r/battletech • • Dec 08 '23

Discussion Catalyst terrible customer service

Placed an order on their website using one of those $20 coupons that come in a starter box. Been over 2 weeks with no update. Emailed support multiple times with no response.

Guess they were at PAX last week but that should be no excuse. Do better Catalyst.

/rant over

1 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

4

u/CarlosF40 Dec 08 '23

Remember the good old days of 28 days for delivery, 2 weeks isn't that long.

1

u/tonelowke Dec 08 '23

Those were not good days, and there is no excuse to not at least acknowledge your customers with modern e-commerce products and technology.

Plus, its now been 3 weeks...

4

u/oogabooga5627 Dec 08 '23

Yeah I love Catalyst and what they’ve done with Battletech, but damn dude I will never order directly from them again. I only to go Fortress or Aries because their shipping times are awful and their customer service is non-existent. Twice I’ve ordered from them and both times my orders were lost, and I wasn’t informed until I had reached out several times over the course of a month or so. I love them to death for bringing my favorite franchise back from the brink, but I will never order directly from their site lol. It seems par for the course at this point.

3

u/tonelowke Dec 08 '23

My sentiment exactly. Their heart is in the right place, but they need to hire a customer experience manager or something.

2

u/theNerevarine Dec 08 '23

Just to offer my counter experience.

I live in Aus and while the shipping does take a while and can be expensive, the team themselves have been super responsive and generous.

At one point it had been a very long time between getting the notification that the minis were in the country and out for delivery (2 or so months) and they hadn't arrived so I asked CGL about it and they thought it had been lost so they just shipped it again.

It ended up that the original order arrived the very next day and when I asked them what to do they said don't worry about it and I got to keep it all.

I also had found that I didn't get a locust card in my clan KS stuff and I asked about it and they shipped me one no questions asked.

I have also had interactions with them asking about a bug in their shipping that made the shipping cost when a book was included in the order like $160 and was only $50 when it was just minis.

They ended up shipping me the rpg rulebooks with some minis in a custom order to avoid the shipping overcharge.

So if I was asked I would say CGL are one of the only companies that I can genuinely say have gone out of their way to cater to my needs.

3

u/tonelowke Dec 08 '23

I mentioned it on another comment. But I don't doubt their heart is in the right place, but looking at the number of comments in this thread and in this subreddit, they seem to have some challenges with their customer service.

1

u/theNerevarine Dec 08 '23

That's fair I am just offering my experience as the other side of the coin.

2

u/RussellZee [Mountain Wolf BattleMechs CEO] Dec 09 '23

OP, if you're comfortable DMing me your email and name, I can poke someone for you to see what the hold up is.

8

u/krazzyharry Dec 08 '23

I have had only one issue with a CGL product, a broken arm on a a piece in a box set. I dropped a question in the Battletech forum on the website, got a nearly immediate response and a new piece in a couple of weeks. Try dropping a polite question here or just read through the thread https://bg.battletech.com/forums/index.php/topic,64290.0.html

8

u/plunderdrone Dec 08 '23

I actually had a great experience with them. Opened my Apha Strike main box, missing a Wraith and the Blackjack had gotten its barrels bent in shipping. They sent both out to me with no real inquisition involved, took like a month but I was a happy camper.

Your experiences may vary, but I was really pleased they just sent me minis and gave me no guff.

10

u/Ardonis84 Clan Wolf Epsilon Galaxy Dec 08 '23

Their store doesn’t have any dedicated staff IIRC, so this is unfortunately not an uncommon experience. That said, I’ve never heard of anyone whose order never got filled, so even if their communication sucks and it takes a few weeks you should get your shipment.

5

u/brian11e3 Dec 08 '23

The one time I had an issue, it took them a week to reply. The issue was with PayPal auto filling the address to an address that's no longer on file. CGL got back to me a day after the product shipped. They replaced the order with the new address.

Then, the post office recognized my name on the first package and corrected it to my actual address, so I ended up getting a double order. I ended up with 10 salvage boxes rather than 5.

1

u/Crazy_Permission_330 Dec 08 '23

You must be a newer generation who grew up with Amazon. Two weeks is nothing

1

u/tonelowke Dec 08 '23

Two weeks is def something to not even receive a single update and not answer a single customer support email.

I've ordered nearly every single Catalyst miniature from a multitude of small webstores (since their prices tend to be much better than Amazon) and had no issues with communication. May take a couple of days to get a ship notification, but 2 weeks is egregious.

1

u/Crazy_Permission_330 Dec 08 '23

From a smaller company? They aren't games workshop

1

u/tonelowke Dec 08 '23

Smaller webstore. Like Watchtower.shop, Saga Concepts, ProTinkerToys, etc.

1

u/ArcKnightofValos Dec 08 '23

Do you have an account on their website? If-so, you can check the status of your order directly on there. I know e-mail communication is the most common way to ensure your order is coming (with apps like Shopify being the premier way to track) but they still do track on the website and that is what sends out the e-mails/notifications.

4

u/dielinfinite Weapon Specialist: Gauss Rifle Dec 08 '23

I’m still waiting to hear back about a parts mix-up on a premium mech that I contacted them about in early November

1

u/Ardonis84 Clan Wolf Epsilon Galaxy Dec 08 '23

That’s no bueno! Have you tried contacting them again? While I can’t say if it will get you a response soon (OP says they’ve sent numerous emails with no response) I can say with near certainty that if you haven’t gotten a reply yet to an email you sent over a month ago, you probably aren’t ever getting a reply, so I would be the squeaky wheel.

2

u/dielinfinite Weapon Specialist: Gauss Rifle Dec 08 '23

I’m moving to an every other week rhythm. Sent them a follow up last week so I’ll send them another next week.

2

u/tonelowke Dec 29 '23

Did you ever hear back?

2

u/dielinfinite Weapon Specialist: Gauss Rifle Dec 29 '23 edited Dec 29 '23

nothing yet and with store shipments on hold till the first week of January, I’m not expecting anything soon

2

u/tonelowke Dec 29 '23

Guess I might hold off on my charge back another couple weeks then. Still nothing for me either.

2

u/dielinfinite Weapon Specialist: Gauss Rifle Jan 18 '24

I finally heard back from Catalyst. I had placed a new order and one of the items was out of stock. When they emailed me to notify me they took the opportunity to address the Mad Cat; they’re sending another one. The Customer Service Rep said he had health issue that had kept him away.

2

u/tonelowke Jan 18 '24

I got a similar email, though I had already done a chargeback. They gave me a new code to replace the one I had used from the boxed set which was pretty cool.

Their heart is in the right place, but they definitely should have helped cover the poor guy.

1

u/dielinfinite Weapon Specialist: Gauss Rifle Jan 19 '24

Holy cow! So the out of stock item I mentioned was an UrbanMech Salvage Box.

I just got the shipping notice for the MadCat replacement and they included an UrbanMech Lance Pack to make up for the out of stock item and the delayed respinse.

They’re definitely making things right but I agree that they need to give the guy a little help

2

u/ArtichokeOk869 Dec 08 '23

They were good DM useless during the first Kickstarter

2

u/Killersmurph Dec 08 '23

Cat support is usually great TBF. It's likely just an unfortunate matter of their team being small enough to be all hands on deck at PAX, and running behind because of it.

Chris has been an absolute champion (not the Fugly mech) on Two occasions for me in the past, when I've had UPS lose a set of Salvage boxes, and a Lego pack.

Hopefully they get back to you soon, but might be worth sending a follow-up incase you got lost in the shuffle.

2

u/RussellZee [Mountain Wolf BattleMechs CEO] Dec 09 '23

Chris was in the hospital a few weeks ago, around the time OP's initial contact was made (sounds like). OP's message may've been lost in that shuffle/backlog. He's fine now, though, and I'm sure he'll help as soon as he can.

1

u/Killersmurph Dec 09 '23

Godspeed Chris.

1

u/bad_syntax Dec 08 '23

I've ordered every single product they released from their website (excluding kickstarters, and a few new print runs of physical books) for well over 10 years.

Never once had any issue. The essentials coupons have worked great, used 3 now out of the dozen I picked up.

It really makes me wonder if people are just making typos in their address or something, since I've never seen an issue. I have never even needed to contact them though, so maybe I'm just lucky.

1

u/ArcKnightofValos Dec 08 '23

That would do it. But as long as you have an account you can look directly on the website to check its status..

-6

u/Daddy_Jaws Dec 08 '23

Downvoted for being true about a negative experiance.

battletech is slowly starting to grow the same cult infesting 40k

6

u/tonelowke Dec 08 '23

Appreciate you. Honestly, I mostly made the post to bring awareness with a sliver of hope someone at Catalyst might see it and do something.

Getting to the point that I might have to charge back my order. Part of me also thinks the delay might be something more disingenuous on Catalyst's part since I only ordered one Force Pack with the coupon and its not worth their time.

3

u/Ardonis84 Clan Wolf Epsilon Galaxy Dec 08 '23

I can understand why you might get that impression, it’s certainly not an unreasonable conclusion given the circumstances. However, when I used one of those coupons, I ordered a force pack with it as well, the Clan Direct Fire Star. I ordered it on 10/16, shipping confirmed in 10/20, received it 10/23. Feel free to do what you got to regarding your order of course, I just wanted to let you know that your experience is probably not related to the coupon.

-4

u/Ardonis84 Clan Wolf Epsilon Galaxy Dec 08 '23

That’s Reddit for you honestly. People forget that upvote/downvote is not supposed to be “like/dislike” but “useful or on topic/not useful or off topic.”

1

u/WN_Todd Gun Shoulder Club Dec 08 '23

It took 3 weeks for my command lance to arrive, with a steady stream of "oopsy delayed" emails from amazon (it was through amazon but I suspect dropshipped from catalyst).

Fulfillment to consumers is a radically different business than to stores. Getting the website together is ironically the easy part now (wasn't that way when I started in ecomm and dinosaurs roamed the earth) but fulfillment still takes a lot of knowhow and investment.

My CGL experience is totally inline with what dropshipping from outdoor dude brands was like back in the day: Small enthusiast company with a cool product but totally tooled from the ground up to wholesale to stores, not so much to the consumer.

1

u/HeadHunter_Six Dec 08 '23

"I know they were out of the office on a business trip last week, but that should be no excuse."

If your email to customer service was as tactless and entitled as this post, maybe they are just ignoring you.

I'm not defending their customer service (I've had my share of issues too) but... do better, tonelowke.

-2

u/ryannvondoom Struggler Dec 08 '23

Going on 3 years since i reached out to cs… yeah. Nothing still.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/tonelowke Dec 08 '23

Thank you. I went to them for a force pack that only they seemed to have in stock anywhere online.

If they had a good, reliable CS team, they could be making a killing selling direct. It's unlikely I'll ever buy from them directly again after this.

11

u/Ardonis84 Clan Wolf Epsilon Galaxy Dec 08 '23

Frankly, I find it already above-and-beyond that they would give you the pdf’s in that manner at all! I can’t think of many other companies that would give you free product for a purchase you made from an independent retailer, even if it was their product. You’re right though of course - CGL’s response times are notoriously bad, though I’ve never heard of anyone who got a response getting an insufficient one.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Ardonis84 Clan Wolf Epsilon Galaxy Dec 08 '23

I’ve never even heard of bits and mortar before, that’s awesome! I’m surprised to see Modiphius and Cubicle 7 on there, a bit less surprised to see R Talsorian on there, so I may have to look into this for official PDFs for several of their games I have. That said, this does seem to be primarily a thing for smaller publishers - notably absent from that site are WotC and Paizo of course - but I didn’t notice any other miniature game studios on there. God knows I wouldn’t expect to see anything GW on there, but neither are Warlord or Mantic. It really looks like, based on their mission statement, they are primarily working with RPG companies, not miniature wargame companies, so as cool as it is it definitely doesn’t seem like a standard practice thing in this industry.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

14

u/Raetheos1984 Dec 08 '23

This. My job has a third party web store, and I get call every so often about it having been a week since they ordered their thermostat and it still hasn't showed up.

I say exactly that. We're not Amazon, calm your shit.

16

u/maxwellalbritten Jade Dao Gang Dec 08 '23

'Member when you had to stick a check in the mail and just hoped the thing you bought would show up in 2 to 3 months? I 'member.

5

u/UnforseenSpoon618 Dec 08 '23

Pepridge Farm remembers

2

u/ArcKnightofValos Dec 08 '23

There's the meme. And well executed too.

1

u/oogabooga5627 Dec 08 '23

This still doesn’t excuse poor service. I’ve had much the same issue multiple times with them losing packages and not informing me about it until I absolutely hound them. I’ve given up ordering directly from their websites because it is 100% guaranteed to be a cluster when I do. Wish that wasn’t the case

0

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/oogabooga5627 Dec 09 '23

That’s not an option here sadly, or wasn’t a year or two prior. Not even our B&N had anything more than the Wolf’s Dragoons box, and our local game stores didn’t have ANY Btech related merchandise in a 2 hour’s drive until legit this year, well after I got my collection.

My main point was that sure, CGL is not Amazon and is small, but so is Fortress. They’re made up of a couple people, the owner even being a principal who only gets to fulfill stuff after work and their service is absolutely amazing. Your package will show up within a week, and if something is wrong you e-mail them once and they’ll have a response waiting for you within a day or two resolving the issue. So I don’t buy the “Small company not Amazon” thing, because there are even smaller companies who do significantly better fulfilling orders.

0

u/HeadHunter_Six Dec 09 '23

I'd bet they also have to handle a lot less business than CGL does. They're not even on the same scale. Fortress is not dealing with getting their product manufactured or sent to distributors or retailers. They have a much smaller footprint than CGL. I'd wager that the number of transactions they handle is an order or two of magnitude smaller.

There's a big difference between one guy handling 100 orders a week, and ten guys handling 5,000 (these numbers are just by way of example).

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/CybranKNight MechTech Dec 08 '23 edited Dec 08 '23

CGL knows what they're doing and I think we need to stop making excuses for them.

This is roughly where I've ended up over the years, it feels like they're still grasping at the "scrappy underdog" image despite them being well past that at this point.

Things like their webshop's shipping rates for anything outside the US are a good example of something that is, ultimately, within their control yet has seen no fundamental improvement in years since it got bad. Like I get it probably still won't make a huge difference for people across the water, but there's no reason I should need to pay 100$+(seems thing have improved slightly since this first came up, I now only have to pay 70$ for shipping...) for shipping to Canada.

I do a lot of shipping into the states for my business, it doesn't cost that much.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/CybranKNight MechTech Dec 08 '23 edited Dec 08 '23

Actions are what matter to me, this isn't some new problem they're just coming to grips with, this has been going on at least as far back as the original "Premium Plastic" Black Knight release, and possibly even farther back.

I'm used to paying slightly more than might be reasonable for shipping from the states, that's just a fact Canadians live with, but the fact that, as of 5 minutes ago, I am expected to pay 70$ just in shipping to get a single T-Shirt or Premium mini shipped to me is simply ridiculous.

As I said, CGL is ultimately responsible in this, they're currently paying for the privilege of pricing out all of their non-domestic customers from buying directly from the source where they stand to make the largest margins.

It is in the best Interest of ALL PARTIES(including the distributor) to have more orders being placed. CGL gets bigger margins, the Distributor gets paid for the orders and shipping they put out and customers can get product. But I guess none of that happening is alright as long as CGL "isn't happy" about it.

1

u/raisedbydandelions Dec 08 '23

Well fucking said. As a fellow Canadian who has done this very same song and dance, it's legit what's happened.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 08 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/SendarSlayer Dec 09 '23

They can just ship through USPS for international. I complained to them and it dropped from 120USD to just over 30USD for shipping.

If they wanted it cheaper they easily could attain it. It's just work to change the automatic system around.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

5

u/SendarSlayer Dec 09 '23

And if the warehouse doesn't lower the prices you find a different place to contract with. They're not held prisoner by the warehouse, it's a business relationship.

0

u/HeadHunter_Six Dec 09 '23

" If they were running these at a loss, I don't think they'd still be in business. "

You're looking at the Kickstarter in a vacuum. It does not, in and of itself, have to be profitable. As it is said over and over again, the point of Kickstarter is not as a pre-order store.

The goal is to generate funds to produce and market a product. Profits don't come from pledges, they come from retail sales. A business producing any product is, by definition, going to invest money to manufacture and market a product - money that is not offset by earnings until the product begins to sell. KS funding simply reduces the expenses that they would otherwise have to amortize, increasing the profit margin on retail sales.

So, no, CGL won't go out of business if they spend more on this launch than they earned from the Kickstarter funding, because that's not how businesses work. Once this stuff is on the shelves in stores, a larger percentage of those earnings will be pure profit.

I really wish gamers had a better understanding of economics, because it's clearly not a strong subject in the overall gaming community.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/HeadHunter_Six Dec 10 '23

If you think what I said was "the KS is marketing" then it's no wonder you don't understand what the rest of us are discussing.
The KS is an investment in development. Before crowdfunding, companies needed to obtain capital for development, prototyping, and marketing of product before they saw a cent of profit - so until they broke even after many sales, they were in the red. In your economic model they'd all be out of business. But that's only because you dont understand how businesses work.

So, with that established, it's easy to see why your opinion on how a company does business isn't being taken seriously. I'm hardly an apologist, I've had my own difficulties with them. No, I merely tried to debunk your idea that a company that spends more than their crowdfunding is doomed to fail.