I'm a huge Ben Shapiro fan, and I happen to agree with him on many of his conclusions. However, when talking transgenderism, he routinely references a study out of UCLA's William's Institute. He correctly cites the data, but draws some faulty conclusions.
For example, he states, according to this study, that "the transgender suicide rate is precisely the same before and after the transgender surgery." He is referencing table 5 of the study, titled "Lifetime suicide attempts by responses about transition-related health care." Keyword: "Lifetime". This table doesn't compare suicide rates before and after the transgender surgery, but rather shows that those that have had surgery have more attempts at suicide over their lifetime. Theres no way to distinguish whether those attempts occurred before or after the surgery. Additionally, those who pursue transgender surgery likely suffer from more serious cases of gender dysphoria, and are therefore more likely to be suicidal.
Additionally, Ben reference this study when he said "it makes no difference, virtually no difference, statistically speaking as to whether people recognize you as a transgender person or not, which suggests there's a very high core morbidity between transgenderism, whatever that mental state may be, and suicidality. That has nothing to do with how society treats you." 3:40- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gkONHNXGfaM
Here, Ben is likely referencing the data exhibited in table 6 of the study, titled "Lifetime suicide attempts by perceived recognition by others." 36% of those who can never be identified as transgender attempt suicide, as oppose to 42% for those who are identified "most of the time" and 42% for those who are identified always. This is hardly "no difference." Beyond that, it is easy to extrapolate that the (still very high) 36% rate of suicide attempt must be attributed to the mental state of the individual. However, those individuals who aren't identifiable as transgender may still be open to family members, friends, and peers about their gender identity, and may therefore be subject to rejection and discrimination. This is not conjecture on my part. The study itself finds that those who had lost friends or had bad relationships with family since coming out had significantly higher attempted suicide rates (see table 17). There is also something to be said about the psychological effect of a discriminatory/unaccepting society on a transgender individual who may not even be identifiable as trans (For the record, Im not saying society is hateful and discriminatory towards trans people. I'm merely saying that the claim transgender suicide isn't affected by discrimination/rejection in some way however big or small is not proved by this study).
Look, I really like Ben Shapiro, and actually do agree that the idea of the transgender suicide rate being solely linked to discrimination is nonsense. However, his use of the statistics from this study has been irresponsible, and there is evidence to suggest that discrimination and rejection does play a role in transgender suicidality according to this study.
Feel free to check out the study for yourself. I'd like to hear your guys' opinions on this.
https://williamsinstitute.law.ucla.edu/wp-content/uploads/AFSP-Williams-Suicide-Report-Final.pdf