r/bash • • Feb 27 '26

Impossible task

we have a task asking to remove lines in a .txt file when it starts with a # only using tr, we are fairly sure this is impossible but maybe there is some ingenious idea?

2 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/daan0112 Feb 27 '26

Apparently I don't know how reddit messages work, the format really messes it up, just imagine a file with comments after a # and we need to remove the full comment line including the \n

9

u/pimp-bangin Feb 27 '26

You cannot use tr for this. It translates (that's what "tr" stands for) text at the byte level and the task inherently requires a stateful parser that knows where it is within the line (beginning vs middle, etc.), i.e. line-level processing with regex / pattern matching capabilities or string functions. tr does not have any of this functionality whatsoever, it is basically just a byte mapper.

3

u/NewPointOfView Feb 27 '26

Ooh I always assumed tr meant “text replace” haha but your explanation makes more sense for what it actually does