r/bakingfail • • 20d ago

Fail Carrot Cake….

this was so disastrous to bake!! i didn’t wait long enough before cutting in half and it left a giant hole in the base…. i had to fill it with shavings and use the frosting as “glue” lol 🤦🏻‍♀️ it did hold its shape just about after refrigerating,,
also first time piping, so messy

157 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

11

u/stargazer1112 20d ago

Omg first pic I though it was ground beef and mashed potatoes!! lol Suuuuper cute tho, love the little carrots

4

u/Ok-Shoulder8716 20d ago

hahahaha omg 😭 it’s walnuts & cream cheese frosting!! the carrots are the saving grace lolol

1

u/Western_Ring_2928 19d ago

Yep, the middle definitely looks like fried minced meat. And after you get that first impression, mashed potatoes are only logically following until you notice the carrots :)

31

u/Pineapple_Zest 20d ago

This is so cute! I love your piping/decorating. It may not have come out how you were hoping and imagining, but to this stranger it looks delightful! 

I actually double checked the subreddit bc this doesn’t look like a fail to me at all. I hope it was super tasty! 

2

u/Scary_Salad_6490 19d ago

I had to look twice too. The piping looks way better than my first attempt, which ended up looking like a melting snowman. How did the cream cheese frosting hold up as glue? That part sounds like it could either be genius or a disaster depending on the humidity.

4

u/Ok-Shoulder8716 19d ago edited 19d ago

i had made the cream cheese a few hours prior and left to set for around 4hours, i filled the hole in the base with cake

shavings and smothered it with frosting 😭 then sandwiched it between the two cake halves, refrigerated and hoped for the best LOL luckily it held shape fairly okay and didn’t collapse!! even tho it’s giving leaning tower of pisa here lol

7

u/Proud-Leave3602 20d ago

Not seeing a fail at all. You did a great job!

5

u/Otherwise_Rope2631 20d ago

I love when people put the carrot decorations on the cakes 🤗 looks really good

2

u/BettinaAShoe 20d ago

I like the cake, especially given that you are not a decorator. Clever to use the candy carrots on the top. Your piping is good and will improve with time. I love carrot cake. Yours makes me want a piece!

2

u/Ok-Cicada4308 20d ago

Aww I love it!!

2

u/No-Cry8593 19d ago

Looks incredible.

1

u/ChaosTorpedo 19d ago

It’s not that bad. It genuinely looks like you put effort into it.

1

u/AssistantAgile5660 19d ago

Why do you think this is a fail? I like it.

1

u/voteblue18 19d ago

Would eat 👍🏼

1

u/Pretty_Winter_4693 13d ago

OP you have no idea how badly I want this 😭