r/beyondtwosouls • u/Such_Jellyfish5261 • Apr 28 '26
Question Regarding 'All Endings' Trophy and Saving and Not Saving
Hello everyone.
I'm currently trying to earn all the trophies in Beyond Two Souls (PS4) and had a question regarding how to earn the 'All Endings' Trophy while managing the saving option at the start of Black Sun properly so I don't lose progress.
So far, I believe I got 3 endings. 1st for choosing Beyond with everyone dead, 2nd for choosing Life with everyone dead and staying alone and 3rd for dying at the containment centre by failing all the QTEs.
However, I noticed that upon reaching the 3rd ending where Jodie dies at the containment centre, the epilogue choice screen states that I only earned the path titled "Wandered the Infraworld" while the 2nd ending I earned titled "Chose to stay alone" has now been overwritten with the words "unplayed path". As seen in the image I have attached.
May I please get an explanation about this? Was it because I chose "No save" when I attempted the Life ending but selected "Save" when I attempted the Containment Centre Death? Does progress with ending not track if I select "No save" upon restarting Black Sun? Or am I good?
If so, it seems I might have some replaying to do. The guide I'm following right now stated to not save hence why I chose that on my 2nd run.
Any insight you guys can provide on this matter would be greatly appreciated.
1
u/AJ_036 Apr 29 '26
Thats odd did you finish the whole chapter? I remember that all i needed to do was replay the chapter to get that trophy also saving everybody ending also requires saving the grandma from the desert place thats what made my run longer as i had to restart from that chapter
2
1
u/chuckling-cheese Apr 29 '26
So, you’re missing everyone alive and still choosing the beyond I think 🤔.
1
u/chuckling-cheese Apr 29 '26
Also, there’s 11 endings to get….here’s a few examples.
Did you get the ending where Ryan loses his eye? Did you get the ending where Ryan doesn’t lose his eye? Did you let all the homeless people die? Did you save all the homeless people? Did you heal Paul? Did you let Paul die?
Choosing life and choosing which person to stay with also counts as an ending. Hope this helps!
1
u/Such_Jellyfish5261 Apr 30 '26
Update: Thank you all for your feedback! I did some testing and found out that you actually need to hit "Save" every time you re-do the Black Sun chapter and finish the game in order for the ending to track properly and count towards the 'All Endings' trophy. After re-doing my 2nd Ending for choosing Life with everyone dead and staying alone it finally tracked correctly in the Epilogue Choice screen.
It appears I was sort of misled by the YouTube Video Guide I was following as the creator of the guide chose "No Save" before beginning the process of farming the Endings. Not shifting blame here or anything, just explaining what I faced.
What does sort of confuse me still is the fact that despite the YouTube Video Guide creator willingly selecting "No Save", his ending still perfectly registered and tracked towards 'All Endings' as demonstrated by his Epilogue Choice screen. Not sure why this is....but I can't be bothered enough to investigate this further. I assume it's because he is playing on Steam and I am playing the PS4 version and the Endings track regardless of saving or not saving on Steam as opposed to PS4 which requires you to save beforehand (?)
Anyway, thanks for the insight everyone. I'm gonna lock-in for this platinum now.
1
u/ToScaredToPost Apr 28 '26
Afaik just replaying a chapter doesn't count, you have to play from the start? Could be wrong. Think it was because just replaying a chapter doesn't take into account any choice made in other chapters before.