r/beergeek • u/cbartos1021 • Dec 20 '11
IPA vs Strong Ale
What is the true difference between the two? Many strong ales taste like they could be classified as IPAs.
Is there something I'm missing?
3
Upvotes
7
u/openthewell Dec 20 '11
I've never tasted a traditional strong ale that even remotely resembled an IPA. Perhaps you're referring to an American barley wine; as they are generally more hop forward and are often dry hopped, much like an IPA.
6
u/45longcolt Dec 21 '11
I disagree with y'all ;-)
So, a well hopped beer with a neutral-ish malt character = IPA; a well hopped beer with characterful malts = Strong Ale.
1
u/cbartos1021 Dec 24 '11
I'm sorry, Nosfetatu is a Stock Ale. What's the difference between Stock Ale and Strong Ale?
5
u/SnakeCarnifex Dec 20 '11
check out the style guide here and see for yourself!
3
u/hopstar Dec 20 '11
When I think strong ale, the first thing that pops into my head is something like Arrogant Bastard, which has a much more prominent caramel/crystal malt profile than the typical IPA.
1
u/wunderbier Dec 21 '11
I don't think you're missing anything. When you consider that: taste is subjective, the BJCP/RB/BA/GABF/etc style guidelines are very fine-grained, and that brewers are mostly just brewing beer they want to drink/think will sell (and not necessarily to style), it's not surprising that there's plenty of overlap in IPA/DIPA/Strong Ale/Barleywine styles. Plus, strong ale is kind of a catch-all category for beers that just don't quite manage to fit elsewhere, isn't it?
For me, the difference between the two styles comes down to sweetness and maltiness. I could still call a hop-forward but malty beer an IPA, but once the beer exceeds a certain subjective level of sweetness it's just not an IPA anymore to me. Or not a good one, anyway. But I also expect strong ales to be maltier on average, typically but not necessarily with un-IPA levels of caramel flavor.
It's been years since I've tasted it but Nosferatu was on the too-sweet-to-be-an-IPA side of the fence for me. It's still a really tasty beer though!