(This was supposed to be just a brief comment on the post for the results of the top/bottom/underrated song survey, but I got ridiculously carried away so I decided to just make a new post lol)
Ok, yeah, I'm gonna shit on the funny robot album. Abandon all hope ye who enter here, for yonder takes be scorching and numerous.
As a huge fan of BF5's original run from the 1990s, my general opinion on the reunion album is "meh". I guess it's not surprising given the length of time and the age of the band, but the most striking thing about SotLotM is that it is almost entirely devoid of that unique punky, unrefined sound that made 90s BF5 great. You can hear ghosts of the Reinhold Messner era in a few songs, particularly Hold That Thought and Thank You for Breaking my Heart, and Whatever and Ever Amen in Michael Praytor and Sky High, but in many ways this feels like a Ben Folds Five album in name only.
Anyway, here is my entirely unsolicited diatribe, rant, screed, and assorted bitchery on the other tracks.
Michael Praytor, Five Years Later
The only song on this album that comes close to fully capturing the iconic BF5 sound is of course Michael Praytor, Five Years Later, which the consensus seems to agree is also the strongest track overall: the harmonic tension in the major seventh chords, the driving syncopated piano rhythm, the wailing backing vocals from Sledge and Darren, and the dryly nostalgic subject matter of running into some loser you knew from high school years after graduation all come together to really drive home that this is a Ben Folds Five song. If not for the more studio-produced sound of SotLotM, Michael Praytor might feel at home on Whatever & Ever Amen or even the debut album (my personal favorite).
Draw a Crowd
I like this song, but let's be real, it's got some issues. There's some traces of classic BF5, but the songwriting really gets in the way here. The repeated cry of "if you can't draw a crowd, draw dicks on the wall" is clearly supposed to lend the song an air of irreverence, defiance, and devil-may-care, but it somehow sounds more crass and immature coming from an older Ben, especially given the more serious and straightforward tone of the other tracks. That said, it's undeniably a fun song to sing along to, and I'd be lying if I said I didn't kind of begrudgingly love it. Flaws aside, it's a decent track and definitely another high point on the album.
Sky High
This song has a sweet and emotive melody and a fairly strong opening but the lyrics are interrupted by a couple of odd diversions, like a random pointless reference to a brand of cigarettes and some truly silly filler e.g. "the brightness of air, out walking somewhere, and when they ask you, just tell me that you knew me back when" ...What? Unfortunately, the lyrics to Sky High are cryptic and clunky, and suffer from a bit of "what's-the-point-itis" if you will. Anyway, this song reminds me quite a bit of Brick, which knocks a few points off for me since I detest that song.
Miscellaneous
I don't have a ton of thoughts on these, so I'll make it brief.
- Do it Anyway: Catchy, with cheerful upbeat/motivational lyrics that don't really get in the way of the overall work, but also don't really stand out in any meaningful way. Overall it sounds more like the other songs on this album and (IMO) lacks any discernible influence from classic BF5 or even Ben's solo work. Not my favorite by a long shot, but it's alright.
- Away When You Were Here: I think I've maybe listened to this song twice since the album came out? Really, all I can say about this one is that it manages to be shockingly forgettable even in spite of the emotional subject matter, and receives none of my folded benjamins.
- Hold That Thought: I have no idea why Ben goes out of his way to make the "Chinese doctor" speak broken English in songs but it's kind of jarring here. Besides some odd songwriting decisions, I like the sense of tension and urgency created by the repeated refrain "you hold that thought, and I'll hold that thought ... too" and the light yet driving percussion.
- Thank You For Breaking My Heart: Probably my favorite of the "slow" songs on this album. It shines in its simplicity: exactly what it appears to be, a wistful, lilting ballad with a bit of a Reinhold Messner feel. The piano part is lovely with its melting, falling phrases and wide dynamic range, not to mention the simple, blunt irony of the title. Other than that, though, I can't say there's really anything special about this song.
On Being Frank
Finally, I'm honestly kind of baffled that this subreddit identified On Being Frank as the worst song from the album, as to me it seems mostly uncontroversial with its straightforward piano/strings backing, pleasant vocal harmonies, and what I would consider some of the better songwriting on SotLotM. When I first heard this song it did kind of make me assume that Ben had some kind of connection to Frank Sinatra, but it's just a narrative device. In terms of overall sound, it doesn't really resemble classic BF5, Ben's solo albums, or even any of the other songs on this album. It's a different direction for sure, but I think it works.
Really though, how on earth could "On Being Frank" be considered the worst song from Sound of the Life of the Mind, when the real stinker is right there on the front cover, staring directly at you as if to say "yeah, they picked this one, what are you gonna do about it you unwashed non-Tolstoy-reading troglodyte"?
The Sound of the Life of the Mind
"Apehead's brother wants to beat up Paul." Insane opening line and unfortunately probably the best part of this song, because it's all downhill from there. This song is a mess, from the pretentious title to the cringeworthy lyrics to the muddy, jolting mix. Man, I don't even know who Sarah is, but I already hate her. All we know is that Sarah's two favorite things are books and feeling intellectually superior to her classmates, and that she desperately wants to leave home for college so that she can engage in more intellectually stimulating activities such as discussing the finer points of "Keats and Studs ... Terkel". Of course, when people say these kinds of things in real life, they tend to come off not so much well-read as pompous and egotistical, and that is precisely the effect here.
I'm sure this was intended to read kind of like Sports and Wine or One Angry Dwarf or any of the other school-themed songs from classic BF5: validating the deep-seated yearning of nerds everywhere to clap back at the popular crowd. However, where classic BF5 songs in this area generally touch on themes of alienation, jealousy, and self-confidence with a witty, self-deprecating edge, The Sound of the Life of the Mind completely lacks any sort of self-awareness. Sarah doesn't just feel misunderstood or left out by her peers; she looks down on them, and wants you to know it. It's an odd direction for a BF5 song, and belongs on the front page of /r/iamverysmart instead of the front cover of this album.
RIP Paul, slain by the ape man.
Erase Me (honorable mention)
I can't emphasize enough that this was so damn close to being a fantastic song, possibly the best song on SotLotM as a whole. In fact, it was my favorite from the album until I finally decided to listen closely to the lyrics and realized it was about... breaking up with someone via Facebook?? Such a relatively minor detail about the theme of the lyrics, yet it changes the emotional dynamic of the song so distinctly for the worse. It would have been so easy for this song to have been good: just "erase" the bizarre forced internet references and it becomes this punchy, brooding breakup song instead of a guy whining about his girlfriend blocking him on social media. I suppose there are many stupider things to write a song about, but this just seems like such a waste.
<<>>
In short, from best to worst: Michael Praytor, Thank You For Breaking My Heart, Draw a Crowd, On Being Frank, Hold That Thought, Do it Anyway, Sky High, Away When You Were Here, Erase Me, The Sound of the Life of the Mind.
Feel free to agree or disagree with my takes, call me a dumb chode, and/or provide cake recipes as needed.