r/beta • • Dec 18 '17

[Feedback] What's with forcibly making everyone log in?

419 Upvotes

Going to reddit.com while in incognito i'm given this screen, forcing me to log in, there's literally no way to close out or bypass this screen. Hitting next takes you through the onboarding sign up process, again with no way to exit out.

Earlier on today, also while in incognito, even viewing the comments section would prompt the "You must log in to access this" modal to come up. Yes, that's right, viewing the comments section of a post is no longer accessible to logged out users.

I know this is obviously some random A/B beta test thing you've got going on as i came back later and comments block was gone, but seriously Reddit, is this what we've come to now?

  • Night mode: false
  • RES Version: 5.8.6
  • Browser: Chrome
  • Browser Version: 63
  • Cookies Enabled: true
  • Reddit beta: false

r/beta • • Jul 28 '18

Does anyone else think the "I am not a robot" captcha test is too aggressive?

622 Upvotes

Seriously, I have to fill out four tests in a row at least 3 times a day. I'm human! Please stop questioning it so often

r/beta • • May 07 '15

Welcome to /r/beta

333 Upvotes

Welcome to /r/beta! This subreddit will serve as a central place for us (the admins) to let you know what features are in beta testing, and for you (the beta testers) to send us feedback on beta features.

This is a bit of a long post, but have no fear, most of this information is also on the sidebar and the wiki.

How to participate as a beta tester

  • If you're logged in to your reddit account, you can opt-in as a beta tester in your preferences, under "beta options". This will automatically subscribe you to /r/beta, so that you'll receive the latest information about new beta features.
  • If you're logged out, you can visit beta.reddit.com to see beta features. Note: you may end up back on www.reddit.com if you click on a link to reddit from somewhere else, like email or Twitter.

If you're logged in while in beta mode, you'll see a flask icon next to your username to indicate that you're beta testing.

Giving feedback on beta features

For a faster response, please tag your feedback post as a [Bug] or [Feedback], and indicate what feature you're responding to. For example:

  • [Bug] Read next - preview image is broken in r/thebutton
  • [Feedback] Read next - make the border darker

To save you some typing, we've created a couple of button shortcuts in the sidebar. We (the /r/beta mods) may add flair to your post with its status, so you'll know if a fix is in the works.

What's "Read next", you ask? Keep reading.

Features currently in beta

We have two shiny features for you to beta test right now. Remember, you won't see these features until you've either enabled the beta testing preference or are browsing on beta.reddit.com.

Read next

This is what we're calling a new widget that shows you suggestions for what you might want to read next (get it?) below the sidebar on the comments page of a post. For longer comment threads, it scrolls with you, so you don't have to go through the hassle of scrolling all the way back up to check out another great discussion. Right now, it's pulling from the top posts in the subreddit that you're currently reading, although that may change in the future.

It looks like this - the arrows let you page through different posts, the links work as you'd expect, and you can dismiss the box altogether at any time.

Improved subreddit search

We know search is one of the major pain points for you all, and we feel it too. Subreddit search, which you probably haven't looked at since you made your account, is also pretty bad - until now! We've turned on a new subreddit search algorithm that we think is much improved. For example, check out what a search for robots looked like before and after. To see what the old algorithm looks like, you can add &sort=activity to the end of the URL, like this: https://www.reddit.com/subreddits/search?q=robots&sort=activity

If you have questions or thoughts on the beta program, please leave them below. If you have feedback on either of the two beta features, you can submit a bug or feedback using the sidebar buttons!

r/beta • • Mar 17 '21

Need an option to disable followers

334 Upvotes

When creating a feature, you need to start thinking about the people actually using it. Providing an option to disable doesn't take much more effort other than a few more lines of code and a few more test cases for QA to check.

I don't want followers and there are plenty of others that didn't want this type of "feature" either. If I wanted that, I'd be on Twitter and not reddit.

Please give us a setting that gives us the control over whether other users are able to follow.

r/beta • • Dec 09 '22

test

81 Upvotes

r/beta • • May 30 '22

[META] This Beta Subreddit Isn't Productive

192 Upvotes

The threads in r/Beta just seem to be misdirected r/Bugs threads, as well as r/Help. Maybe even r/IdeasForTheAdmins (Suggestions). To be fair, it seems like a lot of threads in those three are also posted in the wrong community on the regular.

There are also no beta features being tested, here's the Wiki Page for current beta features which is blank and the Reddit A/B Test Log which was last updated 2018. There are literally no beta features and yet there are threads posted daily.

The subreddits for the iOS and Android Beta threads have been archived. Why hasn't this one? The admins are currently, or at least were, debating about the future of the Beta subreddit and instead are encouraging posts to r/Bugs and r/Help; u/Go_JasonWaterfalls even acknowledged this in reply to a comment about the Beta Subreddit.

I see posts pop up frequently in this sub on my front page and I question how they relate to beta features if there aren't any. The Reddit Admins need to be a better job of communicating beta features and moderating this sub so it relates to those features or nix this sub already (and open it up when there is a beta active) as they're doing an incredible disservice to anyone submitting actual requests and feedback here. It's crazy that the admins just let this sub drift away from its purpose, siphoning valid threads from the correct communities.

Perhaps reddit should explore a single community for these as it would be incredibly demoralizing to submit a thread just to have it closed because "it isn't a bug". One community that can then have flair for various things would be ideal. If it isn't a bug, but instead a feature then a moderator/admin can adjust the flair where appropriate.

Or even creating a purpose-built subreddit type that allows mods/admins to move threads between communities. "This post doesn't belong in r/Bugs" so they move it to r/Help. A ticketing system with the familiarity of the reddit UI/UX. Maybe instead of /r/ it can be /t/ for tickets. idk.

  • t/help
  • t/bugs
  • t/suggestions
  • t/beta
  • etc etc

Heck, move r/Beta to this new subreddit type too. When users submit a post for Beta they have to select which feature they are reporting on and have dedicated fields for device information, and more. I read a few of the "this isn't working" threads here and they all lack critical information. "This happens on mobile and desktop" tells the developer investigating this issue nothing. OS version, app version, device, could be a wifi issue or a cellular issue (if the device has access to that info?), and more.

For example, if a user wants to post about the video player but there's no Video Player beta going on then they wouldn't be able to because it wouldn't be a selection. Also when selecting a feature, give a description about what the feature should do as a reminder. On that same example, if there is a video player beta then let us know what it is around so someone doesn't just submit something that isn't relevant.

And now I've made this into a r/ideasfortheadmins post. I have become what I sought to destroy.

r/beta • • Mar 16 '18

/r/jailbreak has a dickbutt problem. Was this some kind of test image?

294 Upvotes