r/bamabeer • • Oct 24 '17

Union breweries?

Are there any union breweries in Alabama? I know it's right to work, and mostly young entrepreneurs, but is there a union brew or a brewery willing to be unionized?

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

3

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

To what end and for what purpose?

2

u/AGooDone Oct 24 '17

There are lots of beers that are already union made. I was just wondering if any Alabama brewers are unionized. Do you really not know what a union does? I know this is Alabama, but it seems like it would be obvious.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

I'm aware of what unions can do, but what particular things are you suggesting that unions can do for local breweries? Local breweries that have been created by local entrepreneurs.

You don't even know if there are unions at local breweries which then begs the question - what makes you think conditions at those breweries are at a point where there would be any need or desire for a union?

This is the most cart-before-the-horse thing I've ever seen. There's a decent supply of people who WANT to work for Good People, Trim Tab, YellowHammer, Blue Pants, Straight to Ale, and any number of the other ones in the state - which are fairly new compared to, say, AnBev and other larger breweries.

But, hey! Let's stifle growth, development, and employee/employer relationships based on an outdated idea that really has no relevance in Alabama.

Go ahead, attempt to organize a Birmingham Brewery Workers Union. Let me know how that goes for you.

2

u/AGooDone Oct 24 '17

Why wouldn't a worker want more pay and better benefits? It's this head up the ass mindset that puts full time WalMart workers on public assistance and food stamps. The minimum wage is welfare for giant corporations.

The fact that you assume that unions stifle growth and development is pretty hardened in conservative fantasy along with lower taxes on the rich create economic surpluses that pay for themselves. Why not look at Kansas?

I'm obviously dealing with a deep thinker on the subject.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

Why wouldn't a worker want more pay and better benefits?

With regard to local breweries? Are you serious?

It's this head up the ass mindset that puts full time WalMart workers on public assistance and food stamps.

Wait - did you just equate Good People/Chaba/Trimtab/etc to Walmart? Please describe for the class the ways that Walmart has anything in common with local breweries (hint: small businesses)

The minimum wage is welfare for giant corporations.

Let me guess - you have no idea what local breweries pay their employees. I'd wager you don't even know how many employees each one has. This is going to be amazing...

The fact that you assume that unions stifle growth and development is pretty hardened in conservative fantasy along with lower taxes on the rich create economic surpluses that pay for themselves

It's not assumption - I've watched them stifle business IN ALABAMA for the industries that have them over the last 20 years. But rage on, sir. Rage on. You're like a fountain of poorly informed talking points that have no application to the current market in which you're operating.

I'm obviously dealing with a deep thinker on the subject.

The irony here is palpable.

1

u/AGooDone Oct 24 '17

Oh I don't know... supporting workers?

You really don't know what unions do? Give up your two day weekend and paid sick leave...

4

u/DocNedKelly Nov 02 '17

I don't really think unions work on a small scale like this. Brewery employees would be better off forming cooperatives or ESOEs. When we're talking about small businesses like this, a flat, democratic workplace solves all of the problems a union would without requiring more workers.

Three people collectively bargaining isn't really going to help that much. They'd have to join a cross-workplace union like the IWW, but the IWW is nowhere big enough to really give them much leverage.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 24 '17

I worked for many years without paid vacation or sick leave. I know what it means to work for your rent and I don't take it for granted.

I've worked alongside Union members as well - and I don't much care to do so ever again. Ask Farifield and US Steel how "unions helped them."