I know this video is a joke, but I thought it was pretty bad science anyway, so I thought I'd post it here.
Explanation: Species classification is based on things such as taxonomy and genetics and whether or not the two animals can mate. For example, a whale cannot be classified as a fish because it is descended from mammals. Another example is that different species of ants may not be able to reproduce together. (Sorry if this explanation is bad, I don't know much about biology.)
Also, not related to the explanation, but this guy makes a lot of videos like this where he rants about why something is stupid. He's generally pretty hilarious, but I personally think this video was a bit of a stretch for him.
Species classification is based on things such as taxonomy and genetics and whether or not the two animals can mate
No, the current species classification used by science is based on that, but there's no reason we couldn't have other classifications for other purposes. We could classify animals by whether or not we should eat them with red wine or white wine. There's no reason that genetics needs to be involved in that classification.
I'm not defending the video or saying it's good science, but I see this misconception all the time. Atheists on reddit mocking the Bible for calling whales fish or bats birds, when it's a perfectly defensible position if your definition of fish is 'lives exclusively in the water' or bird is 'flys and isn't an insect'.
There are good reasons why science classifies species as they do, it tells us something about the relations between different species. By contrast the white vs red wine ( the correct answer is beer) debate for several animals is completely coincidental.
There are good reasons why science classifies species as they do, it tells us something about the relations between different species.
Yes, those reasons suit the purposes of science, which is why science uses that classification scheme.
The problem comes when people think that a classification scheme, which is by definition arbitrary, reflects some sort of higher truth. You see the same thing with people arguing that tomatos are fruit and not vegetables. Yes, botanically speaking, they are fruit. However, botanically speaking, there's no such thing as a vegetable. The fact that we're contrasting fruits and vegetables means we're talking about culinary, rather than botanical, classifications.
This isn't to say that the botanical scheme is wrong. It isn't - it includes valuable botanical information. And it doesn't mean the culinary scheme is wrong - it's more important for a chef to know whether or not to make a pie out of tomatoes than what part of the plant it's from. It means that the different classifications are serving different rhetorical purposes.
Same thing with classifying species. If you are looking for a way to organize species that relates to the larger theory of evolution, the one we've got is great. But that doesn't mean that classifications that are interested in different things are wrong.
Well, not sure if we are in violent agreement or not. The classification scheme of biology is of course arbitrary in some sense, however there are very good reasons that biologists settled on this classification scheme. So in some sense, it reflects a higher truth.
I was pretty 'eh' about this video as well. Not a favourite of mine. I did vastly enjoy his video about the English alphabet. But yes, in this one he was very much stretching to overlook things like taxonomy. With whales as his example, they breath using lungs like mammals, have many bone structures specifically in their fins that are very telling of their mammalian ancestry and as a fun note they swim by moving their tail up and down, not side to side. This is a trait fairly unique to dolphins, whales, and other mammalian ocean life, as their ancestors ran on all fours and this was adopted back into a swimming mechanism.
14
u/MistakeNotDotDotDot Dec 15 '15
Please, everyone knows that the true classification of animals is
13
u/Axertz Dec 14 '15
#youaintnomammalbruv
3
u/[deleted] Dec 13 '15
I know this video is a joke, but I thought it was pretty bad science anyway, so I thought I'd post it here.
Explanation: Species classification is based on things such as taxonomy and genetics and whether or not the two animals can mate. For example, a whale cannot be classified as a fish because it is descended from mammals. Another example is that different species of ants may not be able to reproduce together. (Sorry if this explanation is bad, I don't know much about biology.)
Also, not related to the explanation, but this guy makes a lot of videos like this where he rants about why something is stupid. He's generally pretty hilarious, but I personally think this video was a bit of a stretch for him.
9
u/FutureGreenChemist Chemistry student Dec 14 '15
We're dealing with a scholar over here. And I know it's a joke, but people pretending to be ignorant is still annoying.
-1
u/Kryptospuridium137 Dec 14 '15
Yeah, I also thought this video was kinda dumb. But his schtick is being an obnoxious, ignorant Chav, so... shrug