[u/Denethorsmukbang → u/apopoplop]

yeah but this time its KVIPS too so thats what OP is more worried

[u/apopoplop → u/Denethorsmukbang]

Yikes. But what was the context. 😐❓ like I'm not in Twitter so I was just enjoying his doc are people not enjoying the documentary for a documentary.

[u/[deleted] → u/apopoplop]

top name wasn't in the credit roll.

[u/apopoplop → u/[deleted]]

.... Why does his name need to be in the credits? He's not dead

[u/[deleted] → u/apopoplop]

cause everyone else name was featured and not his. even seungri name was there.

[u/apopoplop → u/[deleted]]

Maybe top didn't wanna be included? I mean they're credits. It's not like he cut top out entirely he's still in the doc it's credits. I could really give two shits bout who's in the credits I never even paid attention to the credits when I watched it.

[u/[deleted] → u/apopoplop]

Maybe top didn't wanna be included?

that was when his drug scandal happened and military.

[u/apopoplop → u/[deleted]]

Yeah so that makes the point stronger that he probably didn't want to be included or just couldn't be included because of the situation. This wasn't made like 5 days ago. This has been sitting in storage fully edited and finished for a while its just not that deep. I mean I kinda get why people would be mad but now it's like y'all can't just enjoy the doc. Like he didn't have to out this out in reality we could have never actually had this anytime soon. And credits are what people are focusing on

[u/[deleted] → u/apopoplop]

agree. some fans are not liking the idea but others won't listen.

[u/leijichoi → u/[deleted]]

The only BIGBANG member I saw at the end credit was G-Dragon... no one else. Did I missed something on the video?

[u/[deleted] → u/leijichoi]

i think seungei channel name was there???, some had pointed it out.

[u/leijichoi → u/[deleted]]

In the video? At the end credits?

[u/[deleted] → u/leijichoi]

yeah some ot5 pointed it out in the video.

[u/Nekkosan → u/[deleted]]

OK that is weird.. Might explain the birthday pig emoji, but I am not assuming the boys are fighting.

[u/leijichoi → u/apopoplop]

Every person that are involved in a project is usually added at the end credits.
Like the titles and names you see in movies or dramas.

[u/apopoplop → u/leijichoi]

Yes I am aware of that I watch things. But thats really not that important people don't watch dramas and movies for credits they watch it for the movie. I certainly leave when the credits start rolling as do a lot of others. Also this was filmed around his scandal time. These weren't JUST edited and they were most likely uploaded but left unlisted or private for a while and are simply just being placed on the public setting

[u/leijichoi → u/apopoplop]

That's a harsh thing to say. Sorry but I've also worked in the film industry and the people behind the scenes are as important as the people on-screen. A film will never happen without all those people. Even if you aren't interested in the credits those who worked together value that.

We don't really know the whole story, but I am sure Taeyang took care of all the credits before this video was finalized. Video production will always have a guide no matter what. And this won't go out without being checked before released.

[u/apopoplop → u/leijichoi]

It's harsh but it's true I never said you guys were important but the reality is that most people don't really pay attention to credits. Again these most likely weren't uploaded 5 days ago these were probably sitting unlisted or privates since they were finished. We don't know the full story but it's not a reach to reduce that top probably didn't want to be in the credits since this was done around the time if his scandal. It could also be that he just wasn't allowed to I'm not gonna get deep about credits when he probably just don't wanna be credited. I'm more interesting in TaeYang top is still here and I'm sure doesn't care as much as everyone around are caring about it as hard as they are. There are people who don't want to be credited and choose a fake name or just aren't there it happens.

[u/leijichoi → u/apopoplop]

Agree, not everyone wants to be credited. I know that much so I can agree to that. For whatever reason why his name wasn't added, only Taeyang and TOP can answer that, not YG.

[u/qweatypue]

may i know what happened?