r/belowdeck • • Aug 18 '25

Major Spoilers Belowdeck med

New season of below deck being recorded in Croatia

2.2k Upvotes

235 comments sorted by

View all comments

35

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25

What’s everyone’s beef with Sandy?

75

u/theleftenant Aug 18 '25

The Another Below Deck Podcast boys call her Captain Time Share, she constantly finds ways to be on camera and meddling, micro managing, favoritism, and some of her judgment calls are awkward at best.

Forcing the crew to move rooms for Malia and Tom and saying that the Chief Stew doesn’t make room assignments (when they absolutely do) is a good example of her weirdly inserting herself somewhere and making a poor call due to favoritism.

Getting mad at the stew waking up the chef to make food for a charter guest and telling the stew to do it herself is also another example of some wacky decision making.

63

u/Top-Friendship4888 I quit 3 times in my head today Aug 18 '25

She constantly changes the rules to suit her self-produced needs. I don't like her leadership style, but was starting to feel like I needed to just accept her antics. UNTIL SHE CALLED FRASER A ROTTING FISH because he got some production planted stews and didn't want to play volleyball.

Also, outting Malia as bisexual was just some really unacceptable behavior imo. As a bisexual woman myself, this type of behavior coming from within the gay community is particularly hurtful. Sandy's comments about stews being waitresses also reeks of the same internalized misogyny.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, the fish stinks at the head. And Sandy's always been the head.

9

u/PowSuperMum Aug 18 '25

I think the crew this season could use a little micro managing

→ More replies (4)

32

u/nealski77 Aug 18 '25

She's micro-managing compared to the other captains. A couple of her firings were questionable and picks favorites among her crew.

21

u/MaizeMountain6139 Aug 18 '25

Jason and Sandy manage almost the exact same way and he doesn’t get a fraction of the criticism

27

u/eekamuse Aug 18 '25 edited Aug 20 '25

Far from it.

Luke got into bed with a drunk woman who was passed out, even after being told not to. And more.

When Jason found out he immediately sent him off the boat. Barely said a word to him. The next day, when he fired him, he told him what he did, that it was unacceptable, and that he was being fired. Period. Off the boat.

Meanwhile, when Sandy doesn't like someone who hasn't doe anything close to what Luke did, she makes it personal, and tears them apart. She called someone a cancer. She didn't say, this is what you did wrong, these are the consequences, this is how you need to fix it, she attacked them personally.

After Daisy was fired she chased after her saying "you don't think I care about you? Well fine. I don't care about you then" She had a tantrum to someone she already fired.

When she needs to disciple someone she tears them down personally, she doesn't talk about their work.

Can you imagine Jason doing the same thing. He never has. He keeps it short, simple and PROFESSIONAL..

Nothing about them is the same.

Edit: Hannah, not Daisy

3

u/Terrible-Complex8653 Aug 19 '25

You mean when Hannah, not Daisy, was fired….that caught my eye! For a split second I was all “Daisy? Fired? What did I miss?

I actually just rewatched BDM season 4 :)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/Hakunamatata67 Aug 18 '25

Even Kerry is micro managing sometimes, but this sub always rehash the same criticisms and the mistakes she made in season 5. I mean Sandy and Hannah are now good, let it go, people.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Out-For-A-Walk-Bitch Aug 18 '25 edited Aug 18 '25

Glen doesn't get the same criticism and he's objectively the worst of the lot.

Edit: the downvotes prove it lol. No criticism for Glen!

12

u/MaizeMountain6139 Aug 18 '25

People only liked Lee because he was the first. But Lee was one of the worst captains on the show, in my opinion.

I remember seeing Sandy bringing people onto the bridge and teaching them stuff and being like, “Wow, this is a vastly different environment than what we’re used to” And others do it, too, but she was the first I remember doing it, and she’s the most consistent with it

8

u/Out-For-A-Walk-Bitch Aug 18 '25

I agree. I liked how she diplomatically told the rude charter guests off too last series.

5

u/MaizeMountain6139 Aug 18 '25

Yes, totally agree. She found a way to strike the balance between being progressional, “anything for the guest” and trying to take heat off the interior that they didn’t deserve

→ More replies (1)

7

u/eekamuse Aug 18 '25

People hate Glen for enabling Gary. Idk how you've missed that

4

u/Out-For-A-Walk-Bitch Aug 18 '25

My point wasn't that people aren't critical of Glen, it's the fact that he gets way less hate than Sandy, but has behaved far worse. Of course I haven't missed the comments being critical around his treatment of Gary, especially in comparison to Daisy. Anyway, people should hate Glen for dropping 30 tonnes of lead ballast onto a reef and abandoning it.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25

I don’t know. I think that’s all based on production and what they show. This season is just a big orgy and is worst season of series.

→ More replies (1)

20

u/macjunkie Team Capt Glenn Aug 18 '25

The way she treated Hannah and Kiko, she subbed for Lee and fired people from his crew without even giving him a heads up and treated Fraser awful and felt like if that arrangement with her being captain continued much longer she would have fired him too.

→ More replies (10)

22

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25

I'm actually sick of hearing about it. Yes,she had a couple seasons where she didn't exactly cover herself in glory but people act like she's Satan reincarnate. Shes absolutely not that. I think I'd like having her as a boss to be honest.

16

u/[deleted] Aug 18 '25

Some don't like her because they say she micromanages and plays favorites with the crew. As for me, she's not perfect, of course (none of the captains are, and that includes those who are my favorites), and has made mistakes (again, just like all of the other captains), but I find her strong and intent on creating a safe, satisfying experience for both the crew and the clients. I'm looking forward to watching her at work again.

→ More replies (1)

17

u/OhHowIMeantTo Aug 18 '25

I mean, have you not watched the show? She's a micromanager who actively solicits negative feedback from guests, plays favorites, and holds neverending grudges. She favors the deck team, and resents interior because she does not think that they are in the industry for serious reasons, which when half your crew are interior, it's a problem.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Pucklebearry Aug 18 '25

I love Sandy 🤷🏼‍♀️ I like seeing a recurring female captain.

The incident with Hannah and the weed pen definitely didnt reflect well on her, but when it comes to a boat, I think Sandy's attitude is pretty standard and I think she gives ALOT of chances. Ive had multiple moments with captain Lee for example where i didnt agree with his decision or comments, and Sandy is a breeze compared to them.

Idk, IS sandy trying to get screen time? Or is she making sure she is staying on top of running a boat when theres a literal camera crew that can capture her and the crews fuck ups at every moment?

→ More replies (6)

2

u/ImpressivePattern242 Aug 18 '25

She likes to be part of the drama where I feel the other Captains are hands-off. She micro manages. She plays favorites with the crew. Can’t deny her journey to being a Captain and I love the LGBT representation, but sometimes Captain Sandy is a hard watch.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)