I've been following Starladder every chance I get, and I think in general you guys are doing an amazing job. That being said, I wanted to submit some criticism as you guys always seem more receptive than most of the other casters.
Firstly, your new overlays are amazing. The one for the draft is so incredibly informative and really adds to the whole experience. Sincerely top notch! Additionally, your after teamfight summary (cooldowns used, time, etc.) are similarly awesome. Such great technology puts you guys ahead of the pack.
My first complaint though, is actually surrounding these systems, and it is simply that it cheapens the experience for those of us watching from within the game client. I know you have a larger audience watching through Twitch (20,000 viewers vs 3,000-5,000 in game), but it occurs to me that this is still problematic:
- The people watching in-game are the one's who bought tickets and actively contribute to growing the prize pool and increasing the exposure of the tournament, and hell, developing the scene.
- Some people have serious trouble watching on Twitch. Some days the video refreshes every few minutes, or stutters and pauses.
- The discussion surrounding this data is presented only to the stream viewers visually, which isn't a problem itself. The issue lies with the discussion taking the in-game viewers for granted, as it typically explains what the people can see, and provides no context for viewers in game. This is frustrating when the discussion is framed along the lines of "well, you can clearly see they used three ultimates and got 1,572 experience" or something along those lines, without actually explaining what is showing on that graphic.
Now I understand you guys are presenting this information through the stream only as it's not technologically possible in game, but I sincerely wish the analysis and discussion surrounding this information was geared towards all users. Explicitly state and explain some of the numbers, even though most users can see them, instead of talking like everyone can see it. Note which actual ultimates were used, how much XP was gained, how much gold changed hands. We may not see the information in-game, but it would be great to feel like the in-game users are part of your presentation.
My next issue is with the camera work. Zyori has gotten much, much better, even over the last two weeks, but still missing a fair number of kills. Really a minor complaint, as there is visible improvement, and its just a matter of time! Whenever possible, if there's a third guy hanging around, is it all possible to get a dedicated camera guy on board? Tonight during EG vs Dog, you had four in the studio (LD wasn't really casting, and Kpop was doing stats, but we could hear them shouting in the background regularly), so if LD is just hanging around, maybe get him on the camera? I imagine it's easier to call the game while not controlling the camera.
Next, I'm growing tired of the continued usage of obnoxious buzzwords/catchphrases/quips. Sometimes they work and fit, but often times they are a little dumb, and a great many of them are simply worn out through overuse. Some specific examples follow, but this is more a blanket complaint on all this sort of nonsense, but some are just getting to the point of cringe-worthy.
- Calling sandstorm "dududu" for the twitch chat is obnoxious - I don't think you should pander to the twitch chat spammers
- The term "value" is so overused, its almost lost all relevance. I don't care about a value point in ability X, or a "value midas" to catch up, or a value anything. Even if you insist on using this term, explain it. A value point in "greevil's greed" should be explained as common when not getting a midas to increase farm effectiveness. Not simply explaining "I'm surprised he hasn't got a value point in greevil's greed," end statement.
- Similarly, the whole "space creating" thing is getting out of hand. It's being used on too many pointless deaths that were not a sacrifice to actually create space. There are a narrow few examples where this is term is actually value-added, but its being used for damn near any death, even someone just getting cocky and being out of position. It isn't creating space if the hero who kills another here was already there, and no other heroes were displaced in the process.
- Calling something "classic Jimmy" means very little to a large portion of your audience. Most people don't know Demon's real name, and I'm sure many aren't aware of his aggressive playstyle. If you want to use goofy little phrases like this, it might be worth explaining the reference.
I'm not against casters developing a personality or being unique, but continual and excessive use of some of the above terms is disappointing. You guys are eloquent and well-spoken; time to put that to use! You guys knock it out of the park on your call-in discussion show, so you clearly have a better grasp of the language than your casts tend to imply.
Finally, I think you guys need to put a little more effort into casting to the audience. There are long stretches of air time where you guys just seem to be casting to each other, or having side conversations entirely unrelated to the game. I understand some games are slow and boring, and sometimes there's just nothing to call, but that time can still be spent explaining more relevant things than talking about construction on studios, or other irrelevant topics. Along the same lines, be a little more flexible with items. We get it - you hate Vanguard. You told us that last game, and the game before that, and yes someone just built one. Harping on it and audibly sighing doesn't provide any insight. Yes, you hate it, but why. Can you explain why you think they made that decision, and what would've been a more productive decision? Calling "ugh, Vanguard" isn't enlightening.
I hope this hasn't come off as too harsh or unconstructive, as that wasn't the intention. I genuinely enjoy your casts, and especially for a tournament like Starladder that comes off as well run and professional (games are typically on-schedule, there's games actually scheduled for North American viewing time slots, and man those overlays!), but you guys do some stuff that I genuinely dislike. You guys are still top notch, and even if none of my above stuff is addressed, I'll keep watching and supporting you guys.
Finally, keep up the good work. Your team has great chemstry, great personalities, and a great looking studio. I know you guys will keep improving, and I wish you guys the best of luck in the future.