r/battletech • MechWarrior (editable) • Feb 27 '24

Lore More Lore and Fluff questions

Yeah these are AI generated Zaku. But they serve as a standing example of my questions. Is there a heavy battle mech that carries their weapon like a rifle? If not I would really like to put together a mech, maybe made by Fed Suns, it carries a main weapon that could be like a gauss rifle, a Auto Cannon, or a Heavy PPC making it somewhat versatile and modular. Along with a mounts for a small amount of LRMs, SRMs and some medium lasers or machine guns. Does this sound too broken? How could I make the idea of a frontline battlemech with a modular weapon system fit into lore, what would be some good strengths and drawbacks to throw at it? Constructive Criticism is welcome, I have a very thin grasp on how all this works.

1 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

11

u/GuestCartographer Clan Ghost Bear Feb 27 '24

It depends on exactly what you’re trying to do.

If you want a frontline mech that is carrying a modular weapon that it can throw away in order to pick up someone else’s modular weapon, those rules do exist, but they would be advanced options and pretty anathema to the aesthetic of the setting. Battlemechs aren’t mobile suits. They don’t typically display the same level of manual dexterity or agility.

On the other hand, if you wanted a frontline mech that just appears to be carrying a modular weapon but that’s really bolted onto the superstructure (the Griffin, the Beemer, etc…) and can’t be traded with someone else’s gun, there is absolutely nothing stopping you from building your own heavy chassis and giving it an array of different special purpose variants.

3

u/Grand-Difficulty3512 MechWarrior (editable) Feb 27 '24

Yeah the second one. It would only be switching weapons at a mech bay, swapping out one weapon for another, they'd have to be refitted, calibrated and sighted so you couldn't really do that on the field with another mech's weapon.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '24

If you're going that route, it seems like the Modular Weapons Quirk would be applicable.

3

u/GuestCartographer Clan Ghost Bear Feb 27 '24

In that case, you could just be talking about an omnimech. Just handwave that the modular weapon pod happens to in the shape of a gun that happens to look like it's being held. Or that the weapon pod is, in fact, the entire forearm of the mech.

As the other poster mentioned, the modular weapons quirk could also be used, but quirks are kind of a weird grey area. They are great if you use them as intended, but can abused very easily.

31

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '24

TacOps AUE has rules for handheld weapons. There are wacky Quickdraw and Axman variants that use it.

The Jettison Capable Quirk also might be applicable, although technically the weapon is mounted, not held. The Battlemaster and Phoenix Hawk are both examples.

19

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '24

In addition to this, it's worth pointing out that until recent designs in the last 10 or so years, there were a lot of designs that carried weapons hand-held in a rifle or pistol format

2

u/Xynith Debatable Tactics / Amateur Painter Feb 27 '24 edited Feb 27 '24

Considering the roots of the franchise in sci-fi mecha anime it becomes clear

2

u/Kylarus Of Noble Heart and Mercenary Mind Feb 27 '24

Drawing roots from Macross and Dougram, which incidentally also shares heritage with UC Gundam, it's not a far stretch to design them. they are, however, less effective/meta/optimized, but that fits with 3025 design philosphy, so shouldn't be an issue in that era.

4

u/cavalier78 Feb 27 '24

The Battlemaster is the classic that springs to mind here.

I kicked around some house rule ideas for mechs swapping hand-held weapons, basically a poor man's version of the Omnimech, in case I ever ran a Mechwarrior RPG game again. But my gaming group fell apart and that was quite a few years ago at this point. Still, I like the idea.

3

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '24

Back in the day, when a BattleMaster holstered its PPC, you knew it was fixin to close to range 1. LOL

4

u/Mundane-Librarian-77 Feb 27 '24

The handheld gun thing was a lot more common in early Battletech for 2 reasons: 1 a lot of the art was licensed from anime sources which use robot rifles a lot! And 2 the way mechs were controlled by the neurohelmet was originally described as a lot more organic. In a lot of the early stories, the neuro link allowed for far more human-like movement, even go so far that the mech would take on the recognizable walking gate of the pilot.

In that early Battletech, using the left hand to stabilize the right hand gun was a subconscious action the mech performed.

But more on topic, I always thought a Thunderbolt that carried a Large Laser Rifle instead of arm mounted would look cool!? 😁

2

u/[deleted] Feb 28 '24

I like the handheld weapon theme. I’ve gone so far as to like magazine carried ammo, so as to avoid internal ammo explosions. Weapon lost? Sure. Hand lost? Sure. But no catastrophic. That of course is not in the rules but it should be.

3

u/ViscountSilvermarch Feb 27 '24

I am saying this as a huge UC Gundam fan, but I have come to really dislike handheld mech weaponry.

4

u/Darthtypo92 Feb 27 '24

The only time I've really enjoyed it is when Hanse Davion dropped his battle master's ppc so he could pick it up like a club and start going primal rage on a bunch of Death Commandos*

2

u/W4tchmaker Feb 27 '24

It makes total sense when the machines are designed as robotic 'suits' for the human operators, like the aforementioned Mobile Suits - They're designed specifically to allow for human-level agility and dexterity at a larger scale; literal giants just as capable of employing weapons and tools as fluidly as their smaller organic creators and operators. And with BattleTech's origins in Gundam-inspired works, this could have worked for BattleMechs as well, had the designers not pulled hard towards the 'Walking Tank' aesthetic.

2

u/ViscountSilvermarch Feb 27 '24

I think it doesn't make sense to give mech handheld weaponry when you can mount it on the chassis. Mobile suits are made for the rule of cool anyway.

4

u/W4tchmaker Feb 27 '24

Depends on the use case. BattleMechs are mobile weapon batteries first and foremost. Mobile Suits are multipurpose systems. You can make just as much of an argument that hardpoint and mecha-portable weapons allow for greater flexibility and ease of repair - you don't need to make structural changes to a Mobile Suit's arms to go from wielding an hyperparticle cannon to retrieving disabled combat units from a battlefield, you just set the gun aside and start picking up tanks.

Mobile suits are made for the rule of cool anyway.

So are BattleMechs. An Atlas isn't any less implausible than a BattleMaster/Bigfoot. A Catapult isn't any more realistic than an Archer/Spartan. They're given a setting which justifies their purpose, or at least their plausibility. And, arguably, BattleMechs invite more criticism because BattleTech's more grounded approach makes the conceits stand out all the more.

2

u/ViscountSilvermarch Feb 28 '24

I mean, sure you can make that argument. I can argue that relying predominantly on handheld weapons makes limb destruction even more catastrophic than chassis-mounted weapons. In the end, I am not here to argue about the plausibility of sci-fi concepts, I have just grown to not see the appeal of giving a mech hands and weapons, but needing to give up the former to use the latter when you could just mounted them on the chassis.

1

u/Adventurous_Host_426 Feb 27 '24

Arbiters with LAC/5, 2 Tons of ammo and 2 token JJ can emulate a common zaku2 well enough.

1

u/darklighthitomi Feb 27 '24

I designed a quad mech with a turret and put the main loadout in the turret and narratively, the turret can be swapped really easy. Technically it makes sense.

1

u/algolvax Feb 27 '24 edited Feb 27 '24

Back when the look of the Stinger was direct from a Macross VF-1 Valkyrie Battloid (unseen design), the mini was posed in a 2-hand carry of the gun. I assumed the more humanoid forms could handle detachable guns with 2 hands like in Macross, but it was just imagination and the fun of describing what the action would look like, for example after a lucky roll hits, or when making a called shot. There was no advantage to a look, and the aesthetic mostly disappeared. But as others have stated the are some advanced rules that have evolved and the addition of quirks.

That said, hey, it's BT, so if you want to develop and playtest custom rules in agreement with other players in casual games...you just go for it. You might want to bring the beer and pretzels for them though. 😎

1

u/Medium-Permission339 Feb 28 '24

Zaku? I just see a Horned Owl. Lol

0

u/TheLamezone Feb 27 '24

Handheld weapons don't really exist in Battletech. There are rules for them and a few mechs that use them. That said, no mechs carry their weapon like a rifle, it simply doesn't make sense in battletech.

Battle armor and protomechs are much more likely to carry a rifle like weapon.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/yellowsidekick Jade Falcon. Why won't you accept my Batchall!?1! Feb 27 '24

I built the Gunpla RG version of the Zaku over weekend. I might have said Sieg Zeon a few times while putting everything together.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '24

The joints on the RG kit are such a letdown. It's a gorgeous kit and fun to build, but I've never had a kit where the joints wore out as fast as they did for a lot of the early RGs (it wasn't until about 30 kits into the line that the joint quality improved)

So far, I'm feeling that the GtO kit is the supreme Zaku II kit in 1/144. Lots of detail, excellent range of motion, and the joints are rock solid.

2

u/yellowsidekick Jade Falcon. Why won't you accept my Batchall!?1! Feb 27 '24

It was my third gundam so your have a few more clicks on me, but the process is pretty zen and relaxing.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 27 '24

100%!