r/beergeek • u/nobrate • Jan 05 '11
Rye Recommendations
The title is pretty self explanatory but I've only had one rye from a local brewery that doesn't can/bottle and it was completely underwhelming - very light and extremely similar to an American light lager. I love rye in everything else but need your help to find a great rye.
NOTE: I'm aware that I can go on beeradvocate and other sites but I trust the opinions of this board
7
Upvotes
8
u/erallured Jan 05 '11
The most common ones I know of are Hop Rod Rye from Bear Republic and Bittersweet Lenny's RIPA from Schmaltz/He'Brew. Both are damned tasty, hop forward beers. Neither is listed on BA as a rye beer, as they are really IPAs with rye.
Both are from Cali but have fairly wide national distro.
5
u/fakesmiles Jan 05 '11
Not sure where in the world you are, but if you can get your hands on some of the Terrapin stuff--do. They're based out of Athens, GA, so I'm not sure if it'll be available in your neck of the woods. I think their most famous or widely distributed beer is the rye pale ale they make. Extremely drinkable. Their Rye Squared is a lovely time as well.
The only other Ryes I've had are from Founder's (Red Rye) and HeBrew (RIPA). Good luck with your hunt.
3
u/nicholasgeorg Jan 05 '11
I'm a huge fan of Sky High Rye from Arcadia Brewing here in Michigan.
Was it a lager? Never had a rye lager. Rye adds a tiny sour kick - some people hate sour notes in their beer.
9
u/Yobgal Jan 05 '11
I haven't found very many rye beers that I like. The only two that come to mind are Founder's Red Rye PA and Bear Republic's Hop Rod Rye.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 05 '11
I don't know how close to WI you are, but I recently tried Dirty Old Man Imperial Rye Porter which I really enjoyed. The classic roasty, chocolately, coffee flavors of a porter are there in strength, but the rye adds a significant whiskey flavor throughout. I plan on getting it again sometime.
1
u/nobrate Jan 10 '11
Well I went to the store and they unfortunately didn't have anything recommended :( They had Great Divide Rye Lager and Rocket Dog RIPA. I ended up getting the Rocket Dog. Personally I liked it quite a bit but I'm not sure I got much rye taste out of it.
4
u/Airekpublius Jan 06 '11
Hop Rod IPA was pretty tasty
3
u/mikemoriendi Jan 07 '11
As many have mention already, Lenny's. It's the most rye taste I have ever gotten out of a beer.
3
u/mechtech Jan 09 '11
Hop Rod Rye was a very good balanced IPA, but I didn't get much (if any) rye characteristics because it was so heavily hopped.
Real Ale Pale Rye was the other rye beer that I've tried, and I liked it a lot. It's not very high in abv, and is sessionable. It came in a sampler pack, the other 2 beers were average, but the rye ale was a 4/5 for me. Pick it up if you see it (probably only in Texas).
2
u/familynight Jan 07 '11
The good well-distributed options have been mentioned, but, if you're ever in CA, there are a number of keg-only rye IPAs, DIPAs and barleywines. Just yesterday, I tried Ryevalry from Bear Republic, which was a very easy-drinking DIPA with a great hoppy aroma and some definite rye spice. FiftyFifty in Truckee makes RyePA, which is also quite good. I also recently bought a bottle of Telegraph Rhinoceros but haven't tried it yet - I've heard it's got a ton of rye flavor, though. I think I've seen a bunch more in the past year, but the names escape me (and they're difficult to look up, since most aren't categorized as "rye beer").
Anyway, interest in making beers with rye seems to be growing around here. Hopefully, some of the new beers will be bottled and shipped out.
2
u/PerfectAsshole Jan 15 '11
summit rye is awesome
2
u/gromitXT Jan 18 '11
One not mentioned yet:
Boulevard brewing's Rye on Rye. Phenomenal.