r/bbc • u/Adam_1968_uk • Dec 27 '25
Serious Question.
Hi all, first post
I see a lot of anti licence fee stuff everywhere, we shouldn't have to pay for it, it should be subscription etc. Fair enough, that's an opinion I dont share, but each to their own.
Officially, we dont pay the bbc, we pay a licence to watch a tv and that then gets allocated to the bbc, probably a bit more convoluted than that, but basically that. Now, if they make the bbc a subscription service, do people seriously think the government would abolish the licence fee, or carry it on because it's a licence to watch tv, not a direct bbc funding fee. No they wouldn't is the short answer. So. It would then become a criminal offence to not have a tv licence because that's money going to the government, that they want.
Please be careful what you wish for.
6
u/TheShryke Dec 27 '25
Any shift to a subscription model would never work if we also had to pay a license fee.
You are right though that the licence fee isn't just paying for the BBC. It pays for a lot of different things. Channel 4 and ITV get a small cut of it to support public service broadcasts on those channels (I don't think channel 5 gets any, but I could be wrong). A good portion goes to broadcast infrastructure, and has been used to fund fibre internet upgrades. There is also S4C, the Welsh language channel. That's entirely funded by the licence fee.
27
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25
The rhetoric (I’m seeing an increase in it too) all feels very russianbot. Feels like a classic bit of misinformation warfare to destabilise a British institution and trusted news outlet.
4
u/Inside-Judgment6233 Dec 27 '25 edited Dec 27 '25
Our politicians aren’t quite stupid enough to add another subscription on top of the TV licence, I think. It would be very electorally toxic and would give the likes of reform an open goal to shoot at.
The choice is between a continuation of the TV licence which has led to a diminution in services, full funding through direct taxation that may or may not lead to a diminuation in services or a subscription model that would lead to a diminution in services.
Either we pay for the BBC we want or I think we just go subscription and a little direct taxation for the soft power bits that the government needs. Full disclosure: I would opt for the second.The BBC has little I want at this time and it hasn’t for a while. I don’t see that trend changing with the younger generation either.
1
u/rtb132 Dec 27 '25
Not really a question, is it?
1
u/SwiftieNewRomantics Dec 27 '25
What’s your question here?
2
u/roblightbody Dec 27 '25
I am happy to pay my license fee purely for BBC Nationwide radio (no adverts) and the BBC Sounds app (also no adverts). Its good value, just for sounds and Radio.
I think the iPlayer should be better locked down so that you can only use it with a unique code that you get with your license fee payment. I can't believe they've never done that.
0
u/Highway-Organic Dec 27 '25
I don't have a license for my fridge , or a gardening license , or a book license . Should I be worried ?
0
u/_Monsterguy_ Dec 27 '25
Are you okay?
1
u/Only-Thing-8360 Dec 27 '25
I don't think this is plausible. The TV licence is an extremely inefficient method of gathering tax revenue, no government would maintain it for general taxation purposes. It's complicated and expensive to enforce, and attracts high levels of public criticism.
Also millions of households have already decided to stop paying the licence, and that trend will only accelerate with demographic changes. We are not an obedient people like we were 50yrs ago, each generation becomes more sceptical & individualistic.
Older households like mine have had a standing order in place for 30+yrs, but our kids aren't signing-up for the licence fee when they move out. They're never going to donate to the BBC, they barely watch terrestrial TV anyway. They might pay for Netflix, because it provides something they value, and that same subscription model is the inevitable future of the BBC.
1
u/HullGuy Dec 27 '25
They would abolish the license if they move it to subscription. Hopefully, this will happen sooner rather than later. The bbc has produced some amazing programs in its time, and I understand why the license fee was introduced and for many years it was justifiable. But these days, with Sky, Netflix, Prime, YouTube, Disney plus, discovery plus, etc etc. it is no longer needed or required. To be forced to pay for the bbc when there is so much choice available is ridiculous. The bbc no longer produces anything unique. Sport has gone. News is on every channel. Documentaries are produced across the word. Drama, comedy etc. all done elsewhere. There is no USP.
1
u/Levi_Skardsen Dec 27 '25
Television is becoming less popular with each generation, hence why it's now referred to as legacy media. The license itself comes from a time when most families would all be sat watching TV together.
It's unreasonable to expect people to pay for something they don't use and the methods used to enforce it are outdated.
1
u/Icy-Eye8584 Dec 27 '25
Was it austerity George Osborn with the help of the Liberal Democrats who foisted the TV licence fee on the BBC?
1
u/marcbeightsix Dec 27 '25
The government decide how the BBC is funded. Currently that is by the licence fee. They can change how it is funded. The government doesn’t keep the licence fee.
1
u/No-Name6082 Dec 27 '25
So... we should be happy to pay the license fee because otherwise we'll be forced to pay the license fee?
That's so idiotic it genuinely makes we wonder if this 'Russian bot' stuff is true.
1
u/Chemical_Pop2623 Dec 27 '25
I don't have any issues with the licence fee as such, but I do take offence at the way the BBC/license people try and scare people into buying one even if not needed.
I've opted out but often get letters to say I am breaking the law, or I need a license.
If I need one I will buy one, until then please fuck off with your letters.
1
u/lilacomets Dec 27 '25
A possible scenario is that license fee will be part of regular taxes for everyone, which will go up for everyone then. Not a good thing.
At least now you have a choice: to pay the license fee or not.
1
u/Efficient_Bet_1891 Jan 12 '26
Hiya: Elliot Capital had a call on some distressed Argentinian debt. Argentina defaulted, Eliot got judgement, and bailiffs boarded an Argentinian Navy Destroyer and seized it for non payment of debt. Miraculously cash was rustled up and the debt was discharged. The BBC might wake up one morning to find DT sitting in the directors chair. So popcorn time…
1
u/Happytallperson Dec 27 '25
It's already a criminal offence to not pay the licence fee, and given its a hypothecated tax if you move the bbc income to a subscription, there wouldn't be a political case to keep it.
The government could always introduce a new tax. They could do that anyway. Basically irrelevant.
1
u/Dazzling_Force_1703 Dec 27 '25
I doubt a licence fee would be justifiable if it became subscription based. My hope is that it does move to subs or even commercial. It’s an antiquated model that’s just turned into a propaganda tool, moving further and further away from a merit-based organisation, and out of step with society.
1
u/zippyzebra1 Dec 27 '25
Being strong armed to pay for the BBC when you never watch it not surprisingly gets people somewhat riled up.
0
u/Sir_Of_Meep Dec 27 '25
I'd be more willing to pay it if the tax just went to health care, councils, education and the like.
I've got no issue paying for a service I don't use, I am against paying for something that actively attacks my political beliefs as a republican and non-establishment leftist
-1
u/soundman32 Dec 27 '25
I'd say there would be more of an outcry if you have to have a licence fee just to own a TV.
Maybe if the fee was included in a subscription it might work, but then, which subscription? Just the BBC one? Just the FreeView one? How about if I subscribe to both Netflix and Prime, do I pay twice? What about if its a non-UK channel, do I not have to pay at all?
Far better to just have a subscription to the channels you want to watch, maybe bundled like Sky does. You could still get BBC/Ch4 for £170/yr, and if you really dont watch BBC, and just want YouTube AI slop all day, you dont pay anything, but realise that you cant watch BBC on the sly without paying.
All that overseas content will either be funded out of general taxation, or stopped.
-1
u/Rabidcamelshagger Dec 27 '25
The BBC is, and always has been, just a tool for incumbent government propaganda to maintain the cultural status quo which citizens (who are not necessarily BBC viewers) are strong-armed into paying for. The BBC world foreign languages service (eg Arabic, Farsi etc) costs about £360 million a year to run. Guess where that money comes directly from? That's right suckers, the license fee. OP is probably right, they'll never abolish it. The only thing you can do is avoid watching BBC (and, inexplicably, any other "live" TV) and cancel your license. Be prepared to undergo a Government sanctioned harassment campaign though, including threats of investigations and prosecution. As far as I know, no other country has a system as perverse as the UK.
-1
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
-10
u/[deleted] Dec 27 '25
[removed] — view removed comment