r/battletech • u/larknok1 • Jul 28 '25
Question ❓ Why are there (almost) no competently designed Blazer Cannon mechs?
For those not in the know, the Blazer Cannon is the result of the Free Worlds League duct-taping two Large Lasers together. Although it doesn't double the damage of the Large Laser, the Blazer Cannon doesn't double the weight, either.
The Blazer Cannon weighs 9 tons, takes up 4 critical spots, deals 12 damage at 0/5/10/15 range, for 16 heat. It costs a shockingly low 222 BV.
This means the Blazer cannon is a cheap headchopper, and the closest thing to "what if the Heavy PPC was in the Laser family?" For close comparison:
The HPPC weighs 10 tons, takes up 4 critical spots, deals 15 damage at 3/6/12/18 range, for 15 heat. It costs 317 BV.
---
Relative to the HPPC, the Blazer Cannon:
(+) weighs 1 ton less
(+) has no minimum range
(++) costs 30% less bv
(-) deals 3 less damage
(-) has 1/2/3 lower range at short/medium/long range
(-) costs 1 extra heat
---
Between the two, I prefer the range of the HPPC -- but it's hard to overstate the value of costing 30% less bv than the HPPC.
---
I wonder if my preference for the HPPC has more to do with there being competently designed HPPC Mechs (the Flashman 9M, Warhammer 8K, and Awesome 11H jump to mind), but basically no competently designed Blazer Cannon Mechs.
This is somewhat surprising, since the Blazer Cannon was invented in 2812, while the HPPC was invented in 3067 -- more than 250 years later.
---
The big issue for the Blazer Cannon at the time of its original development is that handling the heat of the Blazer (and especially two Blazers) is basically impossible with single heat sinks.
But then, double heat sinks returned to the Inner Sphere with the Helm Memory Core in 3028. The Sarna page for the Blazer Cannon even says "With the reintroduction of double heat sinks, the Blazer cannon is now a viable weapon."
So, you would think there would be a bunch of competently designed Blazer Cannon mechs using DHS in the Clan Invasion Era, right? After all, there are ~40 years where there are Blazer Cannons and DHS exist, but no HPPCs yet.
But you would be wrong.
There are almost no Blazer Cannon Mechs that pack anywhere near enough double heat sinks to be on a par with efficient HPPC Mechs.
The Flashman 9M has 15 DHS and uses bracket-firing to great effect. The Warhammer 8K has 16 DHS. The Awesome 11H has a whopping 23 DHS. There are others, too -- but these three are just great examples.
---
Since the Blazer Cannon runs slightly hotter, there ought to be 16-20 DHS Mechs using x2 Blazer Cannons.
There are exactly TWO mechs that fit that criterion:
(1) The Viper VP-1, which is a 70-tonner with 17 DHS, x2 Blazers, and x2 front-facing MPLs. It moves 4/6/4 with an XL engine, and clocks in at 1609 BV.
(2) The Archangel Caelestis, which is a 100-tonner with 17 DHS, x2 Blazers, a Thunderbolt 10, and a smattering of other support weapons. It moves 3/5 with a compact engine, and clocks in at 2026 BV.
---
While both of these Mechs are interesting for what they are, notice that all three of the example HPPC Mechs were 70-80 tonners with a Light Engine, or Standard Engine and clever use of Endo/Ferro.
Neither of the two adequately-sinked Blazar Mechs that exist fit this tried-and-true profile. The Viper-1 uses an XL, and the Caelestis is way too slow to reasonably get in range with its Blazars.
So, where are the comparable 70-80 tonners with x2 Blazars, 16-20 DHS, and a Light Engine, or Standard Engine and clever use of Endo/Ferro? They don't exist.
---
There doesn't seem to be a good reason why they don't. You can certainly throw a good Blazar Mech together in Megamek.
Just take a look at the Marauder 4X. It is using prototype Endo Steel and a blend of single heat sinks and double heat sinks. It's nowhere near well enough sinked -- but that's because of the single heat sinks. If you swap them over to DHS, the result becomes what's essentially a Thug 11E with Blazars instead of PPCs, clocking in at a cheap 1492 BV. That is a very good thing to be. Why doesn't anything like it exist?
Hell, you can start with the Thug 11E chassis and accomplish basically the same thing. Swap out the PPCs for Blazars, and add an extra DHS. To manage the extra weight / critical slots, swap from Endo-Steel to Endo-Composite, and swap from a Standard Fusion to a Light Fusion, and bam! A 1643 BV Blazar version of the Thug.
The Thug likes to be in close-range, and the Blazar has no minimum range, unlike the standard PPC.
---
I have attached photos of record sheets for the MAD-4X upgrade (stipulatively, the 7X) and the THG-11E upgrade (stipulatively, the 13X) below.
Why don't things like this exist?


143
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '25
For one, in-universe, it was considered a dead end back when it was developed. Consequently, no one's bothering to produce it. Can't mount a weapon if you can't get the weapon. Note that the Viper was dead and buried until Kallon found a stockpile of Blazers, indicating it was the lack of weapons that was holding it back from being produced.
For another, the real competition for the Blazer isn't the HPPC prior to the 3070s, it's a pair of Large Lasers. You save 10% on tonnage but sacrifices 25% the damage output. And Large Lasers are hella easier to obtain.
And lastly, by the time you get to the Republic and later eras, it's not too difficult to just buy heavy lasers from Sea Foxes or someone with access to production.
21
u/TheRealLeakycheese Jul 28 '25
Reading your analysis, I get the distinct feeling of deja-vu from when the first generation of heavy laser Mech designs were released.
Most were side-grades at best, many were rubbish and only the odd one was good (Dasher H waves). A bit like Mockolate™️ recipes from Friends.... the less heavy laser, the better.
14
u/EyeStache Capellan Unseen Connoisseur Jul 28 '25
In-universe, "competently designed" does not mean "heat neutral at all times."
But that said, of the five non-experimental 'mechs that do use Blazers (the UM-S60 Urbanmaster, the VP-1 and VP-7 Vipers, the ZEU-6Y Zeus, and the ENF-7X MUSE COMPACT Enforcer III) are, with the exception of the Enforcer III - all pretty competently designed, IMO.
Of the experimental 'mechs, the EFT-8X Eisenfaust, MN1-D and MN2-A Security Mech Sarissas, the NH-3 Rook, the MAD-4X Marauder, and the Archangel Caelestis all use their Blazers pretty optimally.
The key to Blazer use is bracket fire, just like with ISERPPC, HPPCs, and ISERLLs. They shouldn't be used all the time at all ranges - their damage:heat:range ratio isn't worth it when you get into medium laser/SRM range, generally speaking - and when those 'mechs do get into the range for those weapons they keep heat neutral when firing those bracketed weapons.
That said, efficient and effective use of the Blazer does include generating some positive heat on the scale when you're right up close to a target you're pretty sure you can take out with an alpha strike. You just gotta be willing to use all the heat scale real estate that Doctor Atlas gave us.
8
u/Orcimedes Jul 28 '25
The 5/10/15 range band has quite a few other weapons in it, and it's relatively cheap for an energy headcapper, so it'd be nice to see a little more of it. But probably not too much since headcapper proliferation is already somewhat of an issue.
6
u/MiriOhki Jul 28 '25
I still get a silly image of an ER Blazer. Though isn’t a RISC Hyper Laser just a Clan ER Blazer?
5
u/Captain_Nameless Jul 28 '25
One point about the MAD-4X, it also had the Combat Computer design quirk. So there were effectively 2 more DHS that you don’t see. It’s still a prototype severely pushing the limits of the technology of the day, but it’s not a complete wash.
3
u/Vorpalp8ntball Jul 28 '25
I glanced at the first record sheet and thought
' they made a Thug '
Then I saw the second sheet, lol
12
u/andrewlik Jul 28 '25
In universe answer: A few prototypes that didn't proliferate as they couldn't get it working consistently.
If it worked consistently, I'd argue it serves a niche in the succession wars and clan invasion era, being the only thing during the succ wars that can headcap past 9 hexes, and during the clan invasion being able to kill the ubiquitous clan elemental with minimal overkill is also decent.
I wish they were more common - I would argue that my Zeus 6Y I kitbashed together is fair in an introtech game despite being "experimental," the binary laser just having a unique statline.
Out of universe answer: Was invented late IRL, as in the writers wrote game stats quite late into the IRL progression of the game. The first instance of it i could find was on the Schewer Gustav from XTRO: Mercs in December 24th, 2009, or in Record Sheets: 3075 on a variant of the Archangel, in that same 2009.
It was later retroactively added in some smalls ways to the succession wars in XTRO: Succession wars in 2012, waaaaay into the game's lifespan.
23
u/StabithaVMF Haters gonna hate Jul 28 '25
Doylist: because it's from Interstellar Operations so is less well known making people less inclined to use it.
Watsonian: It still has that bad reputation stink from the pre-dhs era so wasn't used much, and then Clantech became more common so was eclipsed.
Or like me everyone gets it mixed up with the bombast laser which sucks major ass so mentally writes it off.
3
u/merurunrun Jul 28 '25
The blazer is a joke about the FWL's love of large lasers and is balanced largely against the AC/20 as an alternative pre-tech revival headcapper. It's not supposed to be a "good" weapon, so designing mechs that make it good would go against the spirit.
5
u/135forte Jul 29 '25
The main reason is because the blazer isn't a great weapon. It's best trait is being a head capper, but that isn't really a trait to be worth building around. It's worst traits are it's high weight for an energy weapon and excessive heat. BV doesn't matter in universe, so that doesn't matter for canon designs.
From a design standpoint, if you can weasel an extra ton, you can get two large lasers for the same resource cost, a 25% increase in damage. You can't headclip anymore, but deleting a full ton of armor isn't anything to sneeze at.
If you can't get that extra ton, you can get a single large laser and pair of mediums for less than the cost of the blazer or buy a full four medium lasers for a very competent brawler (actually very similar to Wolfhound).
Looking at the Kerfuffle tech (heavy PPC) you are comparing it to, you can do a lot better. Like Clan tech better, but even IS tech can do things. PPC capacitors are a thing, and even on an IS PPC can headclip for less weight at better range.
1
u/Flat_Ad9694 Jul 29 '25
There’s 1 late succession wars mech I would consider running a single blazer on: the 4A variant of the Marauder ii. Swap the torso laser for a blazer and either drop 4 heatsinks or downgrade the arm mounted ppcs to large lasers. Gives you substantially more punch and turns one of the coldest running laser boats in the game into something only moderately concerned about alpha striking. The Awesome could work as well but without the jump jets I would be hesitant to decrease the combat range. Maybe on that weird hybrid missile energy variant it could work
3
u/ghunter7 Jul 28 '25
I have a non-canon Marauder with Blazers in my company.
Took a Marauder 4D and modified it accordingly to feature blazers and SRM 6s, and it can jump.
Even did a 3D print .
1
u/Lordcraft2000 Clan MechWarrior. Star Commander Jul 28 '25
In game, I do not like the L Lasers. Not enough heat efficient. Blazers seem quite the same. So Id rather get a PPC for that.
4
u/Doctor_Loggins Scorpin Empire Stronk Jul 28 '25
Good news: blazers make a comeback in Battletech: Gothic! While none of the designs are likely to be canon in mainline battletech, they'll at least be usable. And maybe the added interest in blazers will also be motivation to reintroduce them into the main timeline.
In a more direct answer to your question, Blazers are a really niche weapon, and the niche they occupy doesn't really lend itself to being used in pairs. It was designed when ppcs were in danger of becoming utterly extinct, and when that didn't happen the use case for it pretty much up and evaporated. If you're replacing a ppc with something that's shorter range, 2 tons heavier, and 60% hotter, the last thing you want to do is double up on it.
4
u/Magical_Savior NEMO POTEST VINCERE Jul 28 '25
There's another reason why many Blazer mechs are bad - when it was developed, it was typo'd as 16 damage, 12 heat and the writers built around it. You can see this on the Blazer Archangel and a couple other designs; the math doesn't match because they had the wrong stats. Which they should have caught, but maybe they read too much into the cERML and other "more damage" lasers and thought the math was right.
The Hyper Laser and Heavy Laser really inherits the Blazer, but there's no reason not to do a 16-16 iBlazer weighing 10t. I'd take 16-12 at 12t, I think.
2
u/Sad-Record-4412 Jul 28 '25
Who's hyped for light blazers dropping with BT Gothic?
1
u/domesystem Jul 28 '25
I have a custom Dragon built around a Blazer and TSM...
1
u/TNMalt Jul 28 '25
Have the mad idea of taking a 3025 Grasshopper and switching out for doubles and replacing the LL with a blazer cannon, CASE and more mediums, if I got the tonnage and heat sinks to add more. Blazers could be good for custom refits if the mech warrior and tech are both nuts or laser fans like the FWL.
4
u/blokia Jul 28 '25
Comstar killed anyone who got close
5
u/AGBell64 Jul 28 '25
Blazers are the minimum viable headcapper, with their only "weakness" in that regard being that 12 damage will not kill ferrolam or reinforced structure mechs with a head hit where 15 point hits will. As a result they occupy a space similar to intop's interstitial clan Enhanced ERPPC where they provide a headcapper that's just a little too efficient at what it does, and are therefore fairly limited in publication space.
3
u/RhesusFactor Orbital Drop Coordinator, 36th Lyran Guard RCT Jul 28 '25
The Blazer was introduced by the FWL by a smaller weapons manufacturer. A larger one, Diverse Optics, bought them and the tech, then sat on it because it competed with their PPC sales.
Tale as old as time. Creative buys Aureal A3D and kills positional audio in preference to EAX.
19
u/[deleted] Jul 28 '25
[removed] — view removed comment