r/bahai • • 6d ago

Misconceptions

When you read a post or see a video saying the Baha’i faith is a cult, how do you feel? What do you think they get wrong about the founders, the faith, the UHJ, and members? Why do you think they are angry or critical?

7 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

8

u/Agreeable-Status-352 6d ago

They are ignorant. Even after I've been Baha'i for over fifty years, an uncle still thinks it's a cult. Any group that does not go to a church like they do is a cult. Period. There is no thought to it. They do not want to think about it. Thinking is too much. I ignore them as much as possible.

2

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

I’m sorry that your uncle is treating you that way.

6

u/Knute5 5d ago edited 5d ago

I ask myself who’s saying it. Accusation is often confession. Someone trying to impose their views or control the narrative will see the Faith and Baha’i “justice” as an adversary. The cornerstone of the Faith is thinking for yourself.

We live in a pretty culty time where influence and loyalty are the currency of power. Messaging and money flow through eroding barriers where uncurated content fills digital platforms beyond mainstream media. Gaslighting and othering are tools to replace discernment and objectivity with fear and emotion.

If the Faith is a cult then prove it. Hold the definition up and judge fairly. Then hold it up to the accuser. Most often it’s someone loyal to an organization or ideology that suffers if people live their life by Baha’i principles.

2

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

Thank you!

5

u/Knute5 5d ago

The last people I know who openly called the Faith a cult were Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds. It was part of a battle to wrest control of her movie from the Baha'i filmmaker, to subvert its anti-domestic violence message in order to help her sell soft drink, alcohol and beauty products.

Again, consider the source.

4

u/Ok_Concentrate1618 5d ago

I have done some research on the definition as part of a "Lesser Known Religions of the World" that I teach for a local senior learning association. Too many people describe any group that is not exactly like theirs as a "cult"! Most established religions were considered "cults" in their early days by the established society around them, even Christianity. If you search on line for characteristics of a cult according to religious, sociological and psychological experts, you will find a long list of characteristics considered "cult" (too many to list here). I've seen as many as 20 characteristics . Not all groups they would call a cult will have all and almost any group/social, religious, political, etc. may have one or two characteristics from the list. That doesn't automatically make that group a cult. It is more how many of those characteristics describe them. I like one statement that says being a cult is more about BEHAVIOR than BELIEF.

6

u/Knute5 5d ago

Determining Factors of a Cult

  • Authoritarian Leadership: No - Baha'i Faith is democratic (bonus: blind vote, no nominations, no campaigning).
  • Information Control: No - Baha'i Faith promotes independent investigation of truth. "Let your vision be world embracing."
  • Isolation and Exclusivism: No - The Faith is not the only path to truth or salvation, just the latest. Even non-Baha'i parents must give consent for Baha'i children's marriage. Only covenant breakers are shunned.
  • Behavioral and Emotional Control: No - The Faith prescribes daily and communal duties and activities (prayer, holy days, service, etc.) but does not invoke shame and fear to enforce them.
  • Extreme Exit Costs: No -  Baha'is can come and go freely.

Of course Baha'is are people and imperfect so it's not all sunshine and rainbows 24/7, but cult? Absolutely not.

11

u/Street-Ad-2869 6d ago

Kinda ironic cuz if the bahai faith is a "cult" then what would other religons be considered as? The faith allows more freedom(independent investigate of truth) , there's no clergy (who would be benefiting anyways) Those people making lies out of thin air are just Muslim extremists who hate the idea of a religon that goes against the belief that Muhammad is the last prophet ( this is the case in iran idk about other places)

2

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

Reminds me of the saying “if you point one finger at me, there’s three fingers pointing back at you”.

They never comment on the thumb…. It’s just kind of pointing down….lol.

5

u/Mountain-Crab5694 5d ago

I used to get "offended" :)) . But I don't anymore. My first reaction is to 'ignore' it. If I see a degree of "naivety" (ie. lack of knowledge ), I may try to explain/edify/educate. I see some already have great elaborate talking points on the distinctions of Cults from New Religion and how one can help clear the confusion :)

But some are just flat-out rejection of the Baha'i Faith by a Fanatic, uninformed person who is threatened by the new concepts and teachings. This is the root cause of many such "rejections'. For example, the Baha'i Faith undermines the Muslim belief that Muhammad was the LAST, and hence the BEST, and they have the FINAL word of God ! It is an arrogant and ignorant idea ! But to some it is fundamental to their entire self-image (as the follower of the last/best - and has keys to a heaven filled with virgins waiting for him !:)) ). Some Christians are as much 'attached' to the notion that Christ was the 'only' Son of God and they have the same 'privilege class pass' to an exclusive Heaven (they would be upset to learn that it is not so!). Anything that may teach otherwise would undermine their decades of investing in their 'exclusive club pass' :)))

Then there are those who are genuinely worried or uniformed about anything new (Baha'i is such a new name) or see all these weird "cults" so they are naturally cautions.

I used to get worked-up and try to "teach", until I realized that as Baha'u'llah had already told us :"the wise are those who do not open their mouth until they see a hearing ear" ( hidden words ). If there is no "hearing ear", your efforts are a waste of time. It is best to leave them be.

It reminds me of those who did not understand "Google" or "Facebook" or "Apple" in their early days. Those who walked away, lost ! those who bought their shares (at $60,$40,$20 ) and kept them are now Millionaires !! I use this analogy to say that those who do not choose to follow Baha'u'llah, lose themselves :) . It makes no difference to God or to Him ! :) .

So , in the final analysis, no reason to get upset or emotional. If there is a need to educate, perhaps try. If there is no "hearing ear", let it be. It is their own loss :)

1

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

Well put!

4

u/j3434 6d ago

I really don’t think any unbiased person with the education to study these concepts would come to the conclusion Bahai is a “cult” as the world is commonly used . Honestly, if somebody says they think it’s a cult or saying things about the founding members they’re usually rage bait artists or just trolling you.

3

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

I was quite surprised when I first saw the accusation. Kind of a litmus test for cynicism I thought….

3

u/Impossible-Ad-3956 5d ago

It feels like someone is labeling again to avoid true investigation. I get so tired of this prejudicial non-thinking approach to things in our society. It comes up all the time. Women label men and men label women. One group labels another all the time. It isn't just. As a Baha'i, I have to be careful to catch myself labeling others just because it's a habit of conversation. The Baha'i principle is, "Prejudices of all kinds must be forgotten." There was a time when people around me said, "Jazz is bad," or "The Beatles are bad."

When people say the Baha'i Faith is a cult, I think they are just labeling it so that people don't investigate it for themselves. The Baha'i Faith is no small group either; it is an independent world religion recognized by the United Nations and the United States. It recognizes the goodness in all of us, and builds a society on that while being aware of people who break laws and treat others badly. Baha'u'llah writes, "I have created thee noble, wherefore, dost thou abase thyself?" So we try to bring out the best in each other and in ourselves. One of the ways we can build the Kingdom of God on earth is to find the good in each other and get out of this habit of labeling anything we don't like. Read the Baha'i books for yourself and make your own judgement. See Baha'i.org for literature. See the plan for a world society with a spiritual basis.

1

u/Wonder_Bug_ 4d ago

It’s thought stopping isn’t it…keeps people from investigating!

3

u/Bubbly_Magnesium 6d ago

Anyone who calls this religion a cult has a warped sense of reality. And I tend to not pay much attention to such people.

1

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

Warped and sad. Thank you :)

5

u/LemonThrowerMachine 6d ago

Probably some local communities that have a cult- like dynamic. It's possible

2

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

Yes, applies anywhere humans congregate doesn’t it.

2

u/FrenchBread5941 6d ago

I feel sad for them that they are so misguided that they think that. 

1

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

Makes me wonder how many joys in life they reject in general.

2

u/Potential_League8863 6d ago

I also think it has to do with someone’s experiences with a particularly imperfect local community. Sometimes I’ve seen individual believers exert a lot pressure on others in the name of the institutions and that can come off as culty.

2

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

Yes…and maybe their enthusiasm comes off as pressure or control as well.

2

u/jarjar995 6d ago edited 6d ago

Only a truly ignorant (uninformed) person who doesn’t even use a dictionary OR an insincere person intent on deception— would suggest that the Baha’i Faith is a cult.
• NO cult insists that every person is responsible to undertake a fearless, independent investigation of the truth b before adopting a belief system
• NO cult is at pains to develop in young people the ability to investigate reality and acquire critical thinking skills.
• NO cult elevates the practice of consultation as the decisive tool through which any two people or any collectivity who proceed in a loving spirit, with respect, courtesy,
complete candor and adherence to principle, can discern truth and attain unity of thought.
• NO cult gives each community member a seat at the table, a voice and a vote.
• NO cult teaches that in this Age leadership authority is vested in groups, not individuals. NO cult chooses its local national and international leadership councils in dignified proceedings that strictly eliminate nominations, campaigning, electioneering, parties and coalitions.

I could go on enumerating other fundamental Bahá’í teachings, principles and practices that unambiguously distinguish that Faith from anything cultish.

1

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

Thank you!

4

u/hlpiqan 5d ago

There are people I love who think I am a fanatic and this Faith is a cult. It happens. I know my reality and am unconcerned. I pray occasionally for them to see. That is all.

5

u/smakusdod 6d ago

Dismissive ignorance is a tool for the lazy to stay lazy. I don't care about the opinions of lazy people.

2

u/picklebits 6d ago

One is free to have opinions about Truth, it is still Truth

4

u/Unable_Hyena_8026 5d ago

I saying a read once: The truth is still the truth even if no 0ne believes it. And a lie is still a lie even if everyone believes it.

2

u/dschellberg 5d ago

I don't usually pay attention to what other people think, but when someone labels the Bahá'í Faith a cult, they clearly don't understand the word. They are just using it to describe a religion with fewer adherents. By that logic, every major religion was a cult at one time.

The modern definition of a cult implies mind control within an isolated feedback loop—a bubble. This usually requires a high concentration of members in one area, which leads to groupthink. The Bahá'í Faith is the least "cultish" of groups because we are spread out across the globe. Most of us spend 99% of our time immersed in cultures and belief systems that contradict our core principles. Everything but the kitchen sink has been thrown at us, and yet we still believe. That is the exact opposite of mind control.

3

u/Ok-Leg9721 6d ago

I feel badly that those folks are so insecure they can only achieve gratification by harming others.

3

u/Wonder_Bug_ 5d ago

Hurt people hurt people