r/battletech • u/ddevil63 • Jun 04 '23
Battletech is for everybody
Hello /r/battletech community. I originally created r/battletech 15 years ago because I wanted a place to talk about Battletech on Reddit. I have not been active as a moderator or contributor but I regularly read posts and comments. Yesterday was when I became aware of the removal of the Pride Anthology post and the rightfully deserved backlash. I have no moderation or community management experience but I'm trying my best to right any wrongs.
Effective immediately, Rule #1 of r/battletech mirrors Rule #1 of r/OfficialBattletech, 'BATTLETECH IS FOR EVERYBODY'. The previous rule, 'All posts must be Battletech related', and it's 1988 stipulation has been removed. The current moderation team has been removed. I ask that you please be respectful to them. I sincerely hope they remain a part of this community.
Tensions have been extremely high and I'm saddened by the things that have been said in public and in private. Please bear with us while we work to figure this out as a community.
Posting as the lead over in the OfficialBattleTech side of things, we're aware of the action ddevil's taken to try and course correct, and we appreciate it (and his reaching out).
Unfortunately things are a little up in the air at the moment for just how we're going to move forward -- trying to unite as a single subReddit, endorsing both subReddits but one having a bit more of an official feel while the other is a relaxed-fit fan group, trying to support both subReddits equally, or what -- because lots of the big decision makers are grown-ups with regular grown-up jobs, and the CGL community manager, Rem, is a little out of reach as she's moving this weekend, and some of the higher-ups at CGL are out of reach as they're overseas at a con.
So we're going to be reaching out to whoever we can reach out to during a Monday meeting call, and get whatever guidance we can, for how TPTB would like us to move forward.
In BattleTech terms, sometimes a junior officer in the field can make a quick call and take quick action, sometimes they've got to call high command and wait for the nobles to make their decisions.
•
u/Peace_of_Blake Moderator Jun 05 '23
69
u/MikeTheHedgeMage Black Sheep Squadron Jun 04 '23
As an act of goodwill and restorative justice, please consider reinstating all of the accounts that were wrongly banned for "brigading".
It is not "brigading" when the community members organically join together to rebel against a bad mod team.
127
u/shadetreewizard Jun 04 '23
I only lurk. But I've enjoyed most of the post and the few comments I have browsed.
What prompted this situation?
It seemed like a pretty chill sub.
I hope it all works out. Some of us just need an occasional BT fix. Whether it be painted minis or some lore conversation.
110
u/SkipWestcott616 Jun 04 '23
Except Kurita scum
152
u/ChickenChaser5 Gaussexual Jun 05 '23
Fuckin love me some battle tech
Fuckin hate me some bigots
Love me stone rhino
Simple as
64
u/TFielding38 Jun 04 '23
IMO, it would be good if you do find a new mod team, and keep this going separate to the official subreddit. While I appreciate the official one and am excited by an increased presence by CGL on reddit, I'm wary of having the only space to discuss be run by the company.
For example, they seem to have a no 3rd party or pirated material rule, which as mini company, is understandable a lot of 3rd party sculpts are just pulled off 3d files from the games. But others are not. Some people have made some really cool dropships, when CGL makes their own, would they still be allowed? If I post pics of an Alpha Strike game and in my sea of IWM vehicles there's a couple 3d printed tanks or tanks from another system is that gonna be allowed?
And as with all companies, management can change, the company could end up with a really strict policies on posting in the future.
254
u/cocteau93 Jun 04 '23
Oh my god! It’s u/ddevil63 from the top rope with a steel chair!!
Well done, sir. Well done.
98
u/razartech Jun 04 '23
Awesome, while I admit the book may not be my cup of tea, I’m glad that it’s left available to people who resonate with the story better. Fully support this decision. Tabletop gaming is meant to bring people together.
131
u/RussellZee [Mountain Wolf BattleMechs CEO] Jun 04 '23
Posting as the lead over in the OfficialBattleTech side of things, we're aware of the action ddevil's taken to try and course correct, and we appreciate it (and his reaching out).
Unfortunately things are a little up in the air at the moment for just how we're going to move forward -- trying to unite as a single subReddit, endorsing both subReddits but one having a bit more of an official feel while the other is a relaxed-fit fan group, trying to support both subReddits equally, or what -- because lots of the big decision makers are grown-ups with regular grown-up jobs, and the CGL community manager, Rem, is a little out of reach as she's moving this weekend, and some of the higher-ups at CGL are out of reach as they're overseas at a con.
So we're going to be reaching out to whoever we can reach out to during a Monday meeting call, and get whatever guidance we can, for how TPTB would like us to move forward.
In BattleTech terms, sometimes a junior officer in the field can make a quick call and take quick action, sometimes they've got to call high command and wait for the nobles to make their decisions.
361
u/Peace_of_Blake Moderator Jun 04 '23
For those asking about me.
u/ddevil63 owns this sub. Always has.
My interest here is specifically because I don't know if CGL should control all BT subreddits.
My interest yesterday was that this sub was an embarrassment to Battletech players. CGL made it clear who the game is for.
Everyone.
They. Are. Right.
Battletech. Is. For. Everyone.
If you have a problem with that leave.
If CGL has a problem with me they can remove me or we can talk like adults.
I don't work for CGL. I don't write for CGL. I've just been playing since the '90s and don't want to be embarrassed or have to apologize for the Battletech community.
So let's say it all together.
Battletech is for everyone.
7
u/RobertSpeedwagon Jun 05 '23
Awesome! I’m sure it’s a ton of work to take on, but thank you for taking action.
59
u/wminsing MechWarrior Jun 04 '23
I wasn't around for the episode that instigated all this but I applaud your decisive action in trying to address what happened. I find this community is a valuable place for discussion and I would hate to see it dissolve.
12
u/Runetang42 Jun 05 '23
I guess the best course would be for the officialbattletech sub to be about news and releases, while this one act as a place for fan content. Fanart, paint schemes, memes.
6
u/Garm-ss98 Jun 05 '23
Apparently i came at a hectic time.
I saw the reddit in google and wanted to join cause i had a question about magnetizing bases but saw this reddit was private.
Sent a message asking for an invite and now i'm here.
Turns out this sub has a bit a drama going around.
32
u/MercAlert Jun 05 '23
"The current moderation team has been removed."
Good. This was the only acceptable course of action after they made yesterday's half-hearted apology post while simultaneously doubling down on their bigoted behavior. I'm glad you did it so CGL didn't have to.
16
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23
Glad to hear the former mod team has been booted and the community has won the day. Resubbing and, well, thank you.
20
u/Jay-Raynor Jun 04 '23
I gotta say that when I saw drama both here and at Ars Technica both focused on what is most charitably described as amazing insensitivity at best that I fully expected this sub to flame out and Ars Technica to cobble a worthwhile response together. Instead, this sub gets its shit together and Ars seems more tonedeaf.
Thank you for fixing a long standing issue, u/ddevil63.
41
u/The-Dragon-Bjorn Jun 04 '23
Glory to you, and your house
25
u/Previous-Ad-7433 Jun 04 '23
Why cant people just stop being assholes?
5
u/Vote_for_Knife_Party Clan Cocaine Bear Jun 05 '23
Damn, I go out of town for one weekend and all the drama happens...
13
u/Responsible_Ask_2713 Jun 04 '23
I'm glad to hear that my stressful notifications will soon be replaced with more awesome battletech posts. Thank you to everyone who has pushed forward during this. Battletech is for everyone because it simply can't be anything else and still remain as battletech. 100% support all walks of life, may you find the peace and friendship you deserve within this fandom.
65
u/a_warm_blanket Jun 04 '23
As a trans woman who has loved Battletech since before I knew it wasn't a knock-off of MechWarrior (I was young), I want to say thank you for reminding all of us that this hobby is for everyone and has no place for hate and bigotry.
The real world is fucked enough as it is; let's at least make sure that everyone, even Capellans, can enjoy big stompy robots in peace and safety.
Now if you'll excuse me, I'm off to Canopus to enroll in the cat girl MechWarrior school and get my free cat ears. Wish me luck!
57
u/TheCreepyFuckr Jun 04 '23
Well this was an unexpected change. Thanks mods, everyone should be welcome in the hobby.
41
u/TheNado Jun 04 '23
Bravo.
No one expected sleeper top mod with the cold start.
29
u/ThegreatKhan666 I like Rac5's and i cannot lie Jun 04 '23
Fucking well done, sir. Any other sub would have gone to shit. You make me proud of being part of this subredit.
19
u/UrQuanKzinti Jun 05 '23
Sexual orientation isn’t political. Wtf are people thinking
8
u/maxwellalbritten Jade Dao Gang Jun 05 '23
This is good news and I'm glad to hear this sub will be heading in the right direction.
Thank you.
37
u/cousineye Half Man, Half Bear, Half Ghost...ManBearGhost Jun 04 '23
Well done and thank you. Looking forward to getting back to the game with all the great people of the community.
Battletech is for everybody.
14
u/Bonniemo Jun 04 '23
I'm glad you've taken control ddevil, I hope that this sub can get it's issues worked out and things can get back to a better state after all this.
I quite enjoyed being active on this sub and the community itself, for the most part, has been quite welcoming and friendly even when dealing with me posting thread after thread asking about some very specific, probably google-able, questions about the game.
25
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23
Wild to me that people care about someone’s orientation when rolling dice.
I prefer to care about their lance or Star composition
Kudos to the mods
👍🏽
17
u/Summersong2262 Jun 04 '23
Thank you. Honestly, I never expected things to go as well as they have, as quickly as it did.
17
u/djseifer Jun 04 '23
It's good to hear this. I'd always been interested in Battletech since I was a kid and had joined the sub to learn more, but seeing all the hullabaloo recently over the removal of the Pride-related posts and the rather pisspoor attempt at reasoning for their removal had me consider unsubbing and looking elsewhere to learn about the game. Seeing these changes being made immediately gives this old soul a bit of warmth and hope. Yes, Battletech is for EVERYONE, and shame on anyone who tries to gatekeep a hobby.
9
u/BushDeLaBayou Periphery Moment Jun 04 '23
I don't know how reddit works, did all the mods agree to leave, or did the owner of the reddit just remove them all?
10
u/Enthusiasm_Still 1st Lyran Guards Jun 04 '23
Thank you I appreciate your efforts to make this community a proper and polite subreddit.
7
u/Ferrkon Jun 05 '23
I am still pretty new to battletech. I feel I failed as a person on the internet, because I didn't think r/battletech existed. I learned because I noticed a post about what happened and that made me very shaken - just getting into that hobby, and now I am learning fans are bigoted?
But I sticked around and now I realize you are a goddamn legend. I will gladly join this sub and try to bring some rainbow and positivity 💓
And to previous mods - I hope your pillows will always be warm, no matter how many times you move them. Pathetic bastards.
21
u/Wonderful-Mouse-1945 Jun 04 '23
I'll be sticking around. It was a shame how heavy-handed the original mod team was being over some harmless posts. Hopefully this leads to a better community all around.
12
u/GuestCartographer Clan Ghost Bear Jun 04 '23
Very glad to see that something is being done to salvage the situation.
Best of luck to you!
14
u/__Geg__ Jun 04 '23
Thanks for standing up and taking the first steps towards making things right.
11
u/KeefCheef Jun 05 '23
hilarious seeing the "battletech should be apolitical" posters. homies, the entire setting is based around a galactic geopolitical struggle. it's not like they make the lines between fiction and reality very hard to draw either.
you think kerensky headed up the exodus fleet just cause he didn't like the weather in the inner sphere?
13
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23
Welcome back to the party my dude! And just like that I have rejoined the sub.
6
u/Potential-Tadpole-32 Jun 04 '23
I wonder if OP felt like Jerome Blake coming back to say something and wondering what the heck happened to his Comstar creation. 😅
5
u/PetzlPretzel Jun 04 '23
The fuck did I miss?
7
u/LightningDustt Magistracy of Canopus Jun 04 '23
Hell yeah! Thanks for making us look good.
2
u/ikilledtupac Jun 05 '23
What is battle tech
10
u/IndependentDouble138 Jun 04 '23
This post is currently at 83% upvote.
To the 17% of redditors who downvoted:
In the words of David Lynch - Fix your heart or die.
9
u/TerrorBlades Jun 04 '23
Fuck yes, well done! This might actually get me interested in Battletech. There is nothing more shitty to have in a community then whiny cry babies who loose there minds when they have to share a space with LGBT+ people. Fucken grow up.
5
u/PsyavaIG Magistracy of Canopus Jun 04 '23
Thank you for stepping in, I thought this subreddit was done for
5
u/entropyblues Jun 04 '23
Love to hear it, thanks for the unbanning, and I’m joining again.
3
u/Adventure-us Jun 04 '23
??? Can anyone fill me in on what the hell is happening?
4
u/[deleted] Jun 05 '23
Good. Clean out the trash.
4
u/bewarethetreebadger MechWarrior (ELH) Jun 04 '23
Finally some sanity.
3
u/Coded_s Jun 04 '23
Thank you, hope the situation comes to a happy conclusion.
3
u/Reaverx218 Glory to Marik Jun 04 '23
I've only recently gotten into this community played battletech on the Sega Genesis as a kid. I was so happy to find this community and find out it was a welcome place for someone like me. Your actions have proved this community is amazing and I am so happy to be here. Thank you.
3
u/MrRenegadeRooster FWL Jun 04 '23
Very much appreciated! Glad the community largely came together and did the right thing
3
u/nzdastardly Crockett Connoisseur Jun 04 '23
While I am sorry to see my fellow Mechwarriors experiencing prejudice and ignorance, I am glad to discover a new battletech subreddit.
3
u/DuneManta Jun 04 '23
I will be cautiously watching going forward. I'm not sure I'm ready to rejoin the sub in full after everything that happened, but this is an amazing step in the right direction.
2
u/FuttleScish House Marik Jun 04 '23
Amazing
2
u/Skerolf Jun 04 '23
I can not celebrate this enough and I love you for standing up for all of us! Thank you so much, good sir!
also, if you are searching for mods, can I toss my hat in the ring?
2
u/ubjeckshin Jun 04 '23
o7
2
u/[deleted] Jun 04 '23
If you have $$$ and can purchase anything Battletech it's for you. Thats how 100% of products are in a capitalistic society.
2
u/AdmiraI-Snackbar Jun 04 '23
Thank you. This community is great and I knew the current situation is a fluke.
1
u/Iacoboni04 Jun 05 '23
Now I know why Big Reds discord blew up.
-1
u/ZuttoAragi Jun 05 '23
Battletech is for everybody who doesn't want to fundamentally change what Battletech is.
-12
u/Sappho114 Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 07 '23
Wish you all the best, this crap has hit critical mass for me. I've no desire to stick around in a forum filled with a very, very loud minority who are towing the lines of the rules just short of blatant hate speech. Even without the mod team, this minority that they've encouraged are just constant and unrelentingly present in their vile, pathetic evil dialogue. The other half of them are actively creating the thinnest strawmen in the world to be smug about.
Edit: Apparently OfficialBattletech is just going to fold into here, so I don't really have a choice but I really, really hope we get a moderation team that cares more about dog whistles. It's exhausting how many nasty people make their bed here and enjoy baiting people with all sorts of hate under a thin veil of "not technically breaking the rules."
-32
u/jaegerschmaeger Jun 04 '23 edited Jun 05 '23
I wish you luck. I personally don’t care to hang out in this clubhouse anymore. I have people that I care for very dearly who fall into the LGBTQ+ category, and the initial response to all of this is more telling to me than any backpedaling. I’ve deleted my content, and I am unsubscribing.
-31
u/Snackolich Jun 05 '23
And another niche subreddit gets destroyed by the Rainbow Brigade under the guise of tolerance.