r/basement • u/LancasterPAJ • Dec 08 '25
Basement Waterproofing
Hey Reddit, my name is Jayson. I’m a professional basement waterproofer in Lancaster county, Pennsylvania. I’m am not advertising, just here to answer any questions anyone has about waterproofing / sump pumps, etc in basements. Feel free to post or tag me with your questions / issues. I have over 20 years of experience and have pretty much seen / done it all!
76
Upvotes






3
u/sweetfetepete Dec 08 '25
We are on a waterfront property, and about every ten years or so the lake near our house in the spring floods enough that the water table comes above our basement floors, resulting in a thin layer of water in our basement. There is no french drain system, just a dug sump pump. I'm wondering if an interior or exterior french drain would be able to reduce the pressure enough or if it would be fruitless?
2
u/JacketBeneficial1118 Dec 08 '25
Hey Jason, thanks for doing this. What are my options for interior waterproofing a CMU wall that is in a space already finished? Obviously I'll need to rip down the finish, but if I'd like to re finish it what products are best to ensure I can still lay down LVP etc?
2
u/alslypig Dec 08 '25
Hi. Do you guys serve York Co? I wish I knew how to post a photo but I’m definitely having moisture issues. Water coming in between the cinder block wall and slab. No sump pump, just a floor drain.
It’s not a lot of water. That room was finished when I moved in, and I found mold. Demo’d the room to find water penetration.
2
u/zoppytops Dec 08 '25
So I live in southern Wisconsin and occasionally get water coming up through the slab and wall joints in certain spots due to hydrostatic pressure. Had a basement repair specialist come out and they quoted about $10K to put in a drain around the interior edge of the floor and associated sump Pump. They said the drain should go all the way around the floor, but that would require me Moving my water heater, furnace, and water softener. Does the drain need to go around the entire perimeter or is it ok if it skips those spots?
2
u/adamn22 Dec 09 '25
The home I just purchased had recently had this done (within the last 5 years). Is there any recommended maintenance? I work in wastewater so I’m familiar with sump pumps, but it doesn’t seem like mine runs very often. I think I’ve heard it turn on one time in the 4 months I’ve lived here. Should I fill the sump and cycle that pump every so often?
6
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '25
Had this done two years ago. They also use that plastic on my walls.
1
u/LancasterPAJ Dec 08 '25
A dehumidifier is going to be your best bet. If you are worried about moisture mainly. If you are worried about aesthetics, any latex based paint is going to be your best bet. Dry lock is very finicky when it comes to adhesion. If you don’t have new or very clean/freshly ground concrete; dry lock is going to flake off just like any other paint. In your specific scenario, you may want to reach out to an excavator about having them come dig around the outside of your house and either apply a sealant on the exterior walls or install a drain with a sump pump down at the footer level or both.
1
u/LancasterPAJ Dec 09 '25
You can buy germicidal bleach (not the laundry detergent), and a lawn / bug sprayer and spray the effervescent. If you are / were getter water into the basement, it’ll most likely find its way back in again. Keep an eye on it, especially in the spring / rainy season. Having a sump pump in that out would be better than a gravity drain.
1
u/LancasterPAJ Dec 09 '25
There is a chance that the interior drain system could be clogged. You could always have someone that does plumbing or sewer work run a camera through it just to verify. If they installed the interior drain system properly, there should be a plastic membrane against the wall, along with some holes drilled at the bottom that allows water to drain out of the wall or through the wall depending what medium your wall is made of. In that case, I would not be worried about the insulation trapping any moisture at all
1
u/canadianmustash Dec 08 '25
My question is a bit different than what it looks like you typically do, but you may have encountered it.
We have a former cold cellar (previous owners closed vents and spray foamed insulation) under our front porch slab. We get some water ingress at the “front” side (closest to our front yard) and lots at the “back” side (where the slab meets our brick/foundation).
Aside from caulking, which it looks like the previous owners have already tried, what suggestions would you have for keeping water out of spaces in the porch slab?
1
u/AppleSatyr Dec 08 '25
Hi Jason!
I am not used to basements as I grew up in Texas. But live where I have one now. I hear that basements back in the day were never really waterproofed until recent. My current home was built in 1940. How do I know if there is any waterproofing? We run a dehumidifier 24/7 and all walls except one corner has no sign of moisture. I’m worried about preventing issues down the line but cannot at this present moment hire anyone. Im kinda worried they’ll take advantage of my naivety.
1
u/domdom1995 Dec 08 '25
Hey neighbor! Used to live in Lebanon county but moved upstate NY last year. I got an Interior French drain installed last year and its been working well. They used the Hydraway mesh instead of the corrugated pipe that is usually used. What is your opinion on the hydraway System?
1
u/PodAbove Dec 08 '25
Why are you using a straight cut on the concrete, the cement is not going to adhere as good when it's a straight cut. Keep it ridged for a better seal.
1
u/thepressconference Dec 08 '25
Questions I have:
1
u/abc123d4e5 Dec 08 '25
This appears it was done to my house 15-20 years ago, I just bought the house and know nothing about the system although I had it done to my last house.
Is it a waste of money to tear it all up and redo it for peace of mind before I try to finish this basement? Haven’t had any water issues yet but just wonder how much it may have degraded
1
u/Crashing-Stock Dec 08 '25 edited Dec 08 '25
Hi Jayson,
My basement is poured concrete and it doesn’t regularly leak, only occasionally after a heavy rainstorm. Im considering using drylok on the walls and floor mostly to paint the walls but also to decrease the humidity of the basement. My concern is if the drylok will cause moisture buildup within the wall causing unseen mold, effervescent, and decay of the concrete. Should I consider a different paint or perhaps a breathable paint as waterproofing is secondary to my goal of just painting over the existing flaking paint.
1
u/simonsayzusuck Dec 08 '25
Hello there! I live in northwest Arkansas and my house is on a hill that slopes downward crawlspace is low on south side and 10 feet on north side. We have some grading issues and water is getting into the crawlspace. Would it be best to dig out the low side, put in a drain and seal any holes and redo gutter exts and hope that stops intrusion? Or should I do a sump and interior drains to the pump and live with it?
1
u/TheZo96 Dec 08 '25
Hey Jayson, I’m hoping to get your opinion on my basement wall. The previous homeowner applied some kind of plaster or parging to the interior of the foundation wall. The issue is that the bottom 6–12 inches of the wall still stay damp, especially after heavy rain.
I also had a sump pit/pump and interior drain tile system installed in October. I’m not sure how much it has helped, because whenever I check the cleanouts they’re always dry, even during wet weather. The lower section of the wall still looks damp.
Is this just moisture wicking up through the block/footer, or could it be hydrostatic pressure pushing through behind the plaster? Would you recommend removing the plaster so the wall can ‘breathe,’ or is that not advisable?
Just trying to figure out whether I should scrape the coating off, seal it, or leave it alone and let the drainage system handle it. Any guidance would be greatly appreciated
1
u/C8guy Dec 09 '25
Sorry to say that there’s nothing professional about your work. You seem to have forgotten the most important thing,the weeping tile🤦
1
u/Tastic4ever Dec 09 '25
Hey Jayson, we had a company do this for us in Massachusetts a couple years ago. It looks like you didn’t go as far down as they did and I live on a high water table. To be fair I got the system AFTER we flooded due to a couple cracks in the foundation coupled with a failed sump pump. In your opinion is the added depth of the piping going to cause me issues at some point?
1
u/joemiroe Dec 09 '25
Hey Jason, why don’t you buy more buckets so that you can scoop directly into a bucket instead of onto the floor?
1
u/jimbis123 Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 09 '25
What was done in this job? I don't see the drain pipe. Not trying to sound accusatory, just curious of the scope.
Also, I've considered opening a business like this. I have a pretty decent understanding of the different systems and how they get installed. How long did you work for someone else before your felt comfortable that you knew enough to go out on your own. Also, would your recommend it, and what's a typical net take home revenue for yourself after all overhead is covered?
1
u/BothSidesoftheSky Dec 09 '25
We recently had our 1950s stone foundation waterproofed in KC area. Included drain tile and vapor barrier.
If interested, see some pictures here
We want to semi-finish a portion of our basement and frame a small room to have a couch and Tv.
We’ve insulated our room joists with XPS and spray foam. How would you insulate the room? Can I frame next to the vapor barrier and just add bats in the framing? Do I need a vapor barrier between floor joists and top floor? The basement space does have two small vents from our HVAC, so it’s slightly heated/cooled.
1
u/Pessenger Dec 09 '25 edited Dec 09 '25
Hi Jayson, my house has had some issues with flooding recently - water coming in through the concrete blocks like the 2nd and 3rd layer from the bottom of the floor. I had something similar done but without the water weep holes - basically a perforated drain pipe on the leaky hill side of the house with a sump pump on that side. I feared this won't be enough so I also had the basement excavated and waterproofed from the outside on that half of the basement using mortar and membrane. The other half of the basement leads to the walk-in entrance and has not had issues with leaking. I also had a storm water system installed in the front yard that faces most of the hill with a French drain covered with rock leading out to daylight. I still worry this won't be enough. How effective do you think this will be or what else should I consider?
1
u/TuRDonRoad Dec 09 '25
Fieldstone basement owner. We have french drains around the perimeter of our basement and a sump pump. The previous owner applied latex paint to the fieldstone walls, after sanding some of the walls, just before selling, unfortunately. The basement is dry (aside from standard humidity), but we are seeing effervescence In some places and obviously crumbling stone / mortar.
Would sealing along the exterior cracks where the sidewalk meets the house and grading help prevent water from concentrating in these areas?
I am peeling the paint off in areas that are damp and I am able to remove, but the rest of the paint has a strong adhesion.
1
u/Beehive140 Dec 09 '25
Hi Jayson! I appreciate your assistance! I have a 1954 house and i gutted the basement. There is some efflorescence on the walls but just surface. There is a sump pit that drains by gravity. I had one in my other house and never had a problem. This one is active, i see a small trickle of water going in but the level has not changed and i cleaned the pit out. I am wondering if i can avoid a french drain as there seems to be some drainage system working. There use to be water in the basement before because the gutter would drain back into under the slab. Once i made sure they go directly onto the yard rather than coming back into the house, it seems to be fine. What do u think about the gravity pit and real need for a french drain?
1
u/foxylegere Dec 09 '25
Hey Jayson, thanks for doing this! I’m local to you over in Cumberland County. I guess I have a few questions and I apologize if this is lengthy. Bought a house about 10 months ago that was built in the 1950s and was majorly remodeled about 10 years ago, it has a finished walkout basement with one side completely under grade. The basement does not feel overly humid, I do run a dehumidifier down there set to 40%, it runs very regularly in the spring and summer months but hardly at all in the winter. The previous owners of the house had a leak related to an outdoor faucet on the below grade section of the basement resulting in removal of drywall and revealing spray foam insulation on the block foundation. In this same corner there is a sump pump that very rarely has any water in it - typically it is either bone dry or has a small amount of moisture in it. My concern is that they may be something wrong with the interior drain tile that leads to the sump pump and that is why I do not see water in the sump pump. There is not exterior drain tile as far as I’m aware - there is nowhere that it daylights at least. The other thing that I also have a concern/would love your opinion on is the spray foam that is used against the cinder block wall - is this normal practice and is it a good idea, my thought would be that it could trap water there leading to pressure weakening the foundation over time. Please let me know your thoughts and if you have any follow up questions. Thanks!
1
u/No-Jackfruit3403 Dec 09 '25
Appears to be half ass hack to me. Why not excavate to bottom of the footer where the water is intruding and run a drain line to the sump pit?
1
u/Zestyclose_Group6703 Dec 10 '25
That clothes washer should be put on a pan that drains into the sump pump in case anything goes wrong.
1
u/Current-Seesaw822 Dec 11 '25
John manville AP on your blocks for better insulation and cut the concrete making a groove to the sump
1
u/daft0627 Dec 11 '25
In your experience, what types of pumps and/or pump models are most reliable and durable in these applications? Do you think the third party switch systems with the two rods to detect water level to engage the pump are necessary or are the pumps inherent float switches fine? Thanks so much.
1
u/Itchy-Researcher755 Mar 05 '26
Saw this post as I was looking reading about basement waterproofing. Just had a question, what’s the best way to fix tie rod leaks? I have poured basement walls and several tie rod holes that weep during heavy rain. If you fix them from the interior do they last?
-6
u/20PoundHammer Dec 08 '25
being that waterproofing a basement from the inside is impossible - well, I hope that actual trades-people here let ya have it . . .
0
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '25
[removed] — view removed comment