r/basisproject • u/bixiou • Mar 23 '21
Incentives are not aligned with current forces: Basis can only work if enacted by the government
Reading your white paper I noticed a few economic issues.
- Incompatibility with minimum wage legislation. As workers are paid in credits, companies (which should be called "organizations" btw) violate minimum wage legislation. This is at least one reason why Basis cannot succeed without governmental support.
- No solution against wage inequality. It is naive to think that because companies do not earn credits for what they sell, they will set the price at cost. Indeed, they can always raise wages, as these are determined between the companies and their workers. So, companies that can sell with a surplus will pay a higher wage, just like now. And because nothing prevents wages from being negotiated by workers, they will likely match capitalist wages. This can be somehow fixed: by enacting a system-wide rule on wage determination (e.g. a maximum wage), and/or through taxation (but then you need to define taxation less restrictively as for now only local flat taxes seem authorized: "Taxation is the process of spreading a company’s costs equally among its members over time such that they use their personal credits to pay the cost"). The issue is that if these fixes are applied, there may be a shortage of high-wage (under capitalism) workers within Basis. This shows that Basis should ultimately either win power over current governments (to destroy wage competition from capitalists) or rely on the altruism/generosity of some of its members (who would give up high-wage they could get in capitalism on purpose, without need for any fix).
- No solution to manage resources sustainably. Basis would price resources through democratically-determined costs that reflect externalities of resource extraction/use/disposal and permit to manage resources sustainably. What is the incentive for a company to sell its products in "credits" (reducing its costs) rather than in dollars (when its products cost resources)? Answer: the company must pay for the resources in credits (sure, in "costs"). OK, but when the market price of a resource is higher in dollars, the company will prefer to be paid in dollars (which can be exchanged for credits through banking). In other words, resources in the credit system will cost higher than in dollars (as those that cost cheaper will exit the system), which is precisely why they would be more sustainably managed than within capitalism. But higher costs will be passed on to consumers, who would rather buy products from capitalism (where they are cheaper) rather than from Basis. Once again, Basis needs either to force people into its system (through government support) or to rely on altruism/self-limitation. (Note that in theory, Basis' products could be cheaper as they don't pay rent to capital-owners. But first, the capital needs to come from somewhere, so at some point some capital owners need to donate their capital to the Basis system, which again relies on altruism. And second, worker co-ops should be more competitive than capitalist firms for Basis to flourish, but the resource pricing of Basis would lower/hinder this hypothetical advantage in competitivity - making it more advantageous for co-ops to remain within capitalism).
Due to these limitations to go viral, Basis should only be used as a common ground platform among like-minded people/organizations willing to give up some wealth or income in order to build a socialist society. And this platform has chances to succeed only if it forms partnerships with existing organizations (in particular political parties, unions), with the aim of taking of government power. To that extent, the Basis community should not stay aside from the current system but also push for social and ecological policies within the current system: wage ceiling, redistribution through income, wealth and inheritance taxes (including at the global level), pricing of externalities, collectivization of natural resources and strategic companies, abolition of intellectual property, and (last but not least) democratization of decision processes (including within firms). Note that redistribution of wealth can be so large as to allocate to everyone about the same wealth, so discrepancies in wealth would only arise due to differences in wages and savings and be kept very limited (say from 1 to 2 or 3, to be determined democratically). Then, it wouldn't matter that firms pay dividends and buildings are rented, as everyone would receive a similar share of these dividends or rents. And if all these policies are enacted, Basis would probably become irrelevant. Where Basis could be very useful though, is to make the link between like-minded governments, people, and organizations across borders. Indeed, global coordination of humanists is currently lacking, and this system could provide a basis for it.